The Royal Wulff Murders

By: Keith McCafferty

Narrated by: Rick Holmes

Length: 10 hrs and 26 mins

Publisher's Summary

An award-winning editor for Field & Stream magazine, Keith McCafferty presents his debut novel, The Royal Wulff Murders. A local fisherman lands more than he bargained for when he pulls a dead body out of Montana’s Madison River. Sheriff Martha Ettinger takes on the case and soon comes into the company of reclusive artist, Montana newcomer, and ex-PI Sean Stranahan. After teaming up to investigate, Martha and Sean soon uncover evidence that the murder has ties to one of the state’s biggest industries: fly fishing.

©2012 Keith McCafferty (P)2012 Recorded Books, LLC

I like this series set in Montana

This is first book of a Montana-based mystery series led by Sheriff Martha Ettinger and "private detective" Sean Stranahan. I like all the characters (except for the ridiculous Velvet Lafayette). The setting along the Madison River is written so beautifully, I have looked up the location and hope to get there some day. The story is told mostly from Stranahan's perspective. He is a young, good man with sharp intellect and instincts. There is some art, lots of fishing and some good dialog. I will definitely use a credit to purchase the next book in the series.

If you enjoy Walt Longmire or Joe Pickett mysteries, this will be a good listen for you.

Get to know the state you’re writing about.

The story was an average mystery. Author has taken a lot of poetic license with Montana geography. His blatant political statement at the end berating mining and agriculture for harming his recreational pursuits lead me to believe that he thinks the pristine beauty of Montana and its environment compared to other states was by accident rather than the efforts of many generations of Montana residents who have lived here much longer than he or any of his progeny will. We protect it because we love it and depend on a healthy environment to produce healthy crops and livestock. We open our land and our streams to recreational users because we know how lucky we are and want to share with others. Maybe the author should step out of the water and actually get acquainted with the business owners he openly criticized rather than just feeling good about himself for donating to causes with paid staff to do the work that we do every day.

Murder, Montana & Fly Fishing

Up front I need to say that I fly fish for trout with a bamboo rod on smaller streams in the northeastern part of America. Oh yes--and I am a woman and I tie my own flies. My favorite aspects of fly fishing involve walking and reading the stream, wading out into the rushing water and really just being part of the complex wild ecosystem that fishing requires.

I really enjoy complex and well thought out mysteries set in distinct locations. Often it is difficult for me to read a mystery about a subject I know well because many times writers take on themes they don't really know inside out. This can ruin a story. Thankfully this is not this case with this book. McCafferty, the survival and outdoor skills editor for Field and Stream magazine, knows his subject well.

This is the first book in a mystery series set in Montana and I thought it was good. Some reviewers found that the book focused too much on "the fishing". I disagree--in fact I would have enjoyed a bit more detail on that subject. I mean, the plot and story are really about fly fishing in Montana. So, I don't understand how there can be too much fishing??

McCafferty's writing captures the beauty and wildness of nature and Montana. The story was engaging and the characters were unusual and interesting. I thought there was a good balance between the mystery, the background information and the atmosphere and sense of place the author established.

At times, I thought the narrator became monotone and sounded bored by the reading. But, for the most part Holmes did a good job reading the book.

Recommended if you like mysteries with quirky characters, some rough talk, a few gruesome scenes, a bit of violence and lots of the great outdoors. Oh, and yes, there is the fishing too.

Found a new series

Listened to the fourth book and enjoyed it so much had to start at the beginning. If you like Longmire or Joe Pickett you'll like this. Good character, tough talking female , and politically incorrect friend. The best part is the narrator. So good you don't notice him. His voices are done well and are not irritating.

Good book but not as good as Longmire Series

I am a fan of Craigslist Johnson and after reading all his Longmire Series was looking for a authentic in a simular vien. This author is good but seems to be lacking the spark maybe humor of Mr. Johnson. I do not expect 2 author to write the same, but this author was sort of dark and depressing. I do not mine dark if there is enough amusement or humor to balance it. That I believe is the mark if a truly great author capturing that delicate balance.

Incredulous

I liked the characters and nature portrayed in this story, but the plot seemed incredulous, implausible - ridiculous. I can abide one or two small trips down implausibility lane. That's just humanity, I guess. But, the ones here are so far-fetched I can't recommend this book, in spite of the characters and descriptive beauty. There'd only be one book in any series of a real-life character who made these choices: the main character wouldn't survive to a second book.

Fishing and Painting in Montana

Had a little bit of a rough start for me . . . overly bad language for no apparent reason, but got better quickly . . . I like ex-PI Sean Stranahan . . . not nearly as much as I like Walt Longmire, but not everyone can compete with Longmire . . . the back story of Stranahan is good and when he takes on the task of locating the fish with the notched fin so he could scatter the ashes of the elusive lady's father, it just gets more interesting . . . a job a little more complicated than finding a fish, Stranahan soon learns that he's stepped off the deep end . . . right into murder . . . the painting, contemplative, private eye is in for much more than he bargained for . . . turned out to be a satisfying listen and great resolution . . .

Entertaining Fly Fishing Mystery

I enjoyed the descriptions of fly fishing tremendously. The mystery was compelling and there were some interesting characters. What I didn't like was the handling of the obligatory romantic angle of the story. I felt that our hero's relationship with the women was too male fantasy, and too manipulated to suit a formula, to ring at all true.

Heavy on fly fishing

What did you like best about The Royal Wulff Murders? What did you like least?

Perhaps a cut above average story and a good, sound performance. I'm not a fisherman, but the fly fishing details and threat to trout were interesting; nonetheless, I wouldn't welcome a steady diet of that much detail. I found the several physical injuries to the protagonist a bit overdone.

What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?

The who-done-it aspect was most interesting. The on-again-off-again romance episodes would hardly capture one's attention very effectively. If I had been reading, rather than listening, I would probably have skipped much of that.

Which character – as performed by Rick Holmes – was your favorite?

Hard to say what character was performed best. Rick Holmes was so practiced and adroit he became invisible as the reader. All one hears is the characters, and the performance becomes transparent, as it should with a really professional job.

Did The Royal Wulff Murders inspire you to do anything?

Well, . . . I'm not going to take up fly fishing for trout, if that's what you're asking; however, I am going to check on the author's latest book.

Fishing For Compliments

This book is a sleeper of a "detective" novel. Sean Stranahan is a former private investigator and tries to resist getting pulled back into it. Fly fishing is clearly Keith McCafferty's love and his story evokes a ton of fishing imagery. The mystery evolves slowly as though the reader is fishing for it. McCafferty's best characters are those with the small parts. Pay attention to the English inn owner - he has some interesting things to say. I am afraid that the women characters, who figure strongly in the story are the weak point, especially Velvet Lafayette. She is a completely unbelievable character.

Anyway, having read another Stranahan book before this, the first book in the series, I'd say McCafferty started well and didn't lose much enthusiasm over time. Highly recommend.