The Versions of Us

De: Laura Barnett

Narrado por: Clare Corbett, Daniel Weyman

In one moment, two lives will be changed forever...and forever...and forever.

The one thing that's certain is that they met on a Cambridge street by chance and felt a connection that would last a lifetime. But as for what happened next...

They fell wildly in love or went their separate ways. They kissed or they thought better of it. They married soon after or were together for a few weeks before splitting up. They grew distracted and disappointed with their daily lives together or found solace together only after hard years spent apart.

With The Versions of Us, Laura Barnett has created a world as magical and affecting as those that captivated listeners in One Day and Life After Life. It is a tale of possibilities and consequences that rings across the shifting decades, from the '50s, the '60s, and the '70s and on to the present, showing how even the smallest choices can define the courses of our lives.

©2015 Laura Barnett (P)2016 Blackstone Audio, Inc.

Well worth the effort.

Listening to The Versions of Us took a bit more effort than the usual fictional book. It was like Maybe in Another Life in that it was about how person’s life would be had they made a different choice at a key juncture in their life. It was unlike Maybe in Another Life because there were three concurrent story lines instead of two to try to keep track of. You would think one more story line would not be that much harder to follow but it actually made my brain hurt at times as I tried to figure out what the plot was in the particular version playing. I think it would’ve been easier to digest as a paper book, and perhaps I should’ve made notes, but I was on the go as I listened and this was not an option.

The chapters were each introduced by its version - 1, 2 or 3. As each chapter started I wracked my brain trying to pick up clues in the narrative to what led to the particular story at that point. I really had to think hard at times and sometimes was confused well into a chapter, even in the later chapters. Most of the peripheral characters remained the same through the book but at times new characters were introduced (as families grew over time) in one version and not the other versions which made the book even more complicated.

The story’s main characters are Eva and Jim and the novel starts with their chance meeting on a bike path outside of Cambridge University in 1958. Eva has a boyfriend, David, at this time and he is also an important recurring character throughout the book. From that initial meeting between Jim and Eva the three versions of their lives take root. The novel covers their lives from their teens all the way to their 70s, in current times.

Despite my tone in this review up until this point I actually really liked this book. The writing was excellent, the story lines were not equally interesting but all were intricate and well-paced, and there was always drama. As I’ve said before, I’m fascinated with these “what if” novels. I think we all have moments in life where we make a pivotal decision which sets our future path, and we wonder after the fact what if we would’ve made a different choice. What would my life be like then? Other things I liked about this novel were detailed settings, and really well fleshed out characters. The narration was performed very well by a Clare Corbett and Daniel Weyman who alternated chapters and did a nice job with all the voices, especially the kids. Maybe my favorite thing about the book was how melancholy the tone was throughout. The happy and sad times in Jim and Eva's life were realistically painted and there were many emotional and moving scenes.

I would definitely recommend this book in either format but I think it would be much easier to follow with the paper version, especially if you keep a note which version each chapter is set in. This is a very ambitious work with an interesting premise and I think Laura Barnett really pulled it off.

1 too many "versions" to keep straight...

There are 3 different "versions" to this story of Jim and Eva, and while each version is engaging and entertaining, I found it exceptionally difficult to keep each of the three versions straight from the other. I wonder if perhaps the audiobook format actually makes this MORE difficult than it would be when reading the actually book. While it was certainly an ambitious attempt, I think 2 versions might have been the maximum.

Excellent performance!

This is an interesting and very well-written tale. It is an intriguing concept in a parallel universe sort of way. However, it got confusing at times. I think it may work better in hard copy so the reader could refer back to see who’s who. The narrators were superb.

Too many parallel stories

The book starts with an interesting idea, (2) characters who meet and then live out (3) separate scenarios in which they connect, or not, over (50) years. But it is a lot of work to keep track of the diverging plots and the multiple secondary characters. The narrator's were good, but couldn't quite give the story the emotional impact it seemed to be reaching for.

Versions of Us stuck with me.

Some books you don’t realize are that good until time passes. This is one of those. It has been several years since I first listened to this book. It stayed with me. I absolutely loved it.