Eight Girls Taking Pictures

A Novel

De: Whitney Otto

Narrado por: Joy Osmanski

“A moving read about the pleasures and pangs that define the lives of women” (USA TODAY) from the bestselling author of How to Make an American Quilt.

A profoundly moving portrayal of the lives of women, imagining the thoughts and events that produced eight famous female photographers of the twentieth century. Inspired by the work of Imogen Cunningham, Madame Yevonde, Tina Modotti, Grete Stern, Lee Miller, Ruth Orkin, and others, author Whitney Otto weaves together eight stories, crisscrossing the world and a century to portray the tensions that defined the lives of female artists. These memorable characters seek the extraordinary through their art, yet also find meaning and reward in the ordinary tasks of motherhood, marriage, and domesticity. This is a bold, immersive, and unforgettable novel about women in love.

A Labor of Love

Would you try another book from Whitney Otto and/or Joy Osmanski?

As a reader, I like consume at least two different offerings from an author before I decide whether to add them to my "must read" list. Although it is clear that this book was a labor of love for the author, I found it lacking in a couple of areas. Primarily, I found the stories hard to follow because there were a lot of "flashbacks" (for lack of a better term). Without reading/listening to the book in its entirety at one time, I could never keep up with whether the character was in the present or back in an earlier time.Secondarily, it was difficult to see how the eight girls were all tied together. The author tried her best to insert dates and create a timeline of events from the first story to the last, but again, as someone who was listening to the story over the course of many days, it proved too daunting a task to memorize who was where at what time.The stories, in and of themselves, are good ones and I enjoyed them individually. The characters were well developed, the descriptions of people and places were very detailed, and it was interesting to hear the author's imagined events as they many have been related to the real, historical ones. My disillusionment with the book began when I realized that the narratives were supposed to be tied to each other throughout history, and I could not keep the timeline in my mind. The final story would have been so much richer for me if there had been a clearer image in my head of who lived when, with whom, and where they had traveled.Overall, I would recommend this book for anyone that enjoys photography, as they will find the subject matter fascinating, and those who enjoy short stories.

If you’ve listened to books by Whitney Otto before, how does this one compare?

I have never listened to or read books by Whitney Otto before.

What aspect of Joy Osmanski’s performance would you have changed?

Ms. Osmanski did a fine job narrating the stories of the eight girls as written by Ms. Otto. There were just a few instances where I felt as though the reflection in her voice did not resonate with where I thought the characters were in the story. In addition, there were two places in the narration where I sensed that Ms. Osmanski may have been tired.

Do you think Eight Girls Taking Pictures needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

I do not feel that this book needs a follow-up because seven of the eight girls would have died by the time the last story reaches its end. The subject matter does not seem to lend itself to telling additional parts of the stories of the eight girls.

Wanted to love this book!

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

As a woman photographer, a lover of people and their stories, I really wanted to love this book.
Had the author settled on "what is this book" and picked a position from which to tell the stories of these women, I believe it could have been a wonderful read.

What could Whitney Otto have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

Had the author stayed with a consistent approach to these stories as a whole, kept with the emotion, thought processes, and experiences of the women rather than go on informational tangents I think it could have held together more and been more enjoyable.

How could the performance have been better?

The performance was fine.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

The opening story had some compelling moments that were infused with authenticity and promise.

Any additional comments?

The book seems to suffer from an identity problem. Is it a documentary? No. Docudrama? Hmm, not exactly. Fiction? It is fictional, sort of, but not a work of fiction. An socialist/communist editorial? A poor one. The book is fragmented and disappointing.

It's Getting Monotonous

Separate stories that aren't connecting. Maybe they do at the end but I've lost interest

I Will Listen To This Book Many Times Over...

The above title leaves nothing more to be said... besides this: do yourself a favor & don't miss listening to this gem ♡

I can't believe it's not true!

Would you listen to Eight Girls Taking Pictures again? Why?

It was fascinating, and a great performance!

Who was your favorite character and why?

Lennie, because she reinvented herself so well and because her backstory was such a clear motivation.

Have you listened to any of Joy Osmanski’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Yes, and this one lived up to my high opinion of her talents.

Any additional comments?

I had to check several times to make sure I was mistaken about the facts of this story. It seems so real. The Period detail about women artists is fabulous!