Death in D Minor

By: Alexia Gordon

Narrated by: Helen Duff

Length: 8 hrs and 22 mins

Publisher's summary

After solving a string of murders and getting used to living with a snarky ghost, Gethsemane Brown tries to rest easy. But in this second book in the series, her roomie disappears, her landlord decides to sell her cottage to a developer, and her brother-in-law comes to visit. The ever-resourceful African American musician and expatriate scrambles to call her spectral roomie back from beyond and to find a way to save the cottage from destruction, but those concerns take a backseat when her brother-in-law is accused of stealing a valuable antique. In order to try to save him, Gethsemane strikes a deal with an investigator to go undercover and snoop for evidence of a forgery/theft ring. But while snooping, she accidentally conjures the ghost of an 18th-century sea captain, ends up the prime suspect for a murder, and races to untangle a web of phony art and stolen antiques to exonerate both herself and her brother-in-law before the killer targets her.

©2017 Alexia Gordon (P)2017 Dreamscape Media, LLC

Did not like the narration

The story is great, but the narration really was a bit terrible. I felt like the “voices” and intonation did not match at all the emotions and meanings from the characters.

Earns 5/5 Ghostly Sidekicks…Accident or Not!

Gethsemane Brown, ex-pat living in Ireland, is quite the virtuoso in more than music; she has proven to be pretty good at sleuthing, too. Her skill gets challenged when the surprising appearance of her brother-in-law and museum curator Jackson Applethwaite, set to bid on an early American miniature sampler on behalf of his museum, turns into his being accused of theft when the sampler goes missing…but could it be murder when the owner of the sampler is found dead? Inspector Iollan 'Niall' O’Reilly of An Garda Síochána (The Guardian of the Peace—Irish police) has approached Brown for her assistance in their investigation of a ring of art forgers and thieves, so things get very serious. She tries to conjure up her helpful ghost Eamon McCarthy to help exonerate her brother-in-law, but something goes delightfully wrong.

I enjoyed this story so much that I decided to revisit it by listening to the audio version narrated by Helen Duff. I am now a big fan of Alexia Gordon’s Gethsemane Brown Mystery series, but newbies can comfortably start with book 2 “Death in D Minor,” the story provides enough details and descriptions into the back story and character connections to keep you very engaged: Irish countryside? Ghostly sidekick? Forgeries? Murders? Who knew being a classical musician could be so…precarious! The story was exciting, nail-biting at times, humorous, and clever using the idea that Gethsemane can ‘summon’ up ghosts, even the wrong ghost, giving so many opportunities for a paranormal twist. It works! It is not juvenile hocus-pocus. Gordon’s characters are well developed with Gethsemane becoming one of my favorite amateur detectives. But, Captain Lochlan, an eighteenth century ship’s captain, adds such a delightful dynamic! Playing out in the background we have intriguing references to needlework, comparisons with Irish and Black history, hints of romance, and continued issues with Gethsemane being an ex-pat. No matter what version, I really enjoyed this second book and highly recommend you go read book 1 “Death in G Major” to see how it all began.

The audio version, narrated by Helen Duff, is an absolute delight, and I loved revisiting this story. She is a different narrator from the first book, “Murder in G Major,” which provides the opportunity for comparison. Duff is a very talented voice artist, but she has a deeper resonance to her voice giving her more success with the male characters, whether American or Irish. She interprets Gethsemane’s Virginia background differently offering a slight southern drawl..,definitely a slower cadence. I choose to change the speed slightly (1.0 to 1.25) which helped alleviate the slower speech. She does extremely well with the various Irish brogues, and did I hear a more educated British accent for her third-person narrator? Her interpretation of the Latin incantations, speed of the auctioneer, and all the emotional ups and downs were excellent…very entertaining! This is why I am such a fan of audiobooks.

Drove slower just to listen to it

The voices and imagery, humor and wit are a great listen! I highly recommend this book!

Entertaining and Cozy

Not great literature but very readable and entertaining. I would say this is light reading with low emotional involvement and is pretty “cozy.” This is perfect pandemic diversion! All in all, it was worth my credit.

Terrible, Terrible Narration!!

The story was okay, but who selected this narrator? Her voice has none of the personality or liveliness of "Southern speak." I rate her at terrible (just a notch above awful) because she voices some of the characters 'okay' but for Gethsamane, the main character - listening to her was painful! I really want to finish the series but I see that the same narrator is used for some other titles. I don't know if I can take any more of that!

Art crime

In Death in D Minor by Alexia Gordon, Dr. Gethsemane Brown is enjoying her well-deserved break over Christmas when she gets involved in a major art fraud case. Getting news that Jackson, her brother-in-law, is coming to visit her in the small Irish town where she teaches music, Gethsemane hurries to get ready to host him. As a museum curator who serves as a significant expert on textiles, Jackson has arrived for an upcoming auction where a priceless embroidered sampler from the 18th century is up for bid. At the auction, the sampler goes missing and gets found in Jackson's jacket pocket. Trying to help Jackson against charges of theft, Gethsemane, a great musician, goes undercover as a pianist at a party held by Olivia, the owner of the sampler, and searches Olivia's office. But then she looks out the window and spots the body of Olivia as having been thrown out the window. And now Gethsemane is a suspect. Plus, Olivia's will has gone missing as well.

This book is interesting, with a creative plot. However, there are so many characters that I couldn't keep them all straight. That made the book confusing. Further, the plot got pretty convoluted and hard to follow at times. I also missed the character of the ghost of Eamon, who made the previous book so delightful. The ghost of an 18th century sea captain makes a few appearances, but he does not have the same flavor as Eamon.

I really appreciated the performance of Helen Duff, who makes this audiobook much more enjoyable than I think it would be to read it. She does terrific accents so that even Gethsemane can be understood as a Southern African American woman, long before it becomes clear from the context.

I strongly loved Murder in G Major, the book that comes before Death in D Minor. But this book does not live up to the standard set by the prior book. I found it disappointing but still enjoyed this book. I give it four stars.

Fun story but terrible narration

Listening to this audio book immediately after the first book of the series made it painful to listen to the narrator’s attempt at the different accents. Also the narration was so slow that I had to listen at 1.5x just for it sound normal.

good story

Good story, lots of characters, fun twists and I enjoyed the narrator. Would love to see another movie made as well, the first one is wonderful.

Change in narrator makes it too jarring to enjoy it

First book was wonderful read by the delightful Jessica Carroll. While her American accent wasn’t great I understood why and at least I could overlook it. The narration was great and the Irish characters wonderful. The second book, and I fear the rest of the series, is narrated by Helen Duff, whose accent is as plummy and British as her name. Moreover her pauses combined with that deep bedroom voice make her better suited to narrate books where breasts are tumbling out of corsets. And instead of an innocuous American accent that can be easily overlooked for any mistakes, her “American” accent sounds like there’s about to be a cowboy shoot out at high noon. Her Irish characters vary widely from massively overdone to barely distinguishable from her English accent. I’m so sad because I loved the first book and was so happy to have a new series to enjoy. But with this new narrator, it will be a miracle if I finish the second book :(

Can't wait for more.

This is the second in a series and I was interested to see after a spectacular debut if the follow up could measure up. It did that and more. We expanded the main characters world, learned more about everyone's background. Dipped our toes into another aspect of crime and are introduced to characters i hope to see again.