Bound for the Promised Land

Harriet Tubman, Portrait of an American Hero

By: Kate Clifford Larson

Narrated by: Pam Ward

Length: 12 hrs and 26 mins

Publisher's Summary

Harriet Tubman is one of the giants of American history - a fearless visionary who led scores of her fellow slaves to freedom and battled courageously behind enemy lines during the Civil War. And yet in the century since her death, next to nothing has been written about this extraordinary woman aside from juvenile biographies. The truth about Harriet Tubman has become lost inside a legend woven of racial and gender stereotypes. Now at last, in this long-overdue biography, historian Kate Clifford Larson gives Harriet Tubman the powerful, intimate, meticulously detailed life she deserves. Drawing from a trove of new documents and sources as well extensive genealogical research, Larson reveals Tubman as a complex woman - brilliant, shrewd, deeply religious, and passionate in her pursuit of freedom. 

The descendant of the vibrant, matrilineal Asante people of the African Gold Coast, Tubman was born into slavery on the Eastern Shore of Maryland but refused to spend her life in bondage. While still a young woman she embarked on a perilous journey of self-liberation - and then, having won her own freedom, she returned again and again to liberate family and friends, tapping in to the Underground Railroad. Yet despite her success, her celebrity, and her close ties with Northern politicians and abolitionists, Tubman suffered crushing physical pain and emotional setbacks. 

Stripping away myths and misconceptions, Larson presents stunning new details about Tubman's accomplishments, personal life, and influence, including her relationship with Frederick Douglass, her involvement with John Brown's raid on Harpers Ferry, and revelations about a young woman who may have been Tubman's daughter. Here, too, are Tubman's twilight years after the war, when she worked for women's rights and in support of her fellow Blacks, and when racist politicians and suffragists marginalized her contribution. Harriet Tubman, her life, and her work remain an inspiration to all who value freedom. Now, thanks to Larson's breathtaking biography, we can finally appreciate Tubman as a complete human being - an American hero, yes, but also a woman who loved, suffered, and sacrificed. Bound for the Promised Land is a magnificent work of biography, history, and truth telling. 

©2015 Kate Clifford Larson (P)2015 Blackstone Audio, Inc.

Narration is problematic

I like the book. It's one of many Harriet Tubman books I am reading to get a sense of her incredible life. There are moments when I have disagreements with the author's assessment of history. But all in all, I value the text.

I have some issues with the narration. The narrator tries to imitate Harriet Tubman's voice. The imitation is awful. It sounds like a character from a minstrel show. I can't get past it. It's offensive. I wish she just read the words and did not try to sound like her interpretation of a black slave. I mean, Harriet Tubman was from Maryland. The narrator gives her a southern accent. The interpretation was not necessary. It's like if some one read Voltaire's works in the voice of Pepe Le Pew.

Voices Matter

I am offended by the portions of narration. I agree with a prior assessment that the narrator’s interpretation of Tubman’s voice sounds demeaning and inaccurate. Voices, like words themselves, assume a perspective that this Author, being White, could not have. I also find the perspective offered about slavery and the life and experiences of the slave to be woefully dismissive, insensitive and at times promotes a belief of a "benevolent" slave master.

Truth is more fascinating than fiction

I've always admired the original American heorine, Harriet Tubman. Having previously learned about her in grade school, I was unaware that her exploits were for the consumption of children and young adults. An animated video of her inform me that she, was not only was a conductor on the Underground Railroad (the most successful), but also a nurse and spy for the Union Army during the Civil War.

What I didn't know, was that she was also a scout who was instrumental in a successful raid that freed about 150 slaves. While also aware of her charitable work after her exploits, I was unaware of her efforts for women's suffrage.

this is a great scholarly work that is accessible to the General Public. unlike other reviewers, I like how the narratorr changes her voice to give character and depth to the narrative.

this is Harriet Tubman in her glory and her imperfections. All in all, a true American heroine!

Quite Dissappointing

I was excited when I learned of this book and looked forward to finding it on Audible, downloading it and listening/reading a fresh new more nuanced telling of a great American’s story. I am greatly disappointed. Not only does the author attempt to dilute Harriet Tubman’s genuine profession of Christian faith with unfounded suggestions of African animist religious ideas it is filled with supposition and assumption rather than original writings of the main character. The entire narrative is disrespectful in it’s attempt to explain her primary thoughts and motivations and stumbles in a forced sympathy and political correctness. It is written and read in a dry monotone.

Dry with weird narration

Rather dry and academic, though I'd rather have that and accuracy than riveting with too much conjecture. Didn't love it but I finished it and am glad to know more about Tubman. The narration by a white woman was weird and distracting though perhaps, as the reminder that it was written by a white historian, it provides an appropriate level of dissonance.

Sad that we know so little

The book is mostly about the times around Tubman. Regrettably this wonderful life has been mostly lost as so little first hand information was recorded. The story is as good as it can be given the limitations.

Detailed biography

Harriet Tubman is a figure that almost everyone knows, but most know little about outside of her work helping slaves escape. The most striking to me initially is that Harriet Tubman lived until March 1913. Like many slaves Tubman was not sure when she was born, but most estimate that it was sometime in 1822. The length of her life was long, although her mother lived about the same length of time and her father not much less.

My grandfather, was born the year before Harriet Tubman died. I intellectually know that slavery legally ended in 1865, but the personal connection to my grandfather, who passed away in 2005, means that as someone in the middle of my life, I really only have to go back two lives to be connected to slavery.

Harriet Tubman is fascinating. A small woman, and one that suffered a serious head wound from abuse of a slave owner early in her life that caused life long problems, Tubman lived a life of service. Through her work with the Underground Railroad, she helped about 70 slaves to escape directly and assisted with the escape of another 50-60. This is not as many as her legend suggests, but her courage to return at least 13 times to assist slaves to escape is important. However, her story does not stop there.

Part of what is interesting about Bound for the Promise Land is that while many parts of Tubman’s story lack detail, Larson has documented about everything that likely can be documented. But just as important, she placed Tubman and her life in clear context. Tubman as an Black woman, was freer to travel than Black men. Not that she was not in danger, she was, but there were things that she could get away with that others could not. Larson has an interesting discussion about Women Preachers during slavery. There were many slave or Free Black male preachers in the south prior to the Civil War, but women preachers were less likely to be arrested or restricted because they were not seen as threatening. Because of this bias, Tubman and a number of others women were able to preach and gather people together in ways that men were not able to.

Tubman was a serious Christian. Her head injury has been connected to visions, but Tubman took many of those visions seriously as words from God. There are at least a few of them there whether real or intuition, seem to have resulted in people’s lives being saved.

Tubman escaped slavery in 1849, 12 years before the start of the Civil War, when she was about 27 or 28 years old. Her husband did not go with her and when she returned for him, he had married again and did not agree to leave with her. (He was a Free Black man, but any children that they may have had together would have been slaves.)

In the years before the Civil War, Tubman built her reputation in abolitionist circles. Many of the trips she took were to bring back family members. White Abolitionists did provide some support for her financially, but much of her work was financed through her own labor. The continuing story of her life was that while many White supporters gave her money, she in turn gave it away to others quickly and supported a number of people through her own work. Finances were always a problem.

During the Civil War Tubman worked as a nurse in Union hospitals, worked as spy and supported herself through her own labor. She received cash payments for some of her spy work, but much of that went to expenses. Tubman also set up small businesses for freed slaves, but mostly labored herself to cover her expenses. Despite her direct work for the army, Tubman was not directly paid during the war. Tubman was the first woman, but not the only, to lead armed assaults during the Civil War, which made her nickname not just Moses, but also as General Tubman. (Although it was John Brown that seems to have been the first to call her that. She assisted in the planning for Brown’s raid, but did not participate.)

On the way home after the Civil War, a train conductor in New York refused to recognize her government pass and tried to eject her from the normal cars to the smoking car. The result of the assault by the conductor and others was a broken arm and a number of other injuries.

After the Civil War, Harriet Tubman was a tireless advocate of freed slaves, women’s rights and women’s suffrage and the support of poor. She raised a number of orphaned children and supported the elderly. She was significantly involved in efforts for women’s suffrage, even though toward the end of her life, the involvement of Black women in the suffrage movement was explicitly denied in part because White suffragists were trying to link women in both the North and South and Southern women resisted the inclusion of Black women in voting.

Bound for the Promise Land documents through Tubman’s life and legacy the rise of the Lost Cause mythology and how it impacted day to day life for Blacks at the time. In 1869, Sarah Hopkins Bradford published the first real biography of Tubman (with the intention of raising money to support Tubman’s work). In 1886 it was re-written and republished, again to support Tubman. But the re-writing significantly changed the tone and style of the book to minimize the horrors of slavery and to characterize Tubman according to the racists feelings about Black women that was common during the era.

Bound for the Promise Land was not the most literary biographies I have read, although certainly not badly written. But it did not feel as literary as some biographies have. The historical quality was excellent. I really do have a hard time thinking that many other details about Tubman’s life and context could be found that were not included here. Tax records, bills of sale, letters, government records, newspapers, etc., were well mined for information. Explorations of various theories and timeline options that could explain what there is clear documentation to prove (and where there is not enough documentation to prove) are exhaustively recounted.

Harriet Tubman is by no means an unimportant figure, she was knew many of the powerful abolitionists, suffragists and humanitarians of the era. Although she never learned to read or write, her speaking ability served her well. While her fame waned and waxed throughout her life and after, the actual work she did, often under-appreciated at the time, with Frederick Douglass, John Brown, William Seward, William Lloyd Garrison, Susan B Anthony was important. All of these listed viewed her as a close friend.

After that first biography in 1869, there was not another biography until 1943, written by Earl Conrad. And except for children or young adult biographies, not another biography of Harriet Tubman was published until after 2000. Bound for the Promise Land was published in 2004 and about that time and since there have been several other biographies. It is unlikely to me that other biographies will have much additional information that is not present here, but I am glad that Harriet Tubman is getting some of the recognition that she deserves and that there are competing biographies after so little academic attention.

Incredible human being - book too speculative

A story of an incredible person. The author fills too much of the book with speculation and opinion. There is no doubt there is a lack of necessary documentation, but like all great leaders Harriet Tubman was not driven by an ego for fame. Her intention was simply to help others. The book would have been better if the author let Harriet’s documented actions speak for her and left out the speculation.

More research is needed

Tubman is a legend yet extremely difficult to uncover her history amidst abundance of public activity during her time. Hopefully more writings about her life would be published.

A solid bio of a fascinating figure.

A solid biography of a fascinating figure that goes beyond elementary-school level mythmaking.

One of the only Tubman biographies aimed at adults (as opposed to most that are aimed at elementary school students), Larson's biography marshals an impressive array of primary sources and scholarship to present a life that deserves more than children's books. While Tubman's life is fascinating and she is deservedly known primarily for her contributions to the Underground Railroad, her struggles as a slave, confidante of John Brown, Union scout (including leading a raid in South Carolina), spy, and nurse all make for fascinating reading.

Larson describes Tubman's life story as "malleable" insofar as different groups used or mythologized her for different purposes. Obviously, abolitionists found value in her story but later in life, Tubman's story found purchase among elements of the suffragist movement in their quest for voting rights for women (I say "elements" because there was a definite split among female suffragists with a sizable number seeking to exclude blacks from their efforts).

The one real critique is that Tubman's post-war life feels condensed. She lived until 1913 but those 50 years take up a comparatively smallish portion of the book. It's a minor criticism and insofar as Tubman's post-war life was primarily just that of a woman trying to make her way with all the obstacles (minor and major) that people face rather than momentous events, it's weirdly appropriate, but still unfortunate.

Overall, "Bound for the Promised Land" is an outstanding biography that paints a far more complete picture than the children's coloring books that dominate the shelves.

not very interesting

struggled to follow....expected a more variety of interesting topic s but what it says at beginning heading its not in rest