The Cleaner

By: Elisabeth Herrmann

Narrated by: Imogen Church

Length: 14 hrs and 23 mins

Publisher's summary

A gripping thriller with a dark secret at its heart.

Pools of blood, scenes of carnage, signs of agonising death - who deals with the aftermath of violence once the bodies have been taken away? Judith Kepler has seen it all. She is a crime-scene specialist. She turns crime scenes back into habitable spaces. She is a cleaner. It is at the home of a woman who has been brutally murdered that she is suddenly confronted with her own past. The murder victim knew Judith's secret: as a child Judith was sent to an orphanage under mysterious circumstances - parentage unknown. And the East German secret police were always there, in the background...When Judith begins to ask questions, she becomes the target of some powerful enemies. Nothing will ever be the same again.

©2011 Elisabeth Herrmann (P)2017 Bolinda Publishing Pty Ltd

Great Thriller

I fell in love with the main character’s gritty toughness. Judith is fascinating and the premise of the story is enthralling. Following Judith through her search for the truth is emotional and riveting. Because it is set in Germany it can be a little confusing to follow. It has a complex narrative so I had to re-listen to parts. I also had to research some of the history to understand some basics. Don’t let that scare you away though. It’s absolutely worth it. I’ve ordered it in paperback and plan to reread it. It’s that good. As alway, Imogen Church soothes and lulls you away from reality. Listening to her voice is escapism for me.

Reader was very distracting

Imogen Church has a truly perfect voice when she's simply reading, which I wish she would do. Unfortunately, she is almost always overly dramatic - using strange emphasis almost every other word! She has a terrific knack for accents - her American accent was pretty perfect - but her male characters are cartoonish doofuses, which I don't think is the intention of the author. I was really disappointed by her performance, and I think it threw off my ability to listen fairly to the actual content of the story.

10 Hours In - Could Not Finish

You read that right. I listened to 10 hours of this novel and finally gave up with just two more hours to go. Can a book be considered to be “over-written”? If so, that’s how I would describe this novel. Being equal parts tedious and overworked, I kept finding myself taking breaks. The last break lasted a few weeks and I realized it was time to throw in the towel.

First of all, this novel would have been significantly more relevant if published 20 years ago when the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the Cold War was only a decade out. Since this author is no Clancy and the historical context is no longer part of the West’s psyche, the story itself seems dated.

This book has too many layers and too many over-the-top coincidences to be believable. The “love story” is entirely absurd.

Last but not least, this book needed a heavy-handed editor to provide the novelist some tough love. There were too many superfluous storylines that dragged this novel further into the literary mud.