Your audiobook is waiting…
The Shopkeeper
People who bought this also bought...
-
The Jensen Brand
- Jensen Brand Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Danny Campbell
- Length: 9 hrs and 27 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 115
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 97
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 97
It's the dawn of a new century. But on the vast Sugarloaf Ranch not much has changed since legendary gunfighter Smoke Jensen and his wife Sally tamed the land two decades ago. Raising cattle is still a dangerous business - and just as deadly as ever. When Smoke is injured swapping bullets with some cow thieves, Sally puts out a call for help to Matt, Ace, and the rest of the Jensen clan. But time is running out. The bloodthirsty rustlers are ready to strike again - and there are lots more of them. And the Sugarloaf's last defense is Smoke and Sally's next of kin....
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Couldn't pull away from it
- By Amazon Customer on 12-12-18
-
The First Mountain Man
- First Mountain Man Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 10 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 206
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 184
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 182
He came west to the Rockies as a young runaway and grew into a legend among the already legendary frontier mountain men. They called him Preacher - a name that would become a monument to all who sought adventure in the savage wilderness of America's untamed west. The only man with the skills to lead a wagon train on the last leg of the rugged Oregon trail, Preacher knows they're headed into trouble. It's hard enough for a hundred greenhorns to survive the wilds of the northwest; being pursued by thieving renegade outlaws and Indians with a thirst for gold makes it damn near impossible.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Excellent
- By Anonymous User on 08-06-19
-
Will Tanner: U.S. Deputy Marshal
- Will Tanner Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Eric Michael Summerer
- Length: 8 hrs and 14 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 222
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 188
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 191
After spending most of his young life driving cattle from Texas to Nevada, Will Tanner is ready to wash the trail dust from his throat. Maybe it was fate that brought him to the Morning Glory Saloon on the border of Indian Territory - or just plain bad luck - because right after his sits down three rough-looking characters walk into the bar with vengeance in their eyes, guns at their sides...and fingers on their triggers. The trio's target is the famous US Deputy Marshal Dove who arrested one of their kin - and who's sitting in the bar near Will Tanner.
-
4 out of 5 stars
-
Engaging
- By Jean on 01-27-19
-
Far Canyon
- By: Elmer Kelton
- Narrated by: George Guidall
- Length: 11 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 81
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 70
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 69
In The Far Canyon, Kelton masterfully unveils for his listener the finality of the buffalo’s demise, the beginning of a time when cattle would replace the American bison on the Southern plains and ultimately end the Plains Indian culture.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
great book
- By Troy J. on 02-17-19
-
Luke Jensen, Bounty Hunter
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Jack Garrett
- Length: 8 hrs and 10 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 201
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 171
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 171
Luke Jensen, Bounty Hunter is the first in an exciting new series starring Smoke's long-lost brother. During the Civil War, Confederate soldier Luke Jensen is ordered to smuggle gold out of the city - but he ends up robbed and shot. Taken in by a Georgia farmer, Luke slowly recovers. Though he plans to rejoin Smoke, a budding romance with the farmer's daughter delays his departure - until a tragic event changes everything.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Another Great William W. Johnstone Book
- By Lady M on 08-22-16
-
Frontier America
- Preacher and MacCallister Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 9 hrs and 46 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars 61
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 54
-
Story5 out of 5 stars 53
As the father of a young Crow tribesman, Preacher would like nothing more than to see the long-time natives and newly arrived settlers live together in peace. Then, the killing starts.... As a family man and frontiersman, Jamie Ian MacCallister is more than happy to help the officers at Fort Kearny negotiate a peace treaty with the Crow nation. Until it all goes to hell.... This is not the American dream they were looking for. This is a nightmare. A brutal, blood-drenched frontier war that two heroic men must fight and win - or one struggling nation will never come together.
-
4 out of 5 stars
-
Narrator
- By Jessica on 09-17-19
-
The Jensen Brand
- Jensen Brand Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Danny Campbell
- Length: 9 hrs and 27 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 115
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 97
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 97
It's the dawn of a new century. But on the vast Sugarloaf Ranch not much has changed since legendary gunfighter Smoke Jensen and his wife Sally tamed the land two decades ago. Raising cattle is still a dangerous business - and just as deadly as ever. When Smoke is injured swapping bullets with some cow thieves, Sally puts out a call for help to Matt, Ace, and the rest of the Jensen clan. But time is running out. The bloodthirsty rustlers are ready to strike again - and there are lots more of them. And the Sugarloaf's last defense is Smoke and Sally's next of kin....
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Couldn't pull away from it
- By Amazon Customer on 12-12-18
-
The First Mountain Man
- First Mountain Man Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 10 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 206
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 184
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 182
He came west to the Rockies as a young runaway and grew into a legend among the already legendary frontier mountain men. They called him Preacher - a name that would become a monument to all who sought adventure in the savage wilderness of America's untamed west. The only man with the skills to lead a wagon train on the last leg of the rugged Oregon trail, Preacher knows they're headed into trouble. It's hard enough for a hundred greenhorns to survive the wilds of the northwest; being pursued by thieving renegade outlaws and Indians with a thirst for gold makes it damn near impossible.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Excellent
- By Anonymous User on 08-06-19
-
Will Tanner: U.S. Deputy Marshal
- Will Tanner Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Eric Michael Summerer
- Length: 8 hrs and 14 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 222
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 188
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 191
After spending most of his young life driving cattle from Texas to Nevada, Will Tanner is ready to wash the trail dust from his throat. Maybe it was fate that brought him to the Morning Glory Saloon on the border of Indian Territory - or just plain bad luck - because right after his sits down three rough-looking characters walk into the bar with vengeance in their eyes, guns at their sides...and fingers on their triggers. The trio's target is the famous US Deputy Marshal Dove who arrested one of their kin - and who's sitting in the bar near Will Tanner.
-
4 out of 5 stars
-
Engaging
- By Jean on 01-27-19
-
Far Canyon
- By: Elmer Kelton
- Narrated by: George Guidall
- Length: 11 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 81
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 70
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 69
In The Far Canyon, Kelton masterfully unveils for his listener the finality of the buffalo’s demise, the beginning of a time when cattle would replace the American bison on the Southern plains and ultimately end the Plains Indian culture.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
great book
- By Troy J. on 02-17-19
-
Luke Jensen, Bounty Hunter
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Jack Garrett
- Length: 8 hrs and 10 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 201
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 171
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 171
Luke Jensen, Bounty Hunter is the first in an exciting new series starring Smoke's long-lost brother. During the Civil War, Confederate soldier Luke Jensen is ordered to smuggle gold out of the city - but he ends up robbed and shot. Taken in by a Georgia farmer, Luke slowly recovers. Though he plans to rejoin Smoke, a budding romance with the farmer's daughter delays his departure - until a tragic event changes everything.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Another Great William W. Johnstone Book
- By Lady M on 08-22-16
-
Frontier America
- Preacher and MacCallister Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 9 hrs and 46 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars 61
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 54
-
Story5 out of 5 stars 53
As the father of a young Crow tribesman, Preacher would like nothing more than to see the long-time natives and newly arrived settlers live together in peace. Then, the killing starts.... As a family man and frontiersman, Jamie Ian MacCallister is more than happy to help the officers at Fort Kearny negotiate a peace treaty with the Crow nation. Until it all goes to hell.... This is not the American dream they were looking for. This is a nightmare. A brutal, blood-drenched frontier war that two heroic men must fight and win - or one struggling nation will never come together.
-
4 out of 5 stars
-
Narrator
- By Jessica on 09-17-19
-
Deadwood
- A Novel
- By: Peter Dexter
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 16 hrs and 57 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4 out of 5 stars 40
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 34
-
Story4 out of 5 stars 33
Deadwood, Dakota Territories, 1876: Legendary gunman Wild Bill Hickcock and his friend Charlie Utter have come to the Black Hills town of Deadwood fresh from Cheyenne, fleeing an ungrateful populace. Bill, aging and sick but still able to best any man in a fair gunfight, just wants to be left alone to drink and play cards. But in this town of played-out miners, bounty hunters, upstairs girls, Chinese immigrants, and various other entrepreneurs and miscreants, he finds himself pursued by a vicious sheriff, a perverse whore man bent on revenge, and a besotted Calamity Jane.
-
1 out of 5 stars
-
What the hell is it with Narrators of Westerns?
- By Kevin on 06-10-19
-
Rattlesnake Wells, Wyoming
- Rattlesnake Wells, Wyoming Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 9 hrs and 40 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 97
-
Performance4 out of 5 stars 82
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 80
The first story in a fiery new series about the west's most dangerous boomtown, and the reformed outlaw who risks his life to keep it safe....In the dark shadow of the Prophecy Mountains lies the ramshackle town of Rattlesnake Wells, where dreamers come to make their fortunes, and desperados come to die. The streets of this little settlement are slick with mud and stained with blood, and it will fall to Bob Hatfield to sweep them clean. The town marshal, Hatfield, has a young man's face, but his eyes are those of a killer. He is a good man, but he has a secret that weighs on his soul.
-
1 out of 5 stars
-
No go
- By Saddlemaker on 02-26-19
-
The Man Who Rode Midnight
- By: Elmer Kelton
- Narrated by: George Guidall
- Length: 9 hrs and 36 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 126
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars 115
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 114
Nearly 70, Wes Hendricks has led a tough and colorful life as a cowboy and broncobuster, and all he asks now is that he be left alone on his poor, hardscrabble ranch in the West Texas hill country. Not a chance - the powers that be in the little town of Big River (including Wes' old cowboy pal, druggist/Mayor Orville Levitt) have decreed that an artificial lake will be created to generate tourism, and Wes' ranch stands squarely in their way.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
None better
- By Al on 11-18-18
-
The Legend of Perley Gates
- Perley Gates Western Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J.A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Danny Campbell
- Length: 9 hrs and 42 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 293
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 253
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 249
He's the son of a cattle rancher. A restless young dreamer who, under normal circumstances, would follow in his father's footsteps. Normal, however, is not his style. Like his famous grandfather and namesake Perley Gates - a hell-raising mountain man with a heavenly name - young Perley wants adventure, excitement, and freedom. And like his grandfather before him, he will find his dream - in the untamed wilds of a lawless frontier. That dream though might just become a nightmare....
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
An enjoyable listen.
- By sinkerbait on 04-30-18
-
MacCallister: The Eagles Legacy
- Duff MacCallister Western Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: P.J. Ochlan
- Length: 8 hrs and 59 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 123
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 107
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 104
The Scottish Highlands, 1885. Two men, brandishing knives, attack a young woman outside a pub. Duff MacAllister steps in and saves her - killing one of the assailants. Big mistake. The attacker was the sheriff's son, and now MacAllister is marked for death. His only hope: America. Here, in the sprawling land of dreams, Duff hopes to start a new life with his American cousins. Unfortunately, the sheriff's deputies are tracking him down - with nine of the deadliest cutthroats money can buy.
-
1 out of 5 stars
-
Writing style?
- By Tim Wilson on 04-22-19
-
Agent Zero
- A Kent Steele Thriller
- By: Jack Mars
- Narrated by: Edoardo Ballerini
- Length: 11 hrs and 14 mins
- Original Recording
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 1,463
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 1,342
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 1,337
In this much-anticipated new spy thriller series by Jack Mars, listeners are taken on an action thriller across Europe as presumed-CIA operative Kent Steele, hunted by terrorists, by the CIA, and by his own identity, must solve the mystery of who is after him, of the terrorists’ pending target - and of the beautiful woman he keeps seeing in his mind.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Top Notch Espionage!! With first class narration!
- By shelley on 03-29-19
-
The Jackals
- Jackals Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Danny Campbell
- Length: 10 hrs and 18 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4 out of 5 stars 59
-
Performance4 out of 5 stars 52
-
Story4 out of 5 stars 52
With Apaches on the prod, ex-cavalry sergeant Sean Keegan, bounty hunter Jed Breen, and ex-Texas Ranger Matt McCulloch take shelter in a West Texas way station - along with a hot-as-a-pistol female bound for the gallows, a spiteful newspaper editor, and a coward with $50,000 who promises them five grand if they'll deliver his blood-soaked stash to his wife. Turns out, Indians might be the least of the problems for the trio, soon to be known as the Jackals. The loot's stolen property of the vengeful Hawkin gang, and these prairie rats are merciless, stone-cold killers.
-
2 out of 5 stars
-
Just can’t handle the narrator’s voice
- By Chris on 06-01-19
-
Springfield 1880
- By: William W. Johnstone, J.A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: J. Rodney Turner
- Length: 10 hrs and 47 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 37
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 32
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 32
With a handful of murderous rogues, Captain Jed Foster has run off with four wagons containing new Springfield rifles, bayonets, and ammunition meant to resupply the troops at Fort Bowie in Arizona Territory. Foster plans to sell the weapons to the highest bidder, whether it's Apaches, Mexican revolutionaries, or Confederate veterans who still dream of destroying the Union. But that's the least of Foster's problems. His junior officer, Lieutenant Grat Holden, is coming after him...with the help of an ornery ex-sergeant known as "Hard Rock" Masterson and fiery guerrilla fighter Soledad.
-
1 out of 5 stars
-
Johnstone needs to do better than just more of the same old thing
- By BOB RUDOLPH on 05-19-19
-
The Recruit
- A Jack Noble Short Story
- By: L. T. Ryan
- Narrated by: Dennis Holland
- Length: 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4 out of 5 stars 213
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 186
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 183
In late summer of 1994, Jack Noble, a former All-American quarterback, is in the middle of the toughest event he's ever taken part in: marine corps recruit training. After eight weeks he's managed to make enemies of every drill instructor and every recruit in his platoon. Then on one particularly humid South Carolina day, an odd sequence of events changes everything. Contains an excerpt of Noble Intentions: Episode 1.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Prequel short story to Jack Noble series!
- By Wayne on 03-20-18
-
The Black Hills
- Hunter Buchanon Series, Book 1
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone
- Narrated by: Al Kessel
- Length: 11 hrs and 40 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4 out of 5 stars 82
-
Performance4 out of 5 stars 69
-
Story4 out of 5 stars 69
Meet Hunter Buchanon, a towering mountain of a man who learned how to track prey in Georgia, kill in the Civil War, and prospect in the Black Hills of Dakota. Now he's trying to live a peaceful gun-free life - but fate has other plans for him. When Hunter Buchanon rescued a wounded coyote pup - and named him Bobby Lee - he had no idea the cute little varmint would grow up to be such a loyal companion.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
Awesome informational educational experience Y'all
- By Steven on 02-04-19
-
Remington 1894
- By: William W. Johnstone, J. A. Johnstone - contributor
- Narrated by: Al Kessel
- Length: 10 hrs and 38 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4 out of 5 stars 76
-
Performance4 out of 5 stars 71
-
Story4 out of 5 stars 70
As a teenager, John McMasters won the Medal of Honor as a sniper for the Union Army during the Civil War. Thirty years later, McMasters lives a peaceful life in the Arizona Territory, raising a family and running cattle. These days, he needs eyeglasses to hit a distant target. But that doesn't stop his wife and four children from buying him a special present for his 50th birthday: a beautiful new Remington shotgun. Turns out, he's going to need it....The Butcher gang has come to town. By the time McMasters learns of their arrival, they've invaded his ranch and slaughtered his family.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
I love Westerns
- By Garren Forth on 12-27-18
-
Appaloosa
- By: Robert B. Parker
- Narrated by: Titus Welliver
- Length: 4 hrs and 54 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall4.5 out of 5 stars 553
-
Performance4.5 out of 5 stars 344
-
Story4.5 out of 5 stars 346
When it comes to writing, Robert B. Parker knows no boundaries. From the iconic Spenser detective series and the novels featuring Sunny Randall and Jesse Stone, to the groundbreaking historical novel Double Play, Parker's imagination has taken readers from Boston to Brooklyn and back again. In Appaloosa, fans are taken on another trip, to the untamed territories of the West during the 1800s.
-
5 out of 5 stars
-
I am over 60 but ...
- By Barbara on 01-14-06
Publisher's Summary
In 1879, Steve Dancy sells his New York shop and ventures west to explore and write a journal about his adventures. Though he's not looking for trouble, Dancy's infatuation with another man's wife soon embroils him in a deadly feud with Sean Washburn, a Nevada silver baron. Infuriated by the outrages of two hired thugs, the shopkeeper kills both men in an impulsive street fight.
Dancy believes this barbarian act has closed the episode. He is wrong. He has interfered with Washburn's ambitions, and this is something the mining tycoon will not allow. Pinkertons, hired assassins, and aggrieved bystanders escalate the feud until it pulls in all the moneyed interests and power brokers in Nevada. Can the former city slicker settle accounts without losing his life in the process?
More from the same
What members say
Average Customer Ratings
Overall
-
4 out of 5 stars
-
5 Stars41
-
4 Stars27
-
3 Stars9
-
2 Stars3
-
1 Stars2
Performance
-
4.5 out of 5 stars
-
5 Stars33
-
4 Stars14
-
3 Stars7
-
2 Stars1
-
1 Stars1
Story
-
4 out of 5 stars
-
5 Stars28
-
4 Stars15
-
3 Stars8
-
2 Stars2
-
1 Stars2
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
- J. C. Edmond
- Los Angeles
- 06-11-10
A well written western!
This is a great audiobook series. This book is well narrated and keeps you hooked until the end. The author really researched his material well and brings not only realism but suspenseful story that keeps you guessing all the way trough. I can't wait until I listen to the next book in the series.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars
-
Story5 out of 5 stars
- Kelly Watley
- 09-22-16
classic suspense novel Loved it..
classic suspense. intriguing and suspenseful very enjoyable . different from the norm . great narration believable characters,..
This audiobook was provided by the author, narrator, or publisher at no cost in exchange for an unbiased review courtesy of AudiobookBoom dot com."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars
-
Story5 out of 5 stars
- Hobie
- Houston, TX, United States
- 06-04-15
The Incredible Shopkeeper
A must to listen too. Lots of humor, suspense and action. Steve Dancy, the main character, might be the most memorable soul on both sides of the Rockies. Well written and ranks with The Cowboys and The Cossacks. Take a chance with this masterpiece; you will laugh and will learn a thing or two.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars
-
Story5 out of 5 stars
- Skaught
- 06-04-14
A great western with plenty of surprises!
Who was your favorite character and why?
The main character in the book has plenty of surprises as the author reveals who he is. I listened to the two books available here on audio, and then read the last two books. The author may write more as he has left plenty of room for it and it has been written recently.
Which scene was your favorite?
When this man defends the honor of a lady in a town that is abused by a pair of bullies.
Any additional comments?
Highly recommend this book series - if you like Louis L'Amour books or William Johnstone, you will like this!
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
- MaddogKindle
- 03-31-17
What a book
I couldn't stop till I got through it ,what a story. I m going to listen to and read them all
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars
- Cally
- 09-02-16
Well written
Well written, no pornographic surprises, good story, plenty of twists. Great character development. I will look for the next book in the series.
-
Overall5 out of 5 stars
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars
-
Story5 out of 5 stars
- Gaylan D. Page
- Groveton, Texas
- 04-11-16
A Keeper
This audible book is the type that I will listen to many times through the years.
-
Overall4 out of 5 stars
-
Performance5 out of 5 stars
-
Story5 out of 5 stars
- Bruce Lawrence
- Oxnard, CA USA
- 05-19-15
Fun
Just a good tale well told. I recommend to readers of western tales. The narration was dolid.
-
Overall2 out of 5 stars
-
Performance3 out of 5 stars
-
Story2 out of 5 stars
- McFitz
- 03-14-15
Plodding story
Any additional comments?
I do like a good western story, but this was unlike most of the westerns I've read. I didn't care for the main character, Steve Darcy, as much as I expected to. He didn't struggle much with his conscience, for instance, and he condoned actions that were more than questionable. His wealth made it very easy to obtain things and the financial and business transactions were just tedious. Making "deals" for things is not very interesting, especially when it was bribery. I often wished the author would just "get on with it" and write some action, actually.
The book was certainly disappointing after the reviews I read.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful