Frederick the Great

A Military History

De: Dennis Showalter

Narrado por: Joe Barrett

Frederick the Great is one of history's most important leaders. Famed for his military successes and domestic reforms, his campaigns were a watershed in the history of Europe, securing Prussia's place as a continental power and inaugurating a new pattern of total war that was to endure until 1916. However, much myth surrounds this enigmatic man's personality and his role as politician, warrior, and king.

Dennis Showalter's cleverly written book provides a refreshing, multidimensional depiction of Frederick the Great and an objective, detailed reappraisal of his military, political, and social achievements. Early chapters set the scene with an excellent summary of 18th-century Europe and the Age of Reason; an analysis of the character, composition, and operating procedures of the Prussian army; and explore Frederick's personality as a young man. Later chapters examine his stunning victories at Rossbach and Leuthen, his defeats at Prague, and Kolin and Prussia's emergence as a key European power.

Written with style and pace, this book offers brilliant insights into the political and military history of the 18th century, and one of history's most famous rulers.

©1996 Dennis Showalter; introduction copyright 2012 by Pen & Sword Books Ltd. (P)2020 Tantor

Some good info, horrible narration

Had to slow speed to 75% to avoid going nuts. Narrator pauses in weird places and strings together sentences without pausing in other places. I would skip it even though I made it through.

Conflict, Politics, Economics, Social Expectations all form to succeed.

Slow start to this book. Don’t quit. Like a snow ball starting down a mountain. At the bottom it’s a landslide. This book is the same. By the middle of this book, I was not able to stop listening. On the one hand, I wanted Frederick to win. On the other, I didn’t. This book helps to make it clear why it is vital to have a ready, well-trained, and well-lead military. Read and find out.

Superb

I must admit I knew very little about Fredrick the Great. I remember just the name from what I had learned in school many, many years ago. I came across this book hoping I would learn something, and I did.

This is not a biography of Fredrick Hohenzollern II (1712-1786), King of Prussia, but a review of this military campaigns. Fredrick the Great ruled Prussia as a highly disciplined police state. He is famous for reorganizing the Prussian Army. He was fanatical about discipline and his military became famous as the most disciplined army in Europe. He said that he wanted the men more afraid of the officers than the enemy. He also developed the goose step march that requires enormous disciple and strikes fear in the people. Today, it is primarily used by the armies of dictators. Showalter made a comment that caught my attention, he said, “Fredrick was King of Prussia but should have been in the mad house.”

The book is well written and meticulously researched. I was impressed by Showalter’s writing skills. He presented the materials in a most readable fashion. The book is thirteen hours and thirty-one minutes. Joe Barrett does an excellent job narrating the book. Barrett is an actor. He has won fourteen Earphone Awards, eight times a finalist for the Audie Award and finally won it in 2013.

Military History Fans Will Like

Honestly my fault for getting this. I would have enjoyed this title better had the military been a backdrop for the biography. Instead you get Showalter writing for American military history fans. It makes interesting but surface level comparisons to famous conflicts. I really had to force myself through the last 2-3 hours.

completed negative

u tried but after the 3 chapter or so I felt myself disliking the narrator. the negatively toward everything Frederick is similar to CNN toward Trump. I wanted to read about Frederick the Great not be told over and over that the author didn't like him and so everything he did was bad.

Biased

The author really hates Prussia and Frederick and wants you to know. Very disappointing historiography.

Thrashed insensibly by over writing

I have just survived the onslaught of this overwhelmingly badly written book. Dragged about by streams of long passive sentences, then broken up with a fifty-four word active sentence. Showalter’s writing style was a choke hold of incomprehension. Further, the title is misleading. It is not Frederick the Great’s military history but a history of the Seven Year’s War in which he was a participant. The only place his military tactics were discussed was at the last section of the book.
In the recent New Yorker review of David Reynolds’ biography on Lincoln, the reviewer points out that it is the trend by biographers to rely on the social, cultural, political, and I would add economic conditions during which the person was living. Showalter certainly falls in this category if he is writing a military history of Frederick the great; however, if he had made his title apparent that it was a history during the Seven Year’s War, he would be off the hook. As to the Audible, Joe Barrett was ill-adapted to narrate this book. He was insensitive to the cadences to the sentences, to the breaks in phrases, sentences, paragraphs, and sections. Nor did he help the listener digest the long passive passages that became just noise after a time. Don’t read this book as a one’s first book on this subject. Heck, I would not recommend reading this book at all. Stay clear.

Overly biased book with a poor narrator.

The book is very obviously biased against Frederick. The common 20th & 21st century practice of dropping in occasional compliments, even one in the very last sentence, gives a paper thin disguise to the criticism. Whether the criticism is warranted or not can’t even be debated due to its sheer volume and blatancy.

Also, the narrator is awful. I’m sorry. Maybe it’s a personal preference but he sounds like the old American grandfather you never wanted trying to read you a bedtime story that’s just a bit beyond his literacy level. Variances in volume, speed, and tone cause an affect of feeling like you’re riding a wave through your own personal hell when combined with the author’s dry, seemingly above it all, writing style.

(Audible Review)

Two entire sub-chapters are missing from the Audible version. The entire Second Silesian War is missing from its two sub-chapters in Chapter 2. I removed and redownloaded the file twice to make sure something hadn’t gotten messed up on my end but every time it came back missing those two sub-chapters. Pretty annoying.

unclear and vague descriptions throughout

As another reviewer mentioned, this audiobook is inexplicably missing a huge section on the 2nd Silesian War, making much of the book incomprehensible (since the events of that war are constantly referred to thereafter).

Had it been complete I probably would give it 2 stars. I found Showalter's prose obnoxiously vague and pretentious. instead of clearly describing a certain tactic, for instance, he references a book by Nietzsche that, if the reader hasn't read, will mean nothing to them. He's obsessed with analogies and droll idioms, and I learned very little by his constantly unclear descriptions.