©2005 Richard Montanari; (P)2005 Books on Tape, Inc.
"The Rosary Girls is a well-written, fast-moving thriller with twists and turns galore that will keep you guessing until the end." (Phillip Margolin)
"A relentlessly suspenseful, soul-chilling thriller that hooks you instantly." (Tess Gerritsen)
I was terribly dissapointed by this "cliche"ridden book. In an effort to build suspense, the author over-uses red herrings to the point that he creates characters just to be a red herring, then they dissapear. Coincidences abound. Seems like everybody in the book drives the same car as the killer, several people meet not just some, but all of the characteristics of the killer. To top it all, if the police need to be late to the scene to build suspense, traffic jams magically appear. The killer abducts girls in broad daylight, in busy areas, and nobody ever sees him. There is even a "dark and stormy night". The police are so inept that I found myself wanting to yell: "Don't lay down your weapon before you go into the dark basement'you idiot!" Not believable.
This is perhaps my favorite audiobook so far. It has a complex plot, likeable characters, and offers great insight into the mind of a serial killer. The last two hours are unequaled in suspense. It's been a long time since I've been frightened by a book; this one does the job in aces. Also, once again, Scott Brick rules! It's as if he is living the book as he reads it. The Rosary Girls couldn't be better.
I am now on book #4 in this series, and I tend to be stingy with stars. First off, let's take care of the category. Some reviewers cry "not believable". Sure, but these books are not about solving crimes with dogged police work. Again...these are not police procedurals. Yes, they have crimes at their core, but only to hang the many characters, the twisted plot, the parallel story lines, and the suspense on. Think Charlie Huston meets David Koontz (some clues even come to our heroes psychically through Byrne's battered brain). Few of us would complain about the lack of "believability" in many of the movies we see; it's a movie--pure fantasy.
Yes, there are the cliches of Jessica Balzano, tough female detective who boxes, and her tough but much damaged (natch) older male partner Kevin Byrne, both of whose main vulnerabilies are their children, and their good hearts. In each book so far, Balzano and Byrne, regularly find themselves (or their friends and loved ones) at great physical risk, and in very tight life-threatening spots which require miraculously well-timed rescues. And yes, as a number of reviewers have pointed out, Montanari's writing seems to be of the school of "Why use two or three words when an entire paragraph, or better yet, a long interior monologue will do--we can just suspend the intense action for a few minutes". But hey, for those of us who can enjoy highly fictionalized crime thrillers replete with melodrama, Montanari does it quite well, and with a more than reasonable command of the English language, which is not always the case at this level of literature. All of the above add up to why it was brilliant to use Scott Brick to narrate these books (so far). As one reviewer remarked, he could make the phone book sound dramatic. Montanari's and Brick's styles are a pitch perfect match.
There is some violence, and the crimes are gory even though we are not usually present when they are committed. The language is medium; what you'd expect in an adult cop story. The unfortunate part of this series is that if you get hooked, and if you get to numbers 5 and 6, not only are they not available on Audible, they are also not available as ebooks on either B&N or Amazon. And, in fact I can only find hard copies of them in two places in US; most are from UK. The last(?) two, 7 and 8, are here at Audible. Go figure.
I liked the plot and characters of this book. Had some real excitement and unique "murders". Only had two small annoyances, the reader had such a gravelly voice that took some getting used to but never really felt right and the author threw in some "copspeak" lingo that wasn't familiar and felt ostentatious and was unnecessary. Would recommend this to anyone.
Always enjoy Scott Brick, my favorite reader. This is my first book by this author and I certainly plan on reading more. Excellent book,
nice twists and turns. Great character development. Highly recommend!
I found this book, because I listen to all books read by Scott Brick. Well, having been born and bred in a small suburb outside of Phila....what a treat this book was! For me, the city of Phila became a character in this book and I loved that I could actually visualize the settings, because for the most part, I had actually been there at one time or another. But fear not, even if you are not a Philly native, this story's great, and Scott Brick as always is AMAZING! I found the story so intriguing, I went out and bought the hardcover for my husband who could not put it down.
This book seems to me to be a writer pretending that he is an author. Did all of his friends write reviews? It is an overly inflated plot with sinister dum-de-dum-dees. I generally like Scott Brick, but even he couldn't entertain me with his pious reading of evil intentions. The police, newspaper guys, lab people are all seedy and less than admirable. Not good at all! Everyone has different tastes, but what are they thinking in giving so many stars?
I read most of the positive reviews before buying this audiobook and unfortunately, I would have to agree with the one negative review I saw. Not only is it riddled with cliches, I found the prose overly dramatic and wordy. At times throughout listening I experienced deja vous - the author borrows ideas from stronger writers and changes them just enough to hide them from the casual reader. I wonder if he's a big fan of Thomas Harris.
I actually rolled my eyes and groaned out loud at one point near the end. Still, I have to admit I did finish the book (can not say that about all of my purchases on this site), if only to enjoy the rollercoaster of prose. (see? His melodramatic way of writing is rubbing off)
Yes, the characters are complex. I like that Burns is not your ordinary detective. This book had a lot of twists and the end had me at the edge of my seat.
Maybe similar to the John Lutz novel, only because both killers are twisted however "the rosary girls" can stand on its own as creepy.
I can't say enough about Scott Brick, he could read me the dictionary. I chose this book because Scott was the narrator and I'm delighted to see he is the voice for the rest of the series. I will be listening to the second book in this series next.
****SPOILER***** The ending in the basement during the storm was intense. That's all I'm going to say.
Great book, I highly recommend it.
Good listen, not teriffic or seat gripping, but middle of the road. Won't ask for my credit back anyway. Scott Brick is one of my favorite narrators but I found him a little slow and melodramatic in the reading which made me shut it off a couple of times. Its a good filler if your having trouble finding an amazing book.
I have my favourite crime authors (Lehane, Coben, Crais, Connelly) but had exhausted all their books and was desperate to find a new author to enjoy. Step forward, Richard Montanari!
I actually listened to the third book in the series before listening to this, the first in the series. Like his other books, this moves along at a cracking pace with a couple of nice sub-plots and chock-ful of likely suspects. Never yet guessed the perp before the denouement, though. Always the sign of a good author!
And the two main characters are very well-rounded and their personalities develop with each book
If I have any criticism, it is that all his villains are always devilishly clever which gets a little formulaic after you've read several books.
However, that apart, I strongly recommend this book to all fans of Amercian crime fiction. His latest is already on my wishlist
Report Inappropriate Content