The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint

De: Brady Udall

Narrado por: Scott Shina

This astonishing novel was chosen as a Best Book of the Year by the Los Angeles Times, Entertainment Weekly, Publisher's Weekly and Newsweek. Contained within is the story of Edgar Mint, the half-Apache, mostly orphaned child who overcomes a serious childhood injury to embark on a life of tragedies, including a boarding school for Native Americans and a dysfunctional Mormon foster family.

©2001 Brady Udall (P)2002 Recorded Books, LLC

Reseñas de la Crítica

"A bit of a miracle in its own right." ( Kirkus Reviews, starred review)

One of my favorites

I've downloaded close to 100 books from Audible and this has to be one of my top 5 favorites.
A great story and a wonderful lead character.
The reader was also excellent. He handled dialogue from a range of characters with great versatility. Even his recreation of the occasional sound was a plus and not an intrusion.
I'll look for more books from the author and the narrator.

Tedious

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

Could not get back the tedious description of Mint's father as a drugstore cowboy wanna-be. What could have been a truly hilarious rodeo scene with the tired, old bull and the northerner-idiot was relegated to point-by-boring point description.

Master Storyteller

If you could sum up The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint in three words, what would they be?

Detailed, Journey, Perseverence

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint?

There were many poignant moments. I was most affected when Edgar visits Cecil for the last time.

If you could take any character from The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint out to dinner, who would it be and why?

I would take Art. He is cantankerous, unassumingly funny, and says the darndest things.

Any additional comments?

Brady Udall's first novel is a detailed, tale of a half-apache mostly-orphaned boy who travels through one difficult situation to another. The story slowly unfolds with a mixture of anguish and all-out laughter. Settle in for a good listen.

Great Book

Would you consider the audio edition of The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint to be better than the print version?

I think that the print may be better for this audiobook. I found that personally the story affected me more when I was reading it in print.

What other book might you compare The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint to and why?

Anything Dickens.

What about Scott Shina’s performance did you like?

You can tell that he was committed to Edger as a character and was totally convincing in almost all of the roles. The accounts of abuse touched me more in print. I do not know if that is the fault of the narrator or a personal preference.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

This book touched me in a big way. Start to finish the narrative griped me.

A must hear book

Couldn't stop listening!!! The way this book was written is captivating and very inspiring!! I have listened to this book twice and actually read the book once!!@

Loved Edgar Mint for a second time.

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

He has a nice voice, but he places emphasis in the oddest places. I kept being jolted from the story to rewind and edit my understanding of what he said.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

Edgar's Miracle Life will rip apart your heart and then put it together again.

Great Read

Best book I’ve read in a long time. The author provoked almost every human emotion and I didn’t want it to end. The ending was also satisfying. There was some iffy language but not too bad. Some humor is also included and I will highly recommend this book.

Thoughtful and cathartic.

So I don't write reviews often, but Brady Udall is a great author. He is not my usual style of author. I am an escapist sci-fi bum. My wife who is a much deeper and smarter person then me introduced me to him. His work is harder to get through, his characters are deeper, dense and more real, because of that it can be hard to see difficult things happen to people who seem so real. It is also beautiful and hopeful in the sad though. I have to be in the mood for it is great.

Also as a side note Brady Udall is a delightful and caring individual. A few Christmas times ago he signed all of my wife's copies of his books. I talked to him in person when he did and talked plumbing with him (I am a plumber). He was warm and generous to a stranger and sent me away with a Christmas gift my wife has never forgotten. This is the third version of Edgar Mint that we own, I hope we continue to enjoy new work and old from Mr. Udall for a long time to come.

Wonderful story that left me wanting to know more

Would you consider the audio edition of The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint to be better than the print version?

The story stands on its own completely the medium of presentation doesn't really matter. I would however recommend this book for highschool students.

What did you like best about this story?

The resilience of Edgar although he doesn't seem to believe he is really able to create his own path. Although I found this heart wrenching, love did in the end come to Edgar.

Which scene was your favorite?

The sections with the Morman family where Edgar first is able to glimpse what family and love can hold.

If you could take any character from The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint out to dinner, who would it be and why?

Edgar because his path is so intense and real, it would be interesting to discuss his revelations as he reviews his life.

The Miracle In All of Us

In the long-term-care ward of a hospital, a little boy wakes up, a helmet of sorts secured around his head, his mind a blank slate---and so begins a sprawling adventure: Edgar's journey to find out just who, and why, is Edgar Mint. Edgar narrates the tale, and if he "could tell you just one thing", he would want you to know that "when I was 7 yrs. old, the mailman ran over my head." That, more than his name or what he has been told, is the identity he is sure about. He learns about his heartbreaking past and abandonement, he experiences cruelty and rejection, ridicule for being the "retarded" half-breed Indian kid, but he remains above all else, the kid that got his head run over by a mailman, detached but observant, driven to find a purpose, and where he belongs.

Publishers praised Udall's novel saying the characters were "Dickensenian;" critics said the writing was reminiscent of John Irving's; similarites to One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest were noted; readers' reviews were over the top (many saying this is now in their top 10 favs); and Michael Stipe (of R.E.M. fame) liked the novel enough to purchase film rights.

Reviews, even as lofty and complimentary as these have been, can be dangerous, and I wish I hadn't read most regarding Edgar Mint, because sometimes you get front-end-loaded by reviews--your experience of a book is colored by them. And that was the case for me. At times, I thought of Huck Finn, but I never had an Owen Meany moment. The characters are memorable, but lack the patina of Dickens' wonderful characters that have weathered the years. The only similarity I could see to Kesey's fabulous Cuckoo's Nest (one of my favorites) was a Native American with mental issues. I do think it will make an amazing movie, and it may be in my top 100.

Without comparisons, Udall can stand on his own merits. He is a very creative and original talent. He has created a beautiful, but often dark and drepressing, book with his own style of grand characters. His writing flows easily; he is descriptive but not verbose, and even in some pitiful moments is able to create humor. One noticeable strength in this book (and a remarkable achievement) is how Udall gave an authentic voice to Edgar, capturing that disconnect and trauma of someone that hasn't experienced a childhood and all the developmental stages we go through--but rather has been fed his childhood, like a bedtime story. Of course, being a talented writer, he weaves into this purposeful tale the inherent need in all of us to be loved, and the real "Miracle"...the power of the heart to love and to forgive.

My background is in psychology so I understood what Udall was doing with Edgar, (and I enjoyed the symbolic trunkload of typing Edgar hauls about) but still I had trouble connecting with him, even though I liked him. I wonder if sometimes Udall was a little too sparse with Edgar's emotions-- perhaps handling that detachment a little too well. But, inspite of my personal little problem, I think this book has broad appeal, with the exception of readers that may be offended with some language and sexual situations. I highly recommend and think that anyone that chooses to listen will have an unforgettable experience. And who knows...Edgar Mint, in time, may join the ranks of Huck Finn, Oliver Twist, Pip, David Copperfield, even "Chief" Bromden.