Serena Stevens is already popular in her new school in the tiny Texas town of Rojo - so popular she has two guys interested in her. Self-assured Lance is a football star, and introverted Cam is an intellectual who gets nervous just working with her on their English project about Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. In a town with a single-minded obsession with football, Lance is a great catch, but there's something unique about Cam. Between the two of them, Serena has the perfect boyfriend...if she can figure out how to keep them apart.
Soon there's much more to worry about when two cheerleaders go missing. Serena starts to wonder: Could one of the guys be responsible? Appearances might be deceiving...and who will Serena end up with when things come to a boil?