Famous Bull Rider Dallas Day met Cassie Bailey briefly in high school, but her plain looks and quiet personality left no lasting impression on him. Cassie, however, couldn't say the same about Dallas. Their paths cross again 10 years later when Dallas is home recovering from an injury, and Cassie is the only veterinarian who volunteers her services at the home-town rodeo. She's jump-starting her new practice, and every eligible man within a 10-mile radius is trying to land a date with the attractive vet.
When Erika's ex becomes her boss less than a year after dumping her by text, she gets desperate to find a date to the corporate Valentine's dance so he doesn't suspect she still has feelings for him. Though not a fan of texting for the obvious reason, she doesn't have much choice but to tap the keypad in order to gain the attention of the only viable candidate from the classified ads. Grayson made the mistake of listening to his brother a year ago and has regretted what he did to Erika ever since. But his brother's next suggestion just might be his salvation.
Jason Haverty is looking forward to the fall horse drive, until his boss and uncle inform him that one of the new cowboys, who is coming to help, will be riding his favorite horse. His annoyance is furthered when the cowboy turns out to be a cowgirl - a quick-witted and confident blonde beauty. Trying to avoid her doesn't work. The more time he spends with her, the more an unexpected protectiveness toward her grows.
When David's grandmother sees how perfect Ellie would be for her grandson, she gathers the troops. She and her three friends form Cupid's Angels. Their mission: to bring David and Ellie together. Despite their best efforts, the Angels' plans backfire, pushing David and Ellie further apart and into the arms of others. Or, so they think.