Ayla, the independent heroine of the Earth's Children series, sets out from the valley on Whinney, the horse she tamed. With her is Jondalar, the tall, handsome, yellow-haired man she nursed back to health and came to love. Together they meet Mamutoi - the Mammoth Hunters - people like Ayla. But to Ayla, who was raised by the Clan of the Cave Bear, they are the "Others". She approaches them with a mixture of fear and curiosity.
It is the Mamutoi master carver of ivory - dark-skinned Ranec, flirtatious, artistic, magnetic - who Ayla finds herself drawn to the most. Because of her uncanny control over animals, her healing skills, and the magic firestone she discovers, Ayla is adopted into the Mammoth Hearth by Mamut, the ancient shaman of the Great Earth Mother.
Ayla finds herself torn between her strong feelings for Ranec and her powerful love for the wildly jealous and unsure Jondalar. It is not until after the great mammoth hunt, when Ayla's life is threatened, that a fateful decision is made.
Listen to more in the Earth's Children series.
©2004 Jean M. Auel; (P)2004 Brilliance Audio
This is the worse book I have ever listened to from Audible. I don't know how any one can give this 4 stars. The narrater is without a doubt the poorest I've ever listened to. If I could return it I would, total waste of my credit. I listen to 2 to 3 books a month and have for years.
I read these novels when they were first published, when I was working towards a BS in Biology. My faculty adviser recommended Book 1. I was young when I first picked up the books in this series, and loved the whole series. I had never read romance novels, so I guess I was naive. Revisiting the series 20 years later, I realize the constant sex scenes are repetitious in the phrases, settings, circumstances, and dialog to the point of being boring, akin to romance novels that fill voids with prurient content. The effort to make each novel "free-standing" is distracting and boring, and shows that the editors think that the reader is so stupid as to not remember, and hope they can make additional profits when the bookstore browser picks up a book in the middle of the series.
Ms. Auel has produced a great work of historical fiction for an era rarely tackled, except in approximation in fantasy novels. I'm sorry she chose to switch genres from historical fiction to romance novel with gratuitous sex and endless reprise.
This book has alot of fasanating historic information and some fun and entertaining adventures. Unfortunately it is hard to stay focused with all of the explanations of oral sex and giant memberss that only one chosen by the cave lion could fully handle. The charactors become riduiculouslsy stupid in the ways of the heart and communication, and the author uses this to write endlessly of inter-racial sex, general bone-headed main charactors, and rexplaning everything from books 1 & 2. This is where I stop listening to these books. I have an internet full of porn if I want sex, sex, sex. I was really enjoying the first books, but this is just silly.
Very frustrating and unnecessarily long. Could have been much better. But the series has a strange fascination with all the Ice Age cultural detail.
I should have payed attention to the other reviews.
This one is a return.
Yes, this one was a bomb.
Yes, I like her work.
A waste of time
Though this is a very good book to have digitally, the narration leaves something to be desired. The pacing is too fast, without adequate pauses between sentences, and you can often hear the changes in pitch when certain sections are sped up or slowed down. It makes it a little stressful to listen. Also, there are several words that the narrator consistently mispronounces. Still, all in all, the content is interesting enough to keep me on the treadmill.
The first two books were good, Clan of the Cave Bear being the strongest of the books so far. This book was horrible. The sex scenes are ridiculous and I kept trying to skip over them. The he said/she said complicated romance and star crossed lovers plot line was just horrible. Without spoilers, it took forever for the main characters to decide what to do next. If I hadn't bought this so long ago, I would want a refund. It is worth reading if you are bored with all of your other audible books, and want something long to listen to. That is the only reason I listened to it again.
Disappointment. The first two books were enjoyable. This book was a total rehash of the first two, and a ton of boring love scenes thrown in.
This book seriously needed a good editor. The constant repetition of the same storyline over and over gets ridiculous!
I can understand a reminder or two from previous books, lots of authors do that, but this author spends a third of the book repeating the same details. I also really dislike that the storyline has spiraled downward from prehistorical fiction to poorly crafted romance novel. I hope this trend doesn't continue.
The narrator is horrible, she sounds like she is reading a child's fairytale book. (Think of a nursery school reading of Momma, Poppa, and Baby Bear's lines.) Her depiction of the voices of nearly everyone in the Lion camp is exactly the same, and all are overenthusiastic caricatures.
I liked Clan of the Cave Bear, and thought The Valley of the Horses had some good parts. This book, however, holds virtually no appeal. I gave it two out of five stars because you might get two hours of entertainment out of each five hours of listening.
I will give the fourth book a try because I'm stubborn about finishing things, but if it reads like this one I am done with this series.
I will not finished this series of books. The first book was really good, the second was good, and the third was a long resume of the first two books. Too many repetitions.
This is a great story, I want to keep reading about Ayla's adventures but I hope the next book doesn't focus so much on the misunderstandings between Ayla and her love interest. I found it frustrating to the point of yelling at the book for keeping the tension stretched over hours and hours of reading. Jondalar isn't so stubborn! Heehehe!
Report Inappropriate Content