Once a Witch

By: Carolyn MacCullough

Narrated by: Hannah Friedman

Length: 8 hrs and 19 mins

Publisher's summary

Tamsin Greene comes from a long line of witches, and she was supposed to be one of the most Talented among them. But Tamsin's magic never showed up. Now 17, Tamsin attends boarding school in Manhattan, far from her family. But when a handsome young professor mistakes her for her very Talented sister, Tamsin agrees to find a lost family heirloom for him. The search—and the stranger—will prove to be more sinister than they first appeared, ultimately sending Tamsin on a treasure hunt through time that will unlock the secret of her true identity, unearth the sins of her family, and unleash a power so vengeful that it could destroy them all. This is a spellbinding display of storytelling that will exhilarate, enthrall, and thoroughly enchant.

©2009 Carolyn MacCullough (P)2010 Audible, Inc.

Critic reviews

"[MacCullough] has created an enormously sympathetic character in Tamsin, whose itchy relationship with her family will resonate with teens struggling to define themselves. Characters, setting, conflict—all develop nicely to create a light urban fantasy that goes down easy and will have readers asking for its sequel." (Kirkus Reviews)
"With the glut of contemporary romantic supernatural tales, this will be popular, but the action, drama, and great potential for compelling sequels set it apart from the crowd." (Booklist)
"MacCullough's writing is evocative without distracting from her story; readers will identify with Tam's desire to create a space away from parental expectations and take comfort that even extraordinary families make mistakes." (Publishers Weekly)

well written

I really liked this book! The plot kept you listening and the characters really pull you in. I felt the end was really rushed and there wasn't enough describing the circumstances and actions that had taken place. I'm not sure if it was over editing or if it's left that way to be pick up in a hopeful sequel. Either way I enjoyed it enough to anticipate another!

Missing content

I read along with my audio whenever I can. I was shocked that both the prologue and epilogue are both missing from the audio versions. The thing is, they are very important to understanding the story. Very strange decision. The narrator got the Job done and the story was OK. I'm still deciding whether or not I will check out the next installment. I like a little closure with the books I read and this book leaves many unanswered questions.

Pretty fun story, but eh characters

Overall this was an interesting story. I liked the idea of each witch having a "talent" (i.e. special power) and I think Tamsin was a really well done character. MacCullough did a great job with providing depth to Tamsin and really letting the reader understand what she's feeling having grown up with out a talent.

The plot was also really interesting to me. Essentially, Tamsin is searching for an artifact that keeps changing every time she thinks she finds it. She travels through time with a friend of hers, and discovers the truth about who she is. I thoroughly enjoyed that, but also was a little mad at how long it took her to put the pieces together. But I think that's part of why you keep reading, to make sure she gets there eventually.

But here's the thing. I get writing a college-aged guy as one who makes a lot of jokes, and flirts a lot. But the idea that he does it 100% of the time, even when Tamsin's sister is in literal danger just felt like MacCullough has never actually talked to a guy during a real crisis. And just kept taking me out of the story. Like, I have known a lot of bro-y men in my life. But when someone's in danger or afraid, they don't try to flirt in the middle of it.

Overall, I would say if you've been thinking about picking this up, do it. But I do have to admit the ending didn't leave me clamoring for the sequel. I'm not even sure I'll read it. Definitely suggest the audio version though, as I loved the narrator.

Storytelling

This book is so hard to describe it sweeps you up in its world of storytelling and you get lost in the words themselves. This author weaves together so many different stories and makes them all connect masterfully. This is an ode to storytelling itself and does a masterful job of it. I loved listening to this and could have listened to it forever. I was so sad when it ended and I had to leave this world. This story begs to be read out loud and savored not rushed over or anything like that. It’s perfect to curl up with a cup of something hot and get lost in the words.

I will listen to future books in this series.

The story line is fun to follow and grows as you read on. The reader is easy to listen to.

Great Story

The author has a greal deat of talent. Making this a good read for both teens and adults, smoothly, without leaning more one way or the other. I could relate to the heroine (even as a 29 year old) and I was routing for Gabriel (the romantic interest.) She intertwined witchcraft and time travel easily, much more easily then you would think. It does touch on underage drinking and smoking. But neither condemns or approves of it, it just...is apart of the character. The story had this organic and natural feel to it. I certainly hope they continue the storyline.

Worst Book

Chose this book by it's cover that was my first mistake! The writing is terrible, the narrator swallows and you can hear it throughout the book, and it is very predictable.