Walter Covell’s low, velvet voice speaks the introduction to this novel, which predicts that the listener "will sink back among the cushions of your armchair...and lay the blame of your insensitivity upon the writer". The writer is Honorè de Balzac, early French master and chronicler of French life after the fall of Napoleon Bonaparte.
Covell’s excellent French pronunciations add an air of legitimacy and paint an aural picture of Balzac’s detailed portrait of a time and a people. The listener will revel in the intertwined power dynamics of Père Goriot, an aged father; a mysterious criminal named Vaurtin; a ruthless social climber named Rastignac; and most of all in the precise and exacting descriptions for which Balzac is still so highly esteemed. Ready your armchair.
The novel was written when Balzac's genius was at its height and when the his physical powers were not as yet impaired by his enormous labor and reckless disregard for his health. The history of Goriot and his daughters, the fortunes of Eugene, and the mysterious work of Vautrin, not only receive due and unperplexed development, but work upon each other with correspondence and interdependence that forms the rarest gift of the novelist. Nowhere else is Balzac's charm presented in a more pervading and satisfactory manner than in this novel.
This text was translated by Ellen Marriage.
©1994 Jimcin Recordings
This is an old books on tape reading with a very rough and ready fellow reading without rehearsal and often at cross purposes to a character's sentiments. One actually hears him slowing down when encountering difficult passages. In the final scene, when the eponymous character is raving in agony and psychological turmoil, the reader performs as though Goriot were a shopkeeper who had been asked his opinion about the most recent recession. The story is good, but the translation is so wooden that the characters read like emotionally challenged robots.
Balzac, French author early 19th century, was the father of realism and "Pere Goriot" is one of his masterpieces (he wrote over 90 novels). Oscar Wilde said of Balzac that he created the 19th century. Sadly, the English translation used for this reading is from the 19th century and is a very poor translation. I listned to %25 and gave up in a dispair of incomprehension and bought the Norton Critical Edition, a recent and aclaimed translation that captures the essence of Balzac. Recommend the book highly.
Having just finished Les Miserables which I loved, I thought I'd go for another old French book. Well I hated Pere Goriot. Listened to 2 1/2 hours and then gave up. Lots of characters and Balzac TELLS you about them. He does not show you their character by describing their lives (as Hugo does so memorably). And therefore there is not much dialogue. All the characters jumbled together for me and in the end I just didn't care.
"King Lear meets the French Novel"
Tremendous tale of woe as Goriot's daughters display utter lack of feeling as they exploit their father's love.
A picture of the preoccupations of 19th century France and the development of Rastignac from innocent youth from the country to would-be city sophiticate. How does his integrity survive the temptations of worldly success?
Walter Covell's reading is, sadly, desultory at times which spoils the atmosphere which Balzac creates so masterfully.
"Weak reading spoils a complex story"
Pere Goriot offers fascinating insights into social turmoil in early 19th Century France. Balzac's "realist" style contributes to great descriptions of life at various levels of French society and the venality of its citizens. It's a pretty bleak indictment of institutions such as marriage and none of the characters have any redeeming features. It's supposed to be based on King Lear but there's no Cordelia! The reading is quite weak and the dialogue comes across as wooden.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.