©2007 PD James; (P)2009 Random House Audio
"A superb detective novel....and a gift to all readers." (USA Today)
"Glitters with the high-gloss anxiety of a first-rate detective novel, but it goes beyond that fine achievement to another realm . . . An intricate, compassionate novel." (The Boston Globe)
Ok, this was a classic PD James book; beautifully written, lots of very nice psychological details; lots and lots of descriptions; and a good mystery to boot. Would have rated it 5 stars but I found myself wanting the author to get on with the story and therefore lighten up on the descriptions and the psychological details. So, what makes this book great, also made it lag. Perhaps I have become impatient lately because of the more americanized detective stories I have been reading as of late. But, if you want to spend a lot of time on one very well written and detailed murder mystery, this is it. Oh, and I liked PD James' little self portrait which she placed in the book towards the end. . . or I wanted to think it was her, anyway.
Long and slow in parts, but if you like other PD James books, you'll like this one. It's very character driven, which I like. Good story, but the end is a bit unsatisfying and out of nowhere.
Loved reading this book and listening too. In fact, listening really brings out the author's poetic, moving words. Great characters starting with Dalglish and Kate. Wonderful voice with great range that makes each character distinctive.
I always enjoy P. D. James. She brings out flaws in human nature we all have on some level in her characters,
Very disappointed. Did not like narration. Her voice grated on my nerves.I am a huge fan of p. D James but this one missed the mark.
I have GOT to remember to write down this narrator, she has a whinny British accent that drives me insane....hard to keep up with the story when it has such a horrid voice attached. I am wishing there was a refund on my credits when something is so horrid....I listen to several audios a week and never have I had such a hard time listening - wasted 2 credits and will not be able to go past the first of 3 parts....
cannot make it to the ending due to narrator.
NO AND OH HELL NO
another narrator would have helped
wasted 2 credits, should have listened to the sample but I have NEVER had this problem before.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.