Investigate more mysterious doings with Lily Bard.
©1997 Charlaine Harris Schulz; (P)2009 Recorded Books, LLC
"Lily Bard is a complex woman who embodies many of the contradictions of the modern South - its dark side as well as its charm - and this suspenseful, deftly written novel will send new fans scrambling to read its predecessor." (Amazon.com review)
Love books! Classics and lighter fiction, mysteries (not too violent please :-). And selective non-fiction--whatever takes my fancy.
In general, I have liked the two books about Lily Bard, a woman who is a survivor of heinous crimes in her past, who has moved to the little town of Shakespeare to start her life over. Some of the same characters are here--the chief of police, the people from her gym, her lover. I rather enjoyed the first one. This, not so much--but it's not exactly because of the book (I don't think). It's because I personally prefer a series that has more cerebral interest than fast-paced action (here, often resulting in multiple injuries). I suspect many would enjoy this story more than I did.
I gave this book 4 stars instead of the 3 that would more accurately account for how I viewed it, to account for my own taste here. But another part of my frustration with it is that Lily keeps putting herself into such avoidable situations. I know that's what makes the story move, but then I just sit with disbelief that she, for example, could be seriously beaten up one day and show up to work as a cleaning woman the next! Most human bodies could not manage such a feat!
I really like Lily Bard, the character. She has a painful history and is showing courage in her attempts to restart her life. This particular book deals with people who are unable to accept that their southern town is integrated, and are secretly promoting pre-civil rights attitudes, and view the local African Americans as their enemy. It is sad to be reminded that such things do still happen, and I believe the author was trying to bring attention to a problem that still exists in our society.
But I just didn't enjoy this book as much as the first--and it was largely because I found it hard to suspend disbelief at some of the actions that took place. Too much of the story was filled with a long chain of various physical fights & encounters--that people couldn't realistically have recovered from fast enough to keep doing more of the same. If that's your cup of tea, you'll give this story 5 stars. Despite that this is not my reading taste exactly, I did find it hard to stop listening till the end. It is compelling in that way.
Published poet/author, retired public school science teacher, classical dance educator/choreographer, editor, illustrator and avid reader/Audible fan.
Just when you thought you had it figured out...it took a turn to the unexpected.
Lilly herself is my favorite character as she is smart...never stops looking at life as a puzzle to solve, fights her demons and from the shadows solves the mystery in a tiny little town where everyone knows everyone else except the hidden heart within Lily.
My favorite scene happened when Lily let her guard down and accepted a mysterious "dectective" into her life.
Oh yes and I did!
I enjoy all of Charlaine Harris' series, except for Stackhouse (I don't do vampires!), and have never been let down. They're cozies, but with a bit more edge. I'll be sorry when I finish the two of the Lily Bard series I have left. Interesting characters, interesting premise, straight forward story, and some sex without turning into a romance.
Life-long reader, 10 years listening
I like LIly Bard and the stories of her life in the small-town South of Shakespeare, Arkansas. In this book, Lily is in the wrong place at the wrong time on several occasions, all for very good and unrelated reasons, but it nearly gets her killed. We meet Jack, who will become a big part of her life, and who also finds himself in far greater danger than he expected when he took his in this little town.
Julia Gibson does a decent job of reading the story, but I think somehow her very level voice takes some of the excitement out of the book (I read it before listening, a couple of years ago). The some of the events that take place are quite exciting, but you wouldn't know it from just listening to the sound levels.
Really good story, meh reading. I give this a 3.5, taking off a half-point or so for the reader.
I, as many others, am a huge fan of Sookie Stackhouse's series. Not so much for the sensational world it was in but because it took the fantasy to paint a very clear picture of humanity. While this series is nothing like Sookie and definitely not as addictive...Charlaine Harris has the uncanny ability of making you feel like you are literally the main character in a very realistic way. My hats off to her because she is once again showing the ugly and the beauty of people in it's true, uncoated form.
I kind of liked the first book in this series so I decided to try another one. I regret doing it. I could barely stomach the narrator for starters. She wasn't necessarily horrible. I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt that she just isn't my cup of tea. Having said that.... it may just be that it was a poor choice of narrator's for this particular book. I'm not sure. I just know that the more she droned on the less I liked the characters. It became nails on a chalkboard to me.
Also, I really just don't get the author's obsession with body image. It actually trickles into all of her books if I really think about it, but in this book she's specifically talking about a body building. I happen to know a bit about the body building industry and I think she just should have done her homework or written about something she actually knows about.
Lily Bard has zero redeeming qualities as a main character. All of these men think she's hot, etc., but there is really nothing to indicate that she is. She's apparently in shape, as Charlaine Harris constantly goes on about, but it sounds like she dresses like somewhat of a slob and hardly ever puts effort into her appearance (other than going to the gym constantly, where she also dresses like a slob). She's rude to pretty much everyone she encounters and lacks anything resembling a sense of humor. There are parts of the book where I actually thought "Wait, that might have been funny," but the narrator just passed right over it so who knows?
I'm stopping this series and I won't be getting another book from this narrator. Additionally, no one has this much bad luck. I understand that it's fiction, but give me a break.
A total disappointment even if you have loved Charlaine Harris in the past.
i love this series, second one as good as first. Charlaine Harris always delivers an action packed tale. I'm never bored. I love that Lily is strong, but her scars, inside and out, make her vulnerable as well as cautious. And she is not dumb. She thinks things through and can keep her mouth shut.
I'm a huge Charlaine Harris fan, so I thought I'd give this series a try. I've always believed that one may not have an opinion until she has read/heard an entire book series, but even though I've purchased all four books, I will NOT be continuing. What a horribly boring and idiotic main character! She keeps getting herself in the most ridiculous situations which are so obviously avoidable and none of her business! The story-line is equally boring and ridiculous. I not only would like my money back, but my precious time! You're so much better than this, Ms. Harris!
I went right on to this after finishing the first in the series because I was dying to know what happened next with this character. There is a strong theme of racial tension in this book, which is not my favorite topic and I do I think Harris is stronger writing white characters, however none of that stopped me from enjoying the book. There is a lot more action in this installment than in the previous book. One thing I didn't really understand was why the author chose to do the prologue the way she did. I think it gave us too much of the upcoming story, taking out a lot of the mystery of the mystery. Additionally, it wasn't my favorite mystery since although the motive is one that certainly occurs in real life, I prefer something more personal and complex. Still, I enjoyed the Lily character, and in each of the books we see an interesting development in her character.
Report Inappropriate Content