Agricola, Germania, A Dialogue Concerning Oratory

By: Tacitus

Narrated by: Leighton Pugh

These three vibrant texts show different sides of the Roman historian Tacitus (c56–c102 CE), best known for his principal (and much longer) legacies of The Annals and The Histories.

Agricola was a successful general and governor of Britain (77-83CE), a task which he carried out with firmness and probity - in contrast to much of the corruption and repression in place during the reign of Emperor Domitian. Included in his account are the prebattle speeches of both Agricola and the Briton Calgacus.

Tacitus' account of Germania shows a very different land with its many tribes, their habits and qualities in a strongly rural and resistant environment.

A Dialogue Concerning Oratory, by contrast, is placed decidedly at the heart of Roman culture, a survey of rhetoric and the art of eloquence. The ability to speak clearly and well was admired throughout the Greek and Roman eras; educated men were expected to have received training in form and delivery: exordium, narration, period. Tacitus presents individuals who display the art of oratory in various forms, referring to the giants of the past - the speeches of Cicero, Brutus, Caesar and many others were kept in volumes and studied. And they question whether eloquence and the skills of oratory had declined in the age.

Public Domain (P)2016 Ukemi Productions Ltd

Two Out of Three Ain't Bad

The section on Agricola is compelling and interesting. Likewise, the section on Germania gives a splendid description of that territory and the tribes which inhabited it in Roman times. A corresponding map would be tremendously helpful to visualize what Tacitus describes, but I suppose that is the drawback of audio books.
The section on Oratory is interesting, and describes well the finer points which separate that lost art from mere speech, but listening grows tedious after his point has already been made. I imagine that the original in Latin would be required reading to understand how the great orators left their marks upon history, but alas.