The Iliad, the first of Homer's epic poems, tells of the counsel of Nestor, Achilles's slaying of Hector, and the defeat of the Trojans by the Greeks.
In The Odyssey, in his perilous journey home after the Trojan War, Odysseus must pass through the land of the Cyclopes, encounter Circe the Enchantress, and face the terrible Charybdis and the six headed serpent Scylla.
Both epics are translated here by Samuel Butler.
(P)2002 Commuters Library
The story for those who like such a classic is fabulous. I wont go into story details as most know the story and other reviews have hashed it out. This type of read isnt for everyone but for people into the more flamboyant classic writings, Homer is wonderful.The narrator I feel did an absolutely fabulous job. This isnt an easy book to narrate and he did it with clarity, great pronunciation, and gave a poetic and enjoyable audio for the story and its characters. His voice was pleasant and it felt like he was telling the story rather than reading the story. I have read the Iliad and the Odyssey before but to have it told to you really brings a life to the story thats even more enjoyable than reading it. Some stories are better told than read and this is one of them especially when you have as a good of a Narrator as John Lescault.
I always liked Achilles in the Iliad. His persona just stands out. He is a character that appears larger than life at times. He is stubborn, bold, determined, yet emotions cut to the quick at times.Odysseus in the Odyssey. His journey was one of many trials and tribulations but he prevailed.
He did them all very well. I cant pick just one.
Yes but it was to long to do that. LOL I listened to it every chance I had and it was done in about 1 week.
Reading the reviews I was a little concerned having purchased this prior to reading them. I enjoyed it and was not bothered by the narrating. The narrator can be monotone but I felt he was easy to follow and switched voices to distinguish between characters.
This reckording is at first quite hard to concentrate on. the story can be confusing and the gnarrator monotonic. after a while the listening gets easier although still requiring a good bit of concentration but the story is delivered in a style that makes you believe that that's how it was so
many years ago.
Overall the books are good reads, but the narration is rough. I thought The Iliad was harder to listen to than the Odyssey, but maybe it was just me getting used to the narrator in the second book.
I enjoy counter-terrorism, westerns, historical fiction, detective mysteries, and old school comedy like "A Christmas Story".
Isn't this considered one of the 100 greatest books of all time? What does that say for my self esteem? Normally a great book which starts off boring gets better after you have gotten past the first 25 percent of the piece. When does this one get interesting? Maybe it is a joy for people with photographic memories but I don't have one. It feels like a hundred different characters(mortals, gods, half gods, deformed half mortal/half animals) were introduced for me to digest in the first five hours. I'm determined to revisit and try to finish this "classic" but no way do I recommend unless you crave violent incomprehensible plots.
I've always been curious about these books and it satisfied my curiosity. The Odyssey had more of a story. The Iliad was mostly about fighting which does not interest me at all.
Given the characters simpler names in order to keep track of them. These names were probably simpler in his day.
Hector. Even though he was a brutal warrier, he had a soft side.
No. Many sessions
Worthwhile in the sense of learning (or reminding myself) about Greek mythology and history. But both The Iliad and the Odyssey were written as oral history/ballads, and as such Homer calls out every single character and his/her lineage. It's a bit much. His prose is highly repetitive and there is not much that the narrator can do to make it an enticing listen.
Having had four years of Latin in high school I should have remembered how ponderous the works seem in translation.
Pleasant, a bit bored (hard to make much of Homer), dogged.
some entusiasm and effort
Hunger Games- again
The guy was boring- I could not follow
Just the narrator!!!
While this book is considered literary classic, the narrator leaves much to be desired. The up & down volume is a distraction! I want this selection in my library, only because I am a true fan of the classics.
The narrator reminds me of an electronic voice companies used to use to repeat numbers. I have never read these books, but the pace of the reading puts me to sleep. I am sure the books are better than the impression I now have of them, but I will probably never read them now.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.