Nonagenarian Jacob Jankowski reflects back on his wild and wondrous days with a circus. It's the Depression Era and Jacob, finding himself parentless and penniless, joins the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth. There he meets the freaks, grifters, and misfits that populate this world. Jacob introduces us to Marlena, beautiful star of the equestrian act; to August, her charismatic but twisted husband (and the circus' animal trainer); and to Rosie, a seemingly untrainable elephant.
Beautifully written, with a luminous sense of time and place, Water for Elephants tells of love in a world in which love's a luxury few can afford.
©2006 Sara Gruen; (P)2006 HighBridge Company
"Water for Elephants resembles stealth hits like The Giant's House, by Elizabeth McCracken, or The Lovely Bones, by Alice Sebold, books that combine outrageously whimsical premises with crowd-pleasing romanticism. . . . With a showman's expert timing, [Gruen] saves a terrific revelation for the final pages, transforming a glimpse of Americana into an enchanting escapist fairy tale.” (New York Times Book Review)
"Just like a circus, the magic of the story and the writing convince you to suspend your disbelief." (Booklist)
"Gruen skillfully humanizes the midgets, drunks, rubes, and freaks who populate her book." (Publishers Weekly)
I can find a book to love in any genre -- a beautifully written classic, an interesting mystery or sci-fi, a trashy romance. Bring it!
STORY (historical fiction) - Water for Elephants is an award-winning book and has been made into a popular movie, so I know I'm in the minority with my review. Parts of the book were very enjoyable, but most of the time my mind was wandering and I was looking at the time counter to see how much longer before I could start a new book. It paints what is probably a historically correct view of circus life in the Depression era -- sleeping in train cars and traveling from town to town. It is interesting to a certain point, but IMHO the story kind of just meanders from day to day with too much downtime between important events.
The main character is Jacob, the veterinarian, and the story is told through the use of two different timelines. One timeline is Jacob present day when he is an old man in a nursing home, grumbling about the food and dreaming of his life as a young man in the circus. The second is the story of Jacob's unplanned entry into circus life and his viewpoint of what he finds there. Each timeline is read by a different narrator, so it's easy to follow as you go back and forth.
There is the expected cast of circus characters, but the three main ones in this story are Jacob, a beautiful horse/elephant rider and her schizophrenic husband. There are some ugly exchanges between various characters, some animal abuse which is a hard to hear and a stripper who puts on a pretty bizarre show. Then there is a romance that trancends decades. You will feel afraid, angry, happy and sad. The ending is unexpected and very good.
PERFORMANCE - Both narrators did well, but the one reading the older version did an outstanding job of conveying Jacob's various emotions - frustration, anger, love, etc., as he relived some of his memories.
OVERALL - Some violence and foul language, but not a lot. Some animal cruelty and sexual content.
This book is simply written. There is no depth. The dialog is lacking. The characters are shallow. I cannot imagine where there positive reviews are comming from. The reader for the younger character is almost intolerable.
It is a nice story. I think it would be nice as a bedtime story minus the inappropriate content. Or maybe written by a different author. A children's book? Its just such a light, simple read.
This was a very good story. Part romance, part coming of age, I was drawn in pretty quickly and found myself immersed in the world of a depression era circus. I appreciate a story that is able to clearly present the reader with a sense of it's time and place and this story does a great job of depicting this world of which I knew very little. It was easy to become immersed in this world. The characters were very well done and easy to care about. My reasons for not rating this story higher are twofold. First, I think a major problem for me was having seen the movie beforehand. The movie did a very nice job with the adaptation and followed the story very closely, it is definitely worth watching. My issue was with the character of August, who is the villain of the story, and the narrator's portrayal. The book has 2 narrators as the story is set up as a flashback of sorts so we go between Jacob at 93 and Jacob as a young man. The elder Jacob was fantastic and really made me feel for the character. The other narrator did a fine job with other characters and Jacob, but his voice for August was very nasal and off-putting. I think I was spoiled by having seen Christoph Waltz as the character in the movie. Part of what is interesting about this character as a villain is that he can be very charming and likeable but can change to anger and cruelty at a moments notice. Waltz was so good in the movie, but the narrator just did not get that aspect of the character across for me and so it made the story a bit less enjoyable because this character was not quite as interesting as in the movie. My second issue was with the animal cruelty. Being a circus and the Great Depression, animals were treated very poorly and there were several terrible instances of violence towards animals, mostly from August. Jacob, who was studying to become a veterinarian, is of course as appalled as the reader, but he is powerless to do anything throughout most of the story. Much violence is inflicted against the circus' elephant, Rosie, who was such a lovely character and it was very heartbreaking to listen to. So, potential readers, be cautioned. This is a story worth listening too, but you may find it difficult at times. I had to snuggle my kitties a lot after listening. They didn't seem to mind, though!
I focus on fiction, sci-fi, fantasy, science, history, politics and read a lot. I try to review everything I read.
This is a fine book, with a pleasant story and some nice characters. I particularly liked the ending and the narration was superior without being perfect. The settings for the story were mildly interesting and It was a very easy listen. Given the many great reviews I hoped for a wonderful and magical listen. This it was not. It was a nice modern novel, but for me that was it. The characters sometimes verged on almost becoming really interesting but then the scene ended, they never got me to laugh or cry, or even care very much.
The narration was spectacular and really sold the book. The story was made complete through the older gentleman re-telling his years on the circus. I cried within the first 30 minutes.
I would've liked more depth in the characters and the plot. It seemed for the most part one dimensional and as much as I enjoyed the older man, the story didn't really make me root for his younger self or his relationship with Marlina.
The elderly man. He made me laugh, cry, feel angry and sad for how some treat their seniors. But that one character kept me listening.
I liked how the elderly man made it to the circus and the end result of that. I also enjoyed his friendship his bunkmate and the dog.
I thought the beginning was really moving and grasped my attention, but then near the end of the story there were pieces at the plot that I didn't like and thought could have been developed more. I think the book is worth listening to. It is pretty short, the narration is great, but afterwards I'm left wanting a bit more...
Composer, reader, hommus eater
This is beautifully performed, and it's a mammoth work so the two performers did excellently to keep pace.
However: the book itself has some holes in it. Firstly, it gets monotonous. It's sort of two toned the whole way - even in the high action part, the circus story part, it has this sort of one-dimensional 'main character does something naughty- lots of swearing occurs - bad stuff happens' cycle which leaves you waiting for something to happen - and when the climax of action does happen, you're left feeling a bit hollow because it just feels very similar to everything that's happened before.
Also, the women aren't written particularly well, which is kind of odd coming from a female author (sexism, much Helen? Oh dear.) No really, in all honesty I wanted the lady characters to have bit more nous than this sort of flimsy damsel in distress feel that might be typical of an early 20th century pulp novel but really has no place in 21st century dramatic realist literature.
There are some beautifully profound moments by the old guy though, which I found really touching, and thought provoking too.
But seriously Gruen, step up your women characters!
Whether human or pachyderm, loyalty is the essence of the story. Great characters from the dwarf to the hobo to the enforcer. It was heart warming, especially at the end.
Both narrators did an exceptional job with this book, and it was mostly because of them that I bothered finishing it. I cannot say anything bad about their narrations - some of the best I've heard. Their exceptional performances were wasted on such bad writing, however.
The main story was simplistic, dull, and predictable. The characters were flat and completely lacked chemistry. This was especially true for Marlena, wh, as far as I could tell possessed no personality whatsoever aside from being a helpless, beautiful woman married to an evil, evil man and in need of saving. The young Jacob was likewise dull and also selfish, with very few redeeming qualities outside his bilingual abilities.
That said, the flashes forward to the old Jacob in the nursing home were truly inspired and moving. A couple of times tears came to my eyes as I remembered my own grandfather. It was difficult to reconcile that the same author who wrote these lovely, moving, nuanced segments of an old man abandoned by his family, health failing, was also responsible for the mind-numbing drivel of the circus segments - the main plot of the story. In fact, it seemed to me that the two were so disjointed in tone, voice - everything really - that they were like two separate stories (of differing quality) thrown together.
If you enjoy excellent narration, this book is worth checking out, but be warned - the story itself is mostly annoying, badly written drivel.
I can honestly say I haven't enjoyed a book so much in years. The narration was INCREDIBLE, I loved how it switched between the voices of Jacob at 23 and at 93.
An excellent read. You won't be disappointed.
The narration was lovely and I would listen to another book from either man. Sara Gruen thought up a great story, but some parts fell flat, and some characters were not well developed, ie Marlena.
Yes, I did enjoy it, especially the parts of the book told from the older man's viewpoint.
"Water for Elephants"
Both strangely exotic and nostalgically familiar, this tale of tenderness found in the harsh reality of circus life and enduring love stolen from cruelty is captivating and entrancing. Told through the eyes and voices of an old timer and his younger self, it flips from past to present and back again with ease and manages to bring two stories together with equal strength and interest. A beautiful story that is beautifully read by the narrators.
I listened to this for a second time when I had exhausted my new supply while away.
And it was just as enthralling as the first listen.
Brilliantly written and wonderfully read by the two readers.
I can't recommend it highly enough - one of the best audibles I've listened to.
"A true love story"
A true love story written to thrive in the 21st Centry, from the charactors to the plot line its well written and addictive.........
"The film does not even get close."
I could not put this book down.
I remember exactly where I was when things happened in this book.
The character of the old man is explored to the fullest extend, this character made the story, and was completely overlooked in the film version.
Perfect for a holiday, or summer commutes, as I did.
Unusual subject and not one I would normally choose. It made me laugh and cry. Brilliant. Do read it
I wasn't sure if I was going to like this audiobook when I started listening to it as I found the hopping between the current and past a little hard going and the older person's voice difficult to understand at times. But, I'm glad I perservered with it. The story is very original and draws you in. Worth a listen
"Wonderfully engaging Big Top Book"
This book tells the story of a young man thrown into the life of a circus worker after his parents are killed. The wonderful transition between times takes the listening into two very different but equally compelling settings. Brilliant !!
"Great Original Story"
Great to read an original book for a change. I knew nothing about the american circus trains, and now I do! Takes place during the American Depression. The love story is a bit lame but otherwise a terrific listen.
"I Loved it!"
A really enjoyable listen, on a par with 'The Help'. This has been one of those books I couldn't wait to get back to; it was really well structured and well read, I was thoroughly entertained the whole way through. I highly recommend this audiobook.
"Enjoyed every single second …."
It left me wanting more…. I did not want the story to end. I laughed and cried. This is a tale simply told, an account that was both funny & sad, on times illustrating the cruelty inherent in some human beings and the goodness of others. The narration was outstanding, it brought the wonderful characters to life and I could really see them through ‘Jacobs’ eyes. It also made me think about the value we place on our elderly population. Can’t wait to watch the film, hope it lives up to the book.
There are no listener reviews for this title yet.
Report Inappropriate Content