Quarterback

Inside the Most Important Position in the National Football League

De: John Feinstein

Narrado por: John Feinstein

From legendary sportswriter and #1 New York Times bestselling author John Feinstein, a deep dive into the most coveted and hallowed position in the NFL.

"Another must-read from a master of long-form sports journalism."--Booklist, starred review

In the mighty National Football League, one player becomes the face of a franchise, one player receives all the accolades and all the blame, and one player's hand will guide the rise or fall of an entire team's season--and the dreams of millions of fans. There are thirty-two starting quarterbacks in the NFL, and their lives are built around pressure, stardom, and incredible talent. In his most insightful book yet, John Feinstein shows readers what it's really like to play the glory position and to live that life--mapping out a journey that runs from college stardom to the NFL draft to taking command of the huddle and marching a team down the field with a nation of fans cheering.

Centering on five NFL starting quarterbacks--Alex Smith, Andrew Luck, Joe Flacco, Ryan Fitzpatrick, and Doug Williams--Quarterback provides readers with incredible inside access to the locker room, huddle, and heat of battle. Through spectacular moments and embarrassing defeats, this is as close as most of us will ever come to experiencing life in the most glamorous position in America's greatest game.

Reseñas de la Crítica

"Another must-read from a master of long-form sports journalism."
--Booklist, starred review

"Eminent sportswriter Feinstein embedded himself with five successful quarterbacks . . . tak[ing] readers from one breathtaking finish to another. With a critical eye and unsurpassed sense of sports history and culture, Feinstein examines qualities of leadership, the politics and drama within locker rooms and league offices, and the unrelenting pressure that can either crush a quarterback or turn him into a legend. Stellar research and storytelling that makes this an essential read for NFL fans and sports enthusiasts."
--Library Journal, starred review

"A worthy offering for fans of the modern, increasingly embattled game."
--Kirkus Reviews

Praise for The First Major

“Feinstein’s talent always has been the depth of his relationships, which enables him to get important figures to divulge intimate details of what transpired. . .The book features one interesting anecdote after another . . . In the hands of a lesser writer, a book about a lopsided match would have been hard to pull off. Feinstein, though, knows how to tell a good story, regardless of the outcome.”
—Chicago Tribune

Praise for The Legends Club

“One of [John Feinstein's] best, a beguilingly personal, sometimes heartbreaking look at the psychic cost of doing battle in America’s most brutally, nakedly competitive (and actual) arenas. It makes a fitting bookend to the author’s first, A Season on the Brink (1986), his hair-raising exposé of Indiana coach Bobby Knight, expletives included.”
—The Wall Street Journal

“The legends are right there in the subtitle: Dean Smith, Mike Krzyzewski, Jim Valvano, and an Epic College Basketball Rivalry. The unbilled fourth legend is the author. His longstanding relationships with the principals give the book its insider appeal; his history with each man goes back decades, and the intersecting, layered looks at each are built on firsthand knowledge . . . Funny and smart.”
—USA Today

“Feinstein entertains readers with fair, objective observations based on fact and his unique inside access gained not only through years of his coverage but also through many new interviews with former players, coaches and administrators. . . In a famous speech before he died, Valvano implored all of us to attempt to do three things each day: laugh, think and cry. He would be pleased with The Legends Club because it will evoke all three from readers, no matter where their college basketball allegiances lie.”
—The Washington Post

Stayed In the Locker Room After the Half

I heard about the book when the author was promoting it on an Indianapolis morning radio show. Feinstein had a great back and forth with the hosts and prompted me to buy the book. The first few chapters of the book were able to keep me listening as intently as I was during the radio broadcast. However, the author repeats quotes from players and coaches and apparently loves the phrase, 'would prove to be a harbinger'. This book gets off to a strong start by delving into the lives of 5 different NFL quarterbacks giving the listener a behind the scenes look but quickly devolves into box scores of the 2017 NFL season.

80/20: I knew 80% of it/I found 20% new info

This is an 80/20 book as in 80% of the book was stuff I already knew and 20% was stuff I never knew.

I knew about all of these seasonal recaps, particularly the one most chronicled throughout the book (2017), and how quarterbacks have to say the right things and accept the blame for the team’s losses and mistakes even if they can be exempted.

I also know that the quarterback draft and acquisition process is loaded with misses despite all the money spent and largely racially biased against black quarterbacks.

Feinstein tried too hard to prove that there’s a racist double standard against black quarterbacks by painting the Shanahans as racist against Donovan McNabb when McNabb threw his career away in Washington and Minnesota and was irresponsible for mistakes in Philadelphia such as not knowing the overtime rules.

It exists to some extent, but not enough to where non-blacks can observe and say “You know what John? You’re right!”

Feinstein seems to imply that Daniel Snyder is an administrative racist by not only funding Donald Drumpf’s inauguration but only giving GM titles to white men like Scot McCloughan while never giving them to black men like Doug Williams, a man who was not only the first ever African-American quarterback to win a Super Bowl and the game’s MVP award but has the same duties like a typical GM.

He is also correct about the “athlete” term used on draft-eligible black quarterbacks as it is meant to imply that they’re not smart enough to play quarterback and was applied to Dak Prescott and Lamar Jackson. After all, it’s not applied to Andrew Luck, Ryan Tannehill, or Jake Locker. In fact, almost no white athlete quarterback is asked to change positions like Lamar Jackson, a short guy at 6’3” according to Bill Polian.

This book isn’t worth purchasing unless it’s via an extreme discount and its content was almost all available through websites like Pro Football Talk and The Undefeated. Feinstein is a good author with great past accomplishments, but he needs to stop writing in a quantity-over-quality approach. Instead, he needs new but smaller mediums to display his work because he might diminish his legacy if makes books like “Quarterback.”

Lame

This book is like a middle school book review where the student writes a synopsis of the book instead of making any kind of critical analysis of the plot.

The author spends over half the book recapping games over the last few seasons. For anyone who actively follows the nfl, this is all boring and uninteresting.

I sought out this book because I thought I’d learn some insights about what it takes to be a successful quarterback in the nfl due to the authors efforts in uncovering under the radar insights. Instead the author spends all his time breaking down game recaps and comes back to an obvious theme of “the qb gets all the credit and all the blame” and that’s about it.

Your View of This Book Depends on Your Expectation

Feinstein is a good writer, that's well known. His narration is okay if you increase the speed so he isn't so plodding. I didn't enjoy the book that much because my expectations were not not in sync with the story. You will like this book if the following is what you are looking for
1. You are interested in one or all of the quarterbacks profiled
2. You enjoy hearing game recaps over the span of several seasons in the 20-teens.
3. You have no problem following how the narration jumps forwards and backwards depending on which QB is being profiled at the time.

You won't enjoy the book if
1. You expect to hear about how QBs prep for games, strategies of an offense that must be learned, or descriptions about how QBs develop their craft.
2. What a star QBs life is like in the locker room or outside the stadium as they balance family and fame.
3. You have a low tolerance for Feinstein's liberal politics and random snark of President Trump unnecessarily injected into the story because Feinstein can't help himself.

In the end, I was expecting more about the hows and whys of QBing and not a recitation of the careers of 5 men I am not particularly interested in. I also found Feinstein's taking on the Kaepernick and anthem kneeling antics unnecessary to the story of the QBs. Feinstein only presents the left's view of the events, which is fine since it's his book and he can write about that he wants. I think it is also because he doesn't know/understand the other view point or even acknowledge that another view exists. I don't recommend this book unless you are fine with the first three items I listed above.

Not Feinstein’s best.

I am a big fan of John Feinstein but this was not his best. I was looking forward to this book but was very disappointed. There was too many quarterbacks in the group and none the top five in the league. I would have preferred he limited it to just two like he did with pitchers in Living On The Black. Seemed to bounce around both with teams, players, and time way too much. Also, he repeated stories and facts often. Felt like there was no editing done on this book and it was just rushed to get it out before the end of the NFL season. Can’t wait for his next book but this was not one of his better books.

Good, But Not Great

This is an interesting compilation of conversations with a diverse mix of five quarterbacks - four current and one from the 1980s. Feinstein spent considerable time with each, discussing their thoughts on playing the position, managing expectations, assuming a leadership role in the huddle and locker room, balancing work and life, adjusting to the highs and lows of victories and defeats, and managing a career.

The book falls short in several critical areas.

First, there's a lot more conversation than analysis. The author doesn't focus enough on common themes and differences. And he didn't appear to interview many others - head coaches, position coaches, front-office guys, teammates, etc. - to provide additional perspective on players (though he did rely on some media reports, as I recall).

Second, he bounces from quarterback to quarterback and present to past. It's not easy to follow the flow of the book in the audio format.

Third, he repeats a lot of information two or three times during the course of the book - like details of key games and seasons. It's not as though two of the quarterbacks were part of the same event. He just repeats certain details 50 or 100 pages later when profiling a particular quarterback.

Fourth, the book contains some inaccuracies that the author or an experience editor should have caught. Mike Gillislee wasn't a rookie in his first year as a Patriot; he had played multiple seasons with two other AFC East rivals. The Patriots didn't receive a third-round pick from the Colts in the trade for Jacoby Brissett; they received receiver Philip Dorsett (a second reference to the trade was correct). The Texans' head coach is Bill O'Brien, not Tom O'Brien. And there were at least two other similar errors that I noticed just from listening - not researching other statements in the book.

On the plus side, I continued listening. I learned some things. I have a greater appreciation of Alex Smith, Kirk Cousins, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Joe Flacco, and Doug Williams (though he plays a minor supporting role to the four others). And the author/reader has a very deliberate speaking style and cadence. This is the first book that I could play easily at 1.5X speed. Usually I can do only 1.25X.

I wish I could give about a 3.5, or even the 3.7 average at the time I write. I don't want to diss Feinstein because it's a good book. It could have been more thorough and a little more accurate.

Not the best story

Big John Feinstein fan. I’ve read most of his books. Have to say this book lacks depth. A lot of play-by-play from the season, but not as much inside information as would like.

not his best work

I'm a huge Feinstein fan, have read all of his books. This wasn't my favorite. He projected a little too much and (at times) talked more about Donald Trump than quarterbacks.

Interesting tidbits bogged down by unfocused writing

I do not mean to disparage Mr. Feinstein. It's clear he's a great historian of the game did in fact provide a lot of very interesting tidbits about the game of football. The only issue is that apart from some interesting quotes by the quarterbacks interviewed, and a very interesting chapter on the career of the very first black superbowl winning quarterback, the book falls short of it's promise. It's bogged down by formulaic recaps of every game in each quarterback's career while providing very little insight other than repetitive clichéd phrases on how the quarterback takes the glory and the blame for the triumphs and lows of the team. Truthfully if you've watched games by these quarterbacks and have seen any interview then there is almost no new information here for those curious. I was drawn in by the promise of gaining insight into the position. However I had to stop reading from boredom since I couldn't take having games and seasons I had already watched dryly recapped with the same zest as a BBC anchor covering international news of the day. These recaps are broken up by meandering tangents that never led to a great insight or provided any information of value.

It occurs to me that perhaps Mr. Feinstein's mistake was choosing quarterbacks that are still playing in the league. These men have many reasons to be as guarded and protective of their inner machinations as they can be. They don't want to be put at a competitive disadvantage by opening themselves up in a book that will be out and read while their careers are still in swing. Perhaps this is why the most brilliant and palatable parts of the book were when the author focused on Doug Williams. Who was open, honest, and refreshing. With his other subjects not providing anything of value perhaps the author then sought to fill out the needed content with painstaking summaries of each season.

I hope that Mr. Feinstein revisits this subject some day. With the intention of providing subjects that are not afraid to really distill why only a very selective amount of people on this planet can play well enough to not get benched.

Quarterback is a winner!

Very insightful. I am a John Feinstein fan and he delivers another winner with this book!