Shiloh

In Hell before Night

De: James Lee Mcdonough

Narrado por: Gary D. MacFadden

Colorful, dramatic, blundering, and tragic - these are some of the adjectives that have been applied to the two-day engagement at Shiloh. This battle, which bears the biblical name meaning “place of peace,” was one of the bloodiest encounters of the Civil War. The Union colonel, whose words give the present book its title, foretold the losses when he told his men: “Fill your canteens Boys! Some of you will be in hell before night….”

Fought in the early spring of 1862 on the west bank of the Mississippi state line, Shiloh was, up to that time, the biggest battle of American history. One hundred thousand men were involved, and major Civil War commanders such as Grant, Sherman, Johnston, Beauregard, Bragg, and Forrest participated. The battle took the life of Johnston and it left a lasting impact on the reputation of other commanders. More-over, it played a significant role in the campaign for control of the Mississippi Valley.

Although hundreds of books have been written about the Civil War and its battle, questions about the disorganized struggle at Shiloh have continued to perplex historians. Why was Grant absent when his army was attacked? Why did Grant and Sherman apparently ignore evidence of a Confederate advance? What happened to Lew Wallace that he never got his division into the fight on the first day of battle? Why did it take the Rebels so long to make their way from Corinth to the battlefield? Did the Rebels really have a distinct opportunity to win the battle, as it seems in retrospect, or were they doomed from the start? Were Johnston and Beauregard working at cross-purposes? Shiloh - In Hell Before Night provides answers or clues to answers of clues to answers for these and other questions arising from this controversial engagement.

The author tells his story by placing Shiloh in the larger context of the war and by exploring the very personal side of the conflict through the words of the Union and Confederate participants, officers and common soldiers alike. Touches of humor and even or romance are revealed in the midst of the carnage, but the overriding element is the specter of death. Among those who survived, the soldiers who had been eager to “see the elephant,” as they commonly referred to combat, could never again feel so eager for a fight.

James Lee McDonough is professor of history at Auburn University, and the author of Stones River - Bloody Winter in Tennessee, Chattanooga - A Death Grip on the Confederacy, and the co-author of Five Tragic Hours: The Battle of Franklin.

The book is published by University of Tennessee Press.

©1977 The University of Tennessee Press (P)2012 Redwood Audiobooks

SHILOH

There is a lot of information in this book about the war. I learned things , enough to make me want to listen to more books about the cival war. This is more facts than a storyline. I assume everything is true I dont know enough about the cival war to say. There is no way to imagine what some people saw and had to deal with afterwards. I will look for other books from this author. Gary MacFadden does a good job narrating this book. If my review is any help will you please click on the helpful link below. Thanks

Bountiful and thought provoking!

This book is one of my favorite books dealing with Shiloh. The author challenges a lot of the mythology the battle has engendered.

Great book poorly read

Poor performance. Stodgy poor reader. Though excellent work by the author in research and story telling as if a thrilling page turner.

Overall not bad

Dry in parts. Wish the narrator didn’t sound like a computer voice. My biggest complaint is with narration