In fact, by assuming the powers we associate with the role of commander in chief, Lincoln often overstepped the narrow band of rights granted the president. Good thing too, because his strategic insight and will tofight changed the course ofthe war and saved the Union.
For most of the conflict, he constantly had to goad his reluctant generals toward battle, and he oversaw strategyand planning for major engagements with the enemy. Lincoln was a self-taught military strategist (as he wasa self-taught lawyer), which makes his adroit conduct of the war seem almost miraculous. To be sure, the Union's campaigns often went awry, sometimes horribly so, but McPherson makes clear how the missteps arose from the all-too-common moments when Lincoln could neither threaten nor cajole his commanders tofollow his orders.
As we approach the bicentennial of Lincoln's birth in 2009, this work provides a genuinely novel, even timely, view of the most written about figure in our history. Tried by War offers a revelatory portrait of leadership duringthe greatest crisis our nation has ever endured. How Lincoln overcame feckless generals, fickle public opinion, and his own paralyzing fears is a story at once suspenseful and inspiring.
©2008 James M. McPherson; (P)2008 Penguin Audiobooks
This book is very well-researched and -written, but it read quite a bit like a condensed version of Battle Cry of Freedom. McPherson does focus differently in the two books, but his treatment is still very similar in both. Perhaps because I read the two books back to back, I felt that McPherson might have benefited from a more analytical, and less narrative/episodic approach to the question of Lincoln's role as CINC. Regardless, it is still a very good book and better than most Civil War histories you will read. Despite my quibbles, I enjoyed it and will likely return to it again in the future.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.