Clive Merrison and Michael Williams star as Holmes and Watson in the fifth collection of stories from the unique fully dramatised BBC Radio 4 canon.
'The Lion's Mane': Holmes has retired to the Sussex countryside to tend bees. But old habits linger, especially when there is a case of murder waiting to be solved.
'The Veiled Lodger': Mrs Merrilow has the perfect lodger - a gentle woman who keeps to herself and has paid the rent regularly for seven years. But why won't she show her face?
'Shoscombe Old Place': The connection between a dog and its bone has never been more important than in this case which leads Holmes and Watson to a gruesome discovery in an old crypt.
'The Retired Colourman': One of the last cases recorded, the detective is in a ruminative mood as he tackles one of the most controversial cases in the canon.
Where does The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
I listen to this one over, and, over again. I would place this in my top 5 books.
What other book might you compare The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes to, and why?
39 Steps with Robert Powell - a superb narrator, I have a number of his narration so. This is a stunning story with mystery, great descriptions of the scenery, and Powell makes it sound like a group of actors are playing the parts.
Which scene did you most enjoy?
The scenes at the beginning o f each Sherlock Holmes are best, they lead you into the story in many different ways, always surprising yet familiar.
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
Holme's vulnerability and frustration. There is usually at least one moment in each story.
Any additional comments?
I have been listening to talking books since the early 80's, usually on cassette. Audible transformed this listing into something that was easy to access, usually of a very high quality, and with an excellent catalogue. Thank you Audible.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
What made the experience of listening to The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes the most enjoyable?
It is a full BBC dramatisation
Any additional comments?
Unfortunately, the voices of Holmes and Watson were too close, audibly, for easy distinction. This is the only flaw in what is otherwise a superb broadcast.
I think Bert Coules' adaptations are my favourite dramatizations of classic Holmes. He stays true to the mystery plots yet the fresh touches that he adds are so pitch perfect that they often feel like they were missing pieces that should have been there all along! Many times it's a little character moment, but occasionally a reorganization of how the entire story is told. In this collection I particularly love his clever reworking of The Lion's Mane that made it a more satisfying story that I want to listen to again very soon.
Well it all had to come to an end sometime and how sad it is to reach this. I have all of these fabulous productions & wish there were more.
We listen regularly and never get bored, how can you, its Sherlock & with Clive & Michael at the controls, you have the perfect couple to keep you entertained for hours ... Thank you Mr Conan Doyal for the hours of pleasure you have brought 'millions' & will continue to do so.
And thank you Clive Merrison & to the late Michael Williams, the best Sherlock & Watson on radio.