Depending on which side of the growing divide in Manx politics you sit, last week was the best of times or the worst of times. As the old Treasury Minister faced the Cannan guillotine a new Treasury Minister rose back up from the political abyss. So what can Chris Thomas really achieve in the relatively short eight months he has as new Treasury Minister? And was departing Treasury Minister Alex Allinson naively persuing his personal ideology or pragmatically implementing what Tynwald thought it wanted? Find out on this evening’s extended Agenda. Are we heading to a political winter of despair or is a spring of hope just round the corner?

They say that a week is a long time in politics well, if today is anything to go by, it’s going to be a long week! Just after 8am this morning we learned that Alex Allinson had stepped down as Treasury Minister and then shortly after Michelle Haywood had left her role as Minister of Infrastructure. The new DoI Minister is Tim Crookall (this is his third time as Infrastructure Minister since the 2021 election) and as Chanelle Sukhoo was getting Lawrie Hooper’s reaction to the departures we learned that Chris Thomas takes over as Treasury Minister.

The Tynwald Committee on Constitutional and Legal Affairs and Justice is reviewing the Manx Ministerial System which has been in place now for nearly four decades. So far the Committee has heard plenty of evidence to suggest that in good times Council of Ministers works very effectively but when circumstances are difficult CoMin has struggled to take the tough decisions. On Agenda we hear part of the evidence given by Chief Minister Alf Cannan who seems keen to focus more power in the Chief Minister’s hands. Is that good for democracy and will it help get things done, or is this returning us to the days when the governor had absolute power to rule?