The First Congress

How James Madison, George Washington, and a Group of Extraordinary Men Invented the Government

By: Fergus M. Bordewich

Narrated by: Sean Runnette

Length: 12 hrs and 59 mins

Publisher's summary

The First Congress was the most important in US history, says prizewinning author and historian Fergus Bordewich, because it established how our government would actually function. Had it failed - as many at the time feared it would - it's possible that the United States as we know it would not exist today.

The Constitution was a broad set of principles. It was left to the members of the First Congress and President George Washington to create the machinery that would make the government work. Fortunately, James Madison, John Adams, Alexander Hamilton, and others less well known today rose to the occasion. During two years of often fierce political struggle, they passed the first 10 amendments to the Constitution; they resolved bitter regional rivalries to choose the site of the new national capital; they set in place the procedure for admitting new states to the union; and much more. But the First Congress also confronted some issues that remain to this day: the conflict between states' rights and the powers of national government; the proper balance between legislative and executive power; the respective roles of the federal and state judiciaries; and funding the central government.

©2016 Fergus Bordewich (P)2016 Tantor

Critic reviews

"[T]he colorful machinations of our first Congress receive a delightful account that will keep even educated readers turning the pages." ( Kirkus)

Interesting and informative

I picked up this title on a whim and I am glad that I did!

In my experience, many of us today take our modern democracy as a given, but that is not the case.

The United States was a huge real life experiment. It easily could not have worked, but it did.

In all fairness, I learned a lot of this content in school, but it he author does an excellent job of revealing the information and making it feel dramatic - almost to the point where I could imagine that I didn’t know how it ended.

In summary, while not novel (at least not for me) very interesting and well written.

A critical story, well-told

I've wanted to read more on the subject for years. In spite of the era being well covered, I've not before seen a focus on the first congress, which operated with no precedent on which to lean. I personal learned a lot. The writing is very good and the spoken version well done.

What a great Story!

I really enjoyed this book. I learned so much about these men who started our country. I learned that there are no "good old days" where everyone worked together harmoniously for the common good. Work they did, and for the common good, as they each saw it, but harmoniously, no way! I loved the way the characters were described and brought to life through their quotes and the descriptions of their colleagues. Great book! Highly recommended!

Intricate Analysis of Novel Challenges

Bordewich has written a thorough analysis of the challenges faced by the new government, for many of which there was no precedent. Many of the participants therefore looked to classical theory for guidance. One lesson from such theory was that a powerful government could be used against the people, and therefore many Americans feared a strong government. This lesson was countered by the experiences under both the Continental and Confederation Congresses, which convinced many that a strong government was needed to deal with other nations and to protect the nation from external pressures.

Much of the story of the First Congress involves reconciling the conflicts inherent in the two lessons, one looking internally and the other externally. The theoretical answer, contained in the Constitution, is the division of power. The monumental achievement of the First Congress was breathing life into our system of checks and balances.

Bordewich also makes emphasizes how much slavery was already a divisive issue--one with no apparent solution and already threatening to become the defining issue in the new nation. Because the politicians could not envision a solution, it became easier for them to ignore the issue than to address it. This of course would make the problem worse and eventually mean that only force could resolve the issue.

Compelling

The author utilized the First Federal Congress Project to write this book. The Project has cataloged nearly all the diaries, letters and newspaper accounts relating to the proceedings of the Congress of 1789-1791. As we discovered with Bordewich’s book, the project is a gold mine for historians. The key actions of the Congress were the ratification of the Constitution and the creation and passage of the Bill of Rights. They also decided on how the government should function, cabinet positions etc.

This book is well written and meticulously researched. Bordewich has the ability to place the reader right into the scene. I felt as if I was suffering the hot cramped meeting rooms right alongside Madison, Adams and Washington debating each Amendment and the Bill of Rights. I found the section about how they determined the amount of power the president should have most interesting. They said they trusted George Washington but what about some president in the future who wants to become a dictator. It became clear to me that the issues that the men wrestled with in 1790 still have resonance today. The book is easily readable and I found it most enlightening. I have read other books by Bordewich and find him great at writing descriptive details.

The book is thirteen hours. Sean Runnels does an excellent job narrating the book. Runnels has won five Earphone Awards and has narrated a number of Audie Award winning audiobooks. He is also an actor.

The 1st Congress

No complaints at all in this book. Narration was done well and very informative on the various aspects the early leaders had to deal with. Also some enlightenment on some of the precedent that still prevails. Well worth the time.

Fascinating

Well told story of the founding of the country once the fighting stopped. I read a lot about 18th century America, and this is one of the best books I have read (listened).

An immportant slice of US history

The author looks at an important topic that is overlooked in big histories - how the first Congress set up the new government. There was no blueprint. They started from scratch.

All the important figures from that era roam across these pages but two standout in their contributions - James Madison and Alexander Hamilton. You'll see them from a different angle after reading this book.

I highly recommend it.

Often excellent, sometimes flawed

Many interesting facts. Excellent combination of legislative history and biography. Fascinating portrayals of many congressmen, including some who are not well-known today. Too simplistic and too many errors when attempting to contextualize the 1st Congress regarding later developments in constitutional law or US politics.