Insights from Dr. Joe Gothard: Leadership Lessons from a National Superintendent of the Year

In this episode of Superintendents Unplugged, host Addison Davis sits down with Dr. Joe Gothard, 2024 AASA National Superintendent of the Year and proud Madison native, for an insightful and heartfelt conversation on leadership, resilience, and coming full circle.

Dr. Gothard, who began his journey in education as a biology teacher at his alma mater, La Follette High School, shares the powerful story of returning to lead the Madison Metropolitan School District (MMSD)—the same district where he was once a student, teacher, and parent. In a remarkable twist of fate, the very day he accepted the MMSD superintendent position, he was also named the top superintendent in the nation.

Together, Davis and Gothard unpack the lessons learned from leading through adversity, including the pandemic, community tragedies, and the complex political realities facing superintendents today. Gothard speaks candidly about the importance of knowing your values, embracing failure, and fostering inclusivity in school systems. He reflects on his leadership in St. Paul, where he launched groundbreaking equity-driven initiatives such as the East African Elementary Magnet School and expanded dual-language and career pathway programs.

Throughout the episode, listeners get a rare behind-the-scenes look at what it takes to lead with heart, humility, and vision. From navigating national recognition to reconnecting with his roots, Dr. Gothard offers a masterclass in servant leadership—and a powerful reminder that coming home is often the boldest move of all.

Key Moments

06:12 "Prioritize Listening Over Reacting"

09:14 Preparing for Leadership and Community Alignment

10:09 Navigating Superintendent Political Role

14:02 "Redefining Possibilities in Leadership"

Connect with Dr. Joe Gothard

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/joegothard/

Website: https://www.madison.k12.wi.us/