Pearl Harbor Christmas

A World at War, December 1941

De: Stanley Weintraub

Narrado por: Malcolm Hillgartner

Christmas 1941 came little more than two weeks after the attack on Pearl Harbor. The shock - in some cases overseas, elation - was worldwide. While Americans attempted to go about celebrating as usual, the reality of the just-declared war was on everybody’s mind. United States troops on Wake Island were battling a Japanese landing force and, in the Philippines, losing the fight to save Luzon. In Japan, the Pearl Harbor strike force returned to Hiroshima Bay and toasted its sweeping success. Across the Atlantic, much of Europe was frozen under grim Nazi occupation.

Just three days before Christmas, Churchill surprised Roosevelt with an unprecedented trip to Washington, where they jointly lit the White House Christmas tree. As the two Allied leaders met to map out a winning wartime strategy, the most remarkable Christmas of the century played out across the globe.

Pearl Harbor Christmas is a deeply moving and inspiring story about what it was like to live through a holiday season few would ever forget.

Stanley Weintraub is a National Book Award finalist, professor emeritus of arts and humanities at Penn State University, and the author of numerous histories and biographies, including Silent Night, and 11 Days in December. Editor of a ten-volume edition on the works of George Bernard Shaw, he lives in Newark, Delaware.

©2011 Stanley Weintraub (P)2011 Blackstone Audio, Inc.

Reseñas de la Crítica

“A minor genre, the day-by-day chronicle, receives a fine addition as veteran historian Weintraub devotes a chapter each to the last ten days of 1941 plus New Year’s Day…Readers will enjoy his opinionated portraits of the allied leaders as they hammered out strategy, much of which was rendered irrelevant by subsequent events.” ( Publishers Weekly)

A fun read

I will agree with another reviewer, in that this book is mostly useful if you already know the subject to a decent degree. But I've read literally hundreds of WW2 books, and I'm now to the point that I enjoy day by day breakdowns of events. This isn't really that detailed,it's only 5+ hours, so that alone lets you know how limited this is going to be, but I enjoyed listening to it.

I will also agree, however, with the author being fully in love with that wantabe dictator and socalist FDR. Also, like all good FDR foot soldiers, he hates MacArthur. Outside of that, I think he does mostly a fair job with most things, and that comes based off a lot of reading of otherbooks.

History that's actually interesting

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

This tells the story of what happened to various people in the month or so after Pearl Harbor. It reads like a naritive of news events but in an interesting and provocative format. It takes the reader to several theaters of war and deffinately gives the essence of what people who were living must have heard and felt. History doesn't get better than that!

What does Malcolm Hillgartner bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

The narator give the piece a sence of what those living it heard.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

This was a book that I did listen to in one sitting. I couldn't put it down!

Any additional comments?

Try Professor Weintraub's other war book "The Last Great Victory" If you liked this you'll like that too.

FDR WAS NO SAINT

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

The slant towards making the racist socialist, FDR, appears to be a saint, and responsible for everything good that happened in America and overlooking all the evil and bad things he did, aside this was a good book.

What did you like best about this story?

brings to light the history of how hard things were in 1941.

Would you listen to another book narrated by Malcolm Hillgartner?

yes

Was Pearl Harbor Christmas worth the listening time?

yes

Pearl Harbor Christmas

Not much has been written about this early period of the US entry into WWII. This fills in many of those blanks.

A once-over-lightly wartime potpourri

There are a lot of books like this, and they’re always fun. Weintraub has clearly culled news items, letters, passages from published memoirs, etc., all relating to that wartime Christmas season. The book is global in scope, including glimpses of the Philippines, Singapore, and Russia, but with an emphasis, of course, on Churchill’s visit to the White House. The book probably wasn't very hard to write, and WW2 buffs won’t find much new, but it’s certainly entertaining. Notable — but also not surprising — is the highly unflattering portrait of Douglas MacArthur, lying to the nation as well as to his own troops and even making stock market moves in the midst of retreat.

not quite as advertised

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

would not, unless they knew the real subject. This is NOT about Pearl Harbor, but the politics in late December in Washington. It also poorly connected the events described.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

Book just trails off on a certain date

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

Narrator was just ok, could have made it more interesting.

Did Pearl Harbor Christmas inspire you to do anything?

not really. as a pacific war history buff, I just moved on.