This episode examines the late-19th-century Society for Psychical Research through its key figures—Henry Sidgwick, Frank Podmore, Frederic W.H. Myers, Edmund Gurney, and future filmmaker G.A. Smith—focusing on the intersection of psychical research, early psychology, personal ambition, and scandal. It revisits Smith's early career as a mesmerist and telepath whose performances with journalist Douglas Blackburn led to paid work and prestige within the Society, before Blackburn's flawed 1911 confession cast doubt on their experiments and the Society's credibility. Central to this controversy are Podmore's belief in telepathy despite his skepticism toward mediums, Myers' influential but controversial theories of the subliminal mind and survival after death, and Gurney's crucial contributions to psychology and hallucination research, later marginalized due to psychology's rejection of its occult roots. The episode culminates in the mysterious 1888 death of Gurney following the critical failure of Phantasms of the Living, exploring competing theories of suicide versus accidental chloroform overdose amid professional humiliation, personal betrayal, and mental illness. Despite internal conflicts and public criticism, the Society continued to shape early psychology, while Smith—after Gurney's death and his own departure from the Society—returned to theatrical spectacle and soon helped pioneer cinema, carrying the intellectual, ethical, and imaginative tensions of psychical research into the emerging medium of film.

Check out our website at https://www.rhapsodyin35mmpodcast.com/ and subscribe so you don't miss a new posting. Please make sure to follow us on the social media platform of your choice (or all of them!) Rate and comment so more people can find us. See the blog post for credits: https://www.rhapsodyin35mmpodcast.com/post/ep-6-remixed-murder-mystery-g-a-smith-and-the-society-for-psychical-research Until next time!

The episode traces how Victorian-era beliefs in mesmerism, spiritualism, and psychical research—emerging from a period when science, medicine, religion, and spectacle were not yet clearly separated—profoundly shaped popular culture and early horror cinema. Beginning with Franz Anton Mesmer's theory of animal magnetism and its highly theatrical, trance-inducing treatments, the episode shows how mesmerism blurred the line between scientific inquiry, performance, and charlatanism, influencing the development of hypnotism and modern psychology while captivating the public imagination. Spiritualism, imported from the United States through figures like the Fox Sisters and fueled by mass death during the American Civil War, offered comfort, challenged religious orthodoxies threatened by Darwinism, and aligned itself with progressive causes such as abolition and women's rights, even as it was exploited by frauds like spirit photographers. Intellectuals and scientists—including Alfred Russel Wallace and members of the Society for Psychical Research—debated the legitimacy of these phenomena, splitting believers from skeptics and exposing both genuine inquiry and spectacular deception. Within this cultural milieu, early filmmakers such as George Albert Smith, himself deeply involved in mesmerism, hypnotism, and psychical circles, translated spiritualist imagery—ghosts, rapping spirits, mind control, and apparitions modeled on spirit photography—into cinema, often comedically rather than horrifically, yet establishing visual and narrative conventions that would later define horror. Ultimately, the episode argues that Victorian struggles over belief, authority, class, gender, and scientific legitimacy created the conceptual and aesthetic foundations for the horror genre long before it was formally recognized as such.

Check out our website at https://www.rhapsodyin35mmpodcast.com/ and subscribe so you don't miss a new posting. Please make sure to follow us on the social media platform of your choice (or all of them!) Rate and comment so more people can find us. See the blog post for credits: https://www.rhapsodyin35mmpodcast.com/post/ep-5-remixed-mesmerizing-spiritualism-and-the-beginnings-of-director-g-a-smith Until next time!

Although horror may seem easy to identify, early cinema complicates genre classification because it lacked many formal tools—such as sound, editing techniques, close-ups, and artificial lighting—while emerging alongside an already well-established literary and theatrical tradition of horror and the supernatural. Using Georges Méliès' work as a case study, the episode argues that many early "magical," "phantasmagoric," or "trick" films are often misidentified as horror simply because they feature dark imagery like skeletons, bugs, decapitation, or death, when in fact their tone, mood, and character reactions signal comedy or spectacle rather than fear. Drawing on Ann Radcliffe's distinction between terror and horror, the author emphasizes that genre depends not on subject matter alone but on intent, atmosphere, and audience identification with characters—elements communicated through performance and tone rather than narrative complexity in early film. Méliès' trick films such as The Vanishing Lady, A Terrible Night, and The Four Troublesome Heads function primarily as spectacle or comic demonstrations of cinematic illusion, with the "trick" itself forming the narrative arc and no real emotional stakes for characters. Similarly, later films like Mary Jane's Mishap (1903), despite involving death and ghosts, use exaggerated performance and gallows humor to provoke laughter rather than fear. Ultimately, the episode contends that early horror should be defined by a clear intention to frighten, not merely by the presence of macabre imagery, making genre classification in early cinema inherently subjective but still discernible through tone and audience cues.

Check out our website at https://www.rhapsodyin35mmpodcast.com/ and subscribe so you don't miss a new posting. Please make sure to follow us on the social media platform of your choice (or all of them!) Rate and comment so more people can find us. See the blog post for credits: https://www.rhapsodyin35mmpodcast.com/post/episode-4-remixed-from-magic-tricks-to-trick-films-the-transition-of-georges-meliese