From the New York Times best-selling author of Me Before You, a spellbinding love story of two women separated by a century but united in their determination to fight for what they love most
France, 1916: Artist Edouard Lefevre leaves his young wife, Sophie, to fight at the front. When their small town falls to the Germans in the midst of World War II, Edouard's portrait of Sophie draws the eye of the new Kommandant. As the officer's dangerous obsession deepens, Sophie will risk everything - her family, her reputation, and her life - to see her husband again.
Almost a century later, Sophie's portrait is given to Liv Halston by her young husband shortly before his sudden death. A chance encounter reveals the painting's true worth, and a battle begins for who its legitimate owner is - putting Liv's belief in what is right to the ultimate test.
Like Sarah Blake's The Postmistress and Tatiana de Rosnay's Sarah's Key, The Girl You Left Behind is a breathtaking story of love, loss, and sacrifice told with Moyes's signature ability to capture our hearts.
©2013 Jojo Moyes (P)2013 Penguin Audio
Short, Simple, No Spoilers
Beautifully written novel of Sophie, a French wife and her sister left to cook for Germans in occupied Paris in WWI. The portrait painted by Sophie's husband, Edourd, captures a moment when she discovers she loves and desires him for the first time, creating a captivating piece of artwork. As she struggles to stay brave for her family; keep up hope for Edourd; entertain monsters in her own home and place of business; she shows Herculean strength and fights to maintain her spirit and dignity.
Present day Liz, received, "The Girl You Left Behind" as a honeymoon present from her now deceased husband. She calls it her favorite possession and feels a deep connection with Sophie.
Both characters are as different as night and day, disparate, yet intriguing in their own way. When I read books told from two different points of view and time periods, I often find myself liking one more than the other. This was not the case, finally. I couldn't wait to hear Sophie's lilting, lovely French accent and was equally waiting to tag along with British Liz during her quest to move on and hold on to Sophie. Moyes created characters with depth you cared about and relationships you felt with intensity.
One of the best books I've listened to in months. Excellent read, and don't call it chic lit!
I loved the characters Sophie and Liv and how invested I quickly became in their lives
The ending was so dramatic. I was literally holding my breath.
I had listened to the first Jo Jo Moyes and loved it-not sure if same performer, but really enjoyed the performances of these readers.
It did have very sad parts but,also, some very witty dialogue. I really felt like I knew the characters and really cared what happened to them.
I've only read 2 by Jo Jo Moyes, but plan to explore her other books soon
Rating scale: 5=Loved it, 4=Liked it, 3=Ok, 2=Disappointed, 1=Hated it. I look for well developed characters, compelling stories.
The book cover fooled me into expecting a more light weight romantic historical fiction. What I found was a heartbreaking portrait of World War 1 occupation, the complex issues of stolen war property, and the solace that a single portrait provided to two women grieving the loss of their husbands 100 years apart. Told in parallel time lines are the stories of Sophie LeFevre, the subject of the painting by her husband, Edouard, now gone to war, and the current story of Liv Halston, the current owner who received the portrait as a wedding present from her husband, now dead. To both women the portrait is far more than an object – it is the only tangible connection to their husbands whose absence breaks their hearts. Both women must make hard decisions about what they value most and why. Repeated more than once is the line “once it is done, it cannot be undone.”
The characters in both timelines are finely drawn, showing the strength, fear, humor and love all of the characters bring to their relationships. Even the Kommandant is more than just a cardboard villain. The dilemma of ownership of the picture is laid out with balance so that both sides are understandable. The narration was good, although the French reader tended to get overly dramatic with some of her characters. The only weakness was how the ending was written, but I won’t comment further to avoid giving too much away. The story was strong enough to hold my undivided attention over the two days it took to listen, and Sophie in particular has become a literary character I will hold onto for a while.
But not quite. And my issue is tiny enough I can still recommend this book quite highly.
Ms. Moyes does a great job of taking a controversial issue and helping you see it from a fresh perspective. The issue isn't quite as intense as assisted suicide, as she tackled in her most recent book. But it is still polarizing - repatriation of illegally obtained valuables and personal items during a time of war. This book takes a fresh look at the issue and the perspective she crafted was quite ingenious. She takes a step backwards from the more common storyline of evil Nazis and the pillage they committed during World War II and sets the events in motion during World War I.
The story is told from two perspectives, almost 100 years apart. Two women who are terribly different - one who continues to fight and to hope long after everyone around her has stopped and one who seems to have stopped fighting and hoping a long time ago. Through the artwork they share, the strength and righteousness of Sophie gradually becomes imbued in Liv.
The narration was wonderful, especially Sophie's voice. But both narrators performed multiple characters and accents beautifully.
Here is my one tiny complaint. I will try and express it without giving the ending away, but the resolution in Liv's story has one too many last minute reprieves to me. I felt like I was brought to the bring of resolution, only to find out it wasn't once too often.
I finished the book terribly satisfied. It is the 3rd book I've read by this author. I will definitely read another one and I recommend this one highly.
I am an avid "reader"- I prefer to listen to books rather than read them due to the added dimension added by the narrator.
Yes, I have already recommended it numerous times.
I have no books to compare this to. I really enjoyed Me Before You, also by Jo Jo Moyes and having read this, I was propelled to listen to another of her books. I am very fond of her writing style and I love the way she develops her characters.
I always find audiobooks far superior to those I "read". Some feel the complete opposite and would rather use their imaginations to imagine the characters. I personally find voices very helpful in my appreciation of the people in the books I listen to. Often, the accents give me a window into the culture in which the characters are immersed.
I found this very easy to continue to listen to. I could probably have listened all in one sitting if I'd had the time.
I will be seeking out more books by this author. Well done! The only comment I would make is that the ending was a bit predictable but I don't want to give anything away… so listen to the book!
The performances were exceptional, and the story was lovely. I am looking forward to her next book.
Say something about yourself!
Absolutely. There were a lot of characters that came and left throughout the book, as well as fascinating plot twists. To listen again knowing the ending would definitely be worth it!
It was a beautiful love story, just like Me Before You, but couldn't have been more different than Moyes' previous book. I thought she did a great job with historical fiction. The characters faced decisions that were life-changing - nothing black and white - and she worked through them in ways that felt real and believable.
The accents are fantastic and the emotions from their performances were just wonderful.
Yes, absolutely - I would've driven cross-country just to keep listening!
If you loved Me Before You, definitely try this book. Just know going in that they're completely different. JoJo Moyes is a masterful storyteller and I will definitely be watching for her next masterpiece!
Say something about yourself!
I have a lot of comments about a particular character in this book but I will reserve comment so I don't spoil the book for others. I definitely recommend the book. It is engrossing, particularly Part 1. Part 2 started out confusing for me... just the way the author starts... I didn't know what was what... the action just started and I didn't know who was who or what was going on. Finally I sorted everything out. Both narrators are very good. I especially liked the first narrator.
The thing about Jojo Moyes is her stories are all so very different from each other. She (I assume Jojo is a she) has quite the imagination. I love her books. I have listened to all accept one, I believe it is called 'Horse Dancer' or something like that. I plan to listen to it eventually.
Poignant, hopeful, and bittersweet.
Sarah's Key in that the book flows between World War I in this case, and the present day. Both involve fascinating stories in both present and past.
I loved both narrator's as well. They really brought the story to life.
A painting is never just a painting.
One of my favorite listens of all time, just like Sarah's Key was. Loved it!
Wholeheartedly impressed by Jojo Moyes' exceptional "The Girl You Left Behind. Enjoyed narrators as well. The abrupt shift in time and perspective was at first disconcerting, and quite honestly I thought the book ruined, but before long I was engrossed with Olivia's story as I was with Sophie's.
I am frequently frustrated by all the "5 star" book reviews I see in Audible reviews. A book that truly deserves "five stars" rarely comes along. I was sorry to see this one end, but enjoyed it thoroughly.
Full disclosure, it is a bit of "chick lit". I can't wait to read a third book of Ms. Moye's, she is a brilliant, gifted writer.
There are no listener reviews for this title yet.
Report Inappropriate Content