The Sound of Things Falling

By: Juan Gabriel Vasquez

Narrated by: Mike Vendetti

Length: 7 hrs and 41 mins

Publisher's summary

Juan Gabriel Vsquez has been hailed not only as one of South America’s greatest literary stars, but also as one of the most acclaimed writers of his generation. In this gorgeously wrought, award-winning novel, Vsquez confronts the history of his home country, Colombia.

In the city of Bogot, Antonio Yammara reads an article about a hippo that had escaped from a derelict zoo once owned by legendary Colombian drug kingpin Pablo Escobar. The article transports Antonio back to when the war between Escobar’s Medelln cartel and government forces played out violently in Colombia’s streets and in the skies above. Back then, Antonio witnessed a friend’s murder, an event that haunts him still. As he investigates, he discovers the many ways in which his own life and his friend’s family have been shaped by his country’s recent violent past. His journey leads him all the way back to the 1960s and a world on the brink of change: a time before narco-trafficking trapped a whole generation in a living nightmare.

Vsquez is “one of the most original new voices of Latin American literature” according to Nobel Prize winner Mario Vargas Llosa, and The Sound of Things Falling is his most personal, most contemporary novel to date, a masterpiece that takes his writing - and will take his literary star - even higher.

©2012 Juan Gabriel Vasquez (P)2013 Audible, Inc.

Loved the writing; hated the narrator

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

The book, but NOT the audiobook. The writing was lovely, layered, evocative, tragic. The narrator, though, was so awful that I almost couldn't finish listening. He mangled even commonly-heard (in the US) Spanish names and place-names ("Medellin," for instance, and the name "Maya"), read without expression, over-enunciated articles such as "the" and "a," mispronounced random English words, and generally placed vocal emphasis in odd places. Painful.

Great book! Terrible narration performance!

Would you consider the audio edition of The Sound of Things Falling to be better than the print version?

The audio version was a sad missed opportunity! The English translation was very good and natural. The only thing that detracted from the story was the terrible performance of the narrator. Because of him I had to struggle many times as I listened to him bungle words, mumble words and completely miss pronounce words. His performance was devoid of emotion. He would read some of the most gripping lines in monotone. I was very disappointed in that aspect of the book. The story takes place in a Latin American country. The narrator should at least be able to pronounce the characters names and the places in Spanish. Even if it's an Anglicized version of the Spanish name. But this narrator could not even give a terrible English rendition of any Spanish word. The Spanish words were unintelligible and in the reader's mind we were left with no idea what was said. Rather than the words from another language adding a touch of romance or adventure to the story. I was constantly left wondering what the narrator had said. It was frustrating and very distracting. Another thing that was surprising was the editing. I could tell when many of the edits were made. In fact, in the last third of the book, the narrator's voice completely changed. It was like he was on cold medication. I hope the audio version of the book can be re-issued with a more suitable narrator. One with a command of the sounds of the Spanish language. The story is very good and the book is well written. There is plenty of excellent material here for a talented narrator to give us a very moving performance.

What did you like best about this story?

The storyline was full of surprises and intrigue. It's always fun when a story is unpredictable. Learning about Colombian recent history was an unexpected side benefit. Through this book I learned that the drug trade has impacted Colombian society in ways that I never imagined. The author has a wonderful talent for describing the scenes and giving the reader a sense of each characters emotional state as the story unfolds. I really enjoyed the book.

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Mike Vendetti?

I think a narrator with a slight Spanish accent would add so much to the performance of this story. Because the main character is Colombian and he is telling the story. A narrator with a gentle Spanish accent would immediately draw the reader into the story and make it very believable.

Any additional comments?

Please redo the audio version of this book. I would love to listen to it again with the right narrator.

Excellent book, terrible narrator!

This is a beautifully written book about my native Colombia. I had to grit my teeth and endure the reader's abominable mispronunciation of all Spanish words and names. Why would there be no effort made to learn proper pronunciation in order to better render the main character? I particularly enjoy listening to books set in foreign locations in order to gain a better understanding of a culture by hearing the music of it's names. I highly recommend this book to anyone wanting to learn about Colombia beyond what is portrayed in the news. Read the book and skip this audio version.

Simply lovely

While perhaps a bit disjointed in its buildup, this book superbly expresses the nuances and characterizations of a city, individuals, & relationships.

Beautiful descriptions, slow moving story. Important themes about recent history in Colombia

I enjoyed this audiobook very much. My interest is in deciding to live in Colombia for a year and wanting to read a bit of historic fiction. The story is beautiful but it moves quite slowly. I enjoyed the characters, the slow revealing information, Took me quite a few months to complete as I kept on taking long pauses, needing to rewind and listen again to get caught up. The narrators voice is very deep and soothing. I was a bit disappointed that the pronunciations of Spanish words were very far off though. It would not be hard to teach a narrator how to pronounce major cities in Colombia and it would be less awkward. Bogotá and Medellin are not hard to pronounce. Some of the pronunciations almost seemed mechanical, like the name of the university whose acronym was used many times. I am still quite happy about this audiobook but disappointed in the editors for this oversight.

Disappointing Narration

The narrator cannot pronounce even basic Spanish words - including Colombian cities which interferes with this version.

Narration lost me

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

I did not finish this book, in fact I could only listen in total for less than an hour. The narrator 's voice put me to sleep. It is a deep, melodic voice with not enough passion /inflection / engagement in the story. The voice and the story put me to sleep. Not good since I listen while I drive.

Would you recommend The Sound of Things Falling to your friends? Why or why not?

Couldn't get into it.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

It had an announcer qaulity to the voice rather than engaged with the story and its nuances.

Do you think The Sound of Things Falling needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

Didn't listen to enough of it.

'The Damaging Exercise of Remembering'

Against the backdrop of an explosive and defining moment in history -- Pablo Escobar and the Columbian drug cartels, the bloody War on Drugs, the growing cocaine addiction -- Vasquez has set an amazing story that immediately grips the reader. With just his words, he talks to our senses, filling the reader's head with photos and journals, maps and newspaper articles, smugglers flying their illegal cargo, buried secrets, heart wrenching confessionals...and the hippos. An intricate story of the interconnectedness of different characters, different times, seamlessly flowing into a foreign world of heightened senses and paradoxical beauty.

...In 1981, drug lord Pablo Escobar, the vicious head of the Madellin cartel, imported 4 African hippos from New Orleans to be exhibits in his extravagant private zoo. After he was gunned down in '93, the government took possession of most of the animals, leaving a few of the heavy and difficult to transport, hippos behind. The hippos, which had grown to a sizeable herd, basked in the lakes Escobar had constructed, while the zoo around them fell into disrepair. In 2006, a pair of those hippos, Pepe and Matilda, wandered away from the zoo and into local legendom. The mates seemed to have disappeared until in 2009 when they were photographed just 63 miles from the zoo site, grazing in tall river grass with a small calf by their side (dubbed Pepito). Suddenly, stories of marauding hippos terrorizing villagers, destroying crops, killing livestock, began popping up. (You might even remember the NY Times articles on the hippos, or the coverage on TV news.) The government responded by circulating stories of the diseases the *Artiodactyla* carried and *WANTED: Hippos* posters went up throughout Columbia...

Antonio Yammara has just finished reading the final chapter of PePe's life; a picture of the *hunters* standing over the corpse of the one and a half ton black hippo [a squad described by the NY Times, Sept. 10, '09: "Even in Colombia, a country known for its paramilitary death squads, this hunting party stood out: more than a dozen soldiers from a Colombian Army battalion, two Porsche salesmen armed with long-range rifles, their assistant, and a taxidermist." the picture is archived and can be looked up]. Included in the article he was reading was the brutal description of the dismemberment and burial of the animal, and the plans to continue the hunt for the remaining members of this hippo family that fled as the larger hippo was taken down. A familiar sense of melancholy spreads through Antonio. Even his death didn't bury Escobar's violence and greed; the echoes are still being heard and felt. But, this isn't the story of Escobar or his drug cartel, or of hippos.

The memories unlock in Antonio an emotional link to an old mysterious friend...and Antonio begins to recall the series of events that seemed to fall out of the sky and form his life's tragic path when that friend entered his life. Unable to thrust himself out from a crippling cycle of PTSD [Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder], Antonio is obsessed with connecting the events and people, and with answering some tenacious existential questions that have plagued him. The story begins *in media res* -- Antonio coming to a point in his life where the past compels him to find answers in the future at all costs. The title is a metaphorical reference to 2 airplane disasters that tightly connect one time to another, and align the characters. A nightmarish time in history, but as Antonio says, the story is not exclusive to him or the times, "It has happened before and it will happen again."

It is in a smaller sense, a story of the effects of the war on drugs and the people involved, the paradox of the event that harms us is often the thing that heals us. On a bigger scale, there is the universal theme that the dissonance of the past reverberates throughout time and people. The human lives pinned against the "tide of historical events," are the carriers of the psychic wounds, and very often, the price of keeping the meticulous balance of the scales of justice unjustly falls on the fragile shoulders of the innocent... even the hippos.

This isn't a story everyone will like, it burrows deep into a tormented soul and takes you there. Parts of me resisted associating with such a heavy pain. Even days after I finished, I was discouraged, trying to organize my feelings. Vasquez leaves you with the melancholy thought..."Who worries about us when we don't show up, and who can go out and look for us." It wasn't until I got the rebound whack to the head from this boomerang of a book that I realized that I was so blindly affected by the book and was still crawling out of dark places... that's what I call being lost in a book.

Narrator sounds robotic

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

If the narrator sounded less like a robot and more human, even his words ran together.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

Awesome

What didn’t you like about Mike Vendetti’s performance?

Monotonous dull performance by the narrator made it distracting to read along with.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

The plot is great and lots of historical information on Pablo Escobar

A Colombian Tragedy

This is an excellent, absorbing novel nearly ruined by a poor narrator.

The story focuses on a young law professor in Bogota who grew up uncomfortably through the violent years when Pedro Escobar's drug gang imposed random violence on all levels of society--even blowing up a passenger plane in flight to kill a politician who was not on board.

There are several plane crashes in the course of the novel, but the "things falling" include more than airplanes--the professor's life gradually disintegrates after a mysterious older man, a friend he met shooting billiards, is shot dead on the Bogota street. The professor had tried to stop the shooting, but he is also shot and seriously wounded. The story turns to the professor's increasingly obsessive search to understand the friend's life. Along the way, we learn the family history of the murdered man--his grandfather was a prominent pilot for the Colombian military, his daughter raises bees in the countryside. We also learn much about recent Colombian history.

But the narrator is the worst. He reads the novel indifferently, as if he were reading a cookbook. You get the impression as he reads that he has not himself read the material in advance. He makes no effort to differentiate the voices of characters or to put any feeling into their conversation. At times, it's hard to tell which character is speaking because they all use the same resigned monotone.

While the poor narration makes it hard to stick with the book, it's worth the effort. "The Sound of Things Falling" is a thoughtful and moving, if tragic, tale of ordinary people trying to get by in extraordinary times.