The Bloody Shirt

Terror after Appomattox

By: Stephen Budiansky

Narrated by: Phil Gigante

Length: 9 hrs and 45 mins

Publisher's summary

From 1866 to 1876, more than 3,000 free African Americans and their white allies were killed in cold blood by terrorist organizations in the South.

Over the years, this fact would not only be forgotten, but a series of exculpatory myths would arise to cover the tracks of this orchestrated campaign of atrocity and violence. Little memory would persist of the simple truth: that a well-organized and directed terrorist movement, led by ex-Confederates who refused to accept the verdict of Appomattox and the enfranchisement of the freedmen, succeeded in overthrowing the freely elected representative governments of every Southern state.

Stephen Budiansky brings to life this largely forgotten but epochal chapter of American history through the intertwining lives of five courageous men who tried to stop the violence and keep the dream of freedom and liberty alive. They include James Longstreet, the ablest general of the Confederate army, who would be vilified and ostracized for insisting that the South must accept the terms of the victor and the enfranchisement of black men; Lewis Merrill of the 7th Cavalry, who fought the Klan in South Carolina; and Prince Rivers, who escaped from slavery, fought for the Union, became a state representative and magistrate, and died performing the same menial labor he had as a slave.

Using letters and diaries left by these men, as well as startlingly hateful diatribes published in Southern newspapers after the war, Budiansky proves beyond a doubt that terrorism is hardly new to America.

©2008 Stephen Budiansky (P)2008 Brilliance Audio

Critic reviews

"Budiansky brings the unpleasant details of the era alive in a smoothly written narrative." ( Publishers Weekly)

Violent Tactics

I wanted to know more specifically how the southern Democrats used fear, intimidation and terror to regain control of their state governments, and this book delivered in scintillatingly vivid fashion. I was delighted by the narrator's characterizations and reviled by the systematically despicable actions of the white supremacists.

The South Won. Don't Kid Yourself

Rarely have I been so supremely angry as I have been listening to this book.

Excellent.

Not boring but has some extraneous detail from the primary sources.

Brilliantly researched vignettes of terrible events and Ku Klux Klan terrorism in post-Civil War Mississippi, Louisiana, and South Carolina.

The Mississippi Plan

Chapt. 29 - Read the text of The Mississipi Plan. It was probably influenced by the French Revolution, and affected so much of the future of world history, and yet it isn't discussed. There is a reason Woodrow Wilson, who was part of it in his teens, is mentioned in Mein Kampf. It's "Rules for Radicals" on steroids. That's just one reason this book is a valuable read. Another would be the untold success of State Gov's run by illiterate former slaves early on. But there is no more hateful arrogance than that of someone who has owned another human being, especially when they find they are thrust into equality with their former chattel. This book gives you scraps of a history almost erased from our books, and may yet disappear.

ANYTHING but Dull!

I can only assume that the previous two reviews of this book were written by people still in denial over the southern reign of terror that followed the US Civil war. This book is a riveting account of that era in American history that has been washed from the brains of most Americans. The dramatic reading of the writings of actual participants only heightens the enjoyment.

If you have the guts to listen to Americans participating in ethnic cleansing of the blacks in the south, you will find this book facinating. And perhaps wonder why you never read about it in your high school history book!

Presaged 2018 in 2008

An incisive and deeply disturbing story of domestic terrorism carried out by the KKK and similar groups which were staffed by Confederate soldiers and officers during Reconstruction. Thousands of Americans were killed, tortured, raped, imprisoned and had their inalienable rights taken away. We all knew reconstruction was a mess but this paints a bleak picture of the reality of these domestic terrorists. This is not some poorly researched opinion piece, the materials were gathered from the state archives of Mississippi, Alabama and South Carolina and show very clearly the intent, desire and hope to suppress the right to life, the right to vote, the right to assemble, the right to bear arms, and the right to express oneself freely. Clearly this domestic terrorism turned the victory of emancipation on its head when the government was unable to enforce its own laws.

It’s also a startling description of media control by anti-American elements in the South. There was no disputing the acts that took place, they were documented and admitted freely and proudly by the participants. Unbelievably and much like al Qa’ida and ISIS, they enjoyed what they did to fellow human beings and sought religious and civic leaders to back them up. Many were happy to do so. Like the Nazis and Communists in Europe, Asia, the America’s and elsewhere, they wanted to disarm, defeat and destroy anyone who challenged them legally, morally or civically. And they were highly successful. What was so surprising was that that their sense of righteousness was offended when their acts of murderous terrorism were discussed. In other words, they did not dispute what happened, they were mad people MENTIONED their traitorous acts. What an evil mentality.

This book tells that story very well. What is also highly interesting is that Budiansky presaged the recent political trolling of today. It is very clear (and equally sad) that the Russians were able to massively influence, direct and even exert some control over the same sense of victimhood still felt in the South today. Today the same dupes are conducting themselves in the same manner as the KKK has always done. Budiansky, to his everlasting credit, unveiled this mentality ten years ago in a brilliant but depressing story that continues to haunt our country to this minute. This is a must read. You will see the parallels between them and now and your eyes will be opened and your heart and soul will be filled with sorrow for the victims but also for our country.

Southern Defiance Writ Large

Budiansky’s The Bloody Shirt reads like a great abolitionist novel. Every black is a noble, intelligent, and courageous victim. Every white liberal is a chivalrous, erudite, and justified savior. Together these two tropes weave a systemic revenge - as heavy as the hammer of the gods - upon the unrepentant, defiant, and violent South. It’s a tale of, “the more things change, the more they stay the same,” as we unblinkingly see Federal power wed to the radical politics of abolition - a politics very much the norm in contemporary America, filled as it is with moral ferver, resentment, vengeance, and hatred - in order to use blacks as a weapon against the deserving South.

And we don’t just see it, we FEEL it, in the judgement of every impassioned and embittered word penned by Budiansky and brilliantly read by Gigante. This is how History should be written: with a side taken and myths in the making.

In the end, audacity abounds, although victories are fleeting and ultimately chimeric. Alas, the war wages on in the spirit of the book’s late chapters: as a spiritual crusade using a heavy-handed morality of tolerance and inclusion to defeat - I mean, win - the hearts and minds of a younger generation, anxious to rid itself of the last vestiges of the Old South for the sake of white guilt, capitalist consumption, and cultural degeneration.

In the end The Bloody Shirt offers all of us a great challenge to become worthy of our forebears and insure that the current reconstruction goes very different from the last.

Boring

I thought the topic would be interesting especially in light of so much talk about reconcilliation in Iraq. I thought it would be instructive to read about the difficulty of healing our own deep cultural wounds. Instead this book is one repition after another. The reader does not help by his phoney, sterotypical southern accent whenever narrating a southern point of view and innocent, bewildered mode of speaking when narrating the northern senitment. The book is only caricature and vauderville.

Dull

Could not get through it. Painful and boring