The plot was not very entertaining and I often felt the writer made things happen even when they made no sense or fit into the story. The feeling was the ending was the goal and the trip there did not matter.
I like the first book so I guess my expectations were just to high.
Not sure, probably try another.
If you read this after the Killing floor, and appreciated the plot and how the story unfolded then this one, in my opinion does do it as well. The whole story thing seems unlikely.
I never noticed in The Killing Floor, how often the character's conversations end with someone saying "Right?" Almost all the characters say this at the end of sentence,. In this book, with this narrator it's immediately jarring and continues throughout. I found it pretty distracting on top of a mediocre performance. If I listen to another of Child's books, I'll probably listen to a Dick Hill one.
Listened to the first book, it was great, read the reviews for the second and third where everyone dissed the narrater, can't agree with their call. Story line on this one was a little hokey with the militia members being brain dead zombies, but overall it was an interesting story that I enjoyed listening to. By the way, if Mr. McClain is a boring narrater, let me offer up some other books I've listened to. Mr. McClain does a good job, keeps the characters differentiated, only struggled with the female characters.
I agree with some of the other reviewers that Dick Hill is the "real" Jack Reacher, and I have listened to both versions of this book. I have to say that Jonathan McClain does a great job with the non-Reacher characters, and his version of Reacher is certainly acceptable. I wouldn't hesitate to buy the book due to the narrator and actually think that he did a great job with the main villain. The story is one of the better Reacher stories, even if a certain degree of suspension disbelief is necessary. If you're a fan of the series or if you love thrillers of the Flynn, Clancy, Thor ilk, I think you'll enjoy this one.
I came to this after listening to all the other Reacher books, as i had become accustomed to Dick Hill. OK, Reacher sounds different, but I cannot understand the criticism. I thought it was excellently narrated and the voices were good (at least to my British ears).
The story was really compelling and I finished it in two days. Overall a very good listen.
I have now listened to all of the Jack Reacher books, in order, and love the entire series. I came back to one of the Jonathan McClain books after listening to the rest to see if I still liked his narration more than Dick Hill's ... turns out I still do.
I think Jonathan McClain's narration is really good. He does a great job with Beau Borken's voice. For instance, after Holly Johnson attacks her captors, he captures an out of breath, high pitched crazy man's voice perfectly. And I love the cool, smooth way he does Reacher. I was quite disappointed when the series switched back to Dick Hill (who also does a fine job, but not as good as McClain in my estimation). I was surprised to see a lot of reviewers who didn't like McClain, and felt compelled to "vote."
i am still in the process of listening to this book and no doubt i will finish it because it is a great book- i have to say that the narration sometimes makes me grumpy because it is so bad. This book will most likely take me about 3 times longer than usual just because i have to stop listening after a while because this guy is so definitely not Dick Hill. I'm even more upset that i have to make it through a second novel (Tripwire) with the same narrator. Dick Hill brought Jack Reacher to life and I absolutely LOVED his narration and the different characters he was able to make me believe in. Jonathan McClain nowhere near gives the experience of Dick Hill but the book itself is a great read.
His voice is boring. He sounds nasally when he attempts to bring characters to life and I have a hard time figuring out if he is supposed to be doing a man's voice or a woman's. Everything sounds the same. BAD.
barely. I think I may have to use my eyes rather than my ears for the next book. I highly recommend getting Dick Hill to redo 'Die Trying' and 'Tripwire'. It's way too much of a tease to hook listeners in on the first Jack Reacher novel with Dick Hill and then force them to be stuck with Jonathan McClain for the next 30hours of Jack Reacher.
i dont want to take away from the novel itself- it is awesome!
I am hooked on the Jack Reacher series. Suspenseful, action, plot twists!! I find myself sitting in my car and listening as long as possible. This book absolutely meets the caliber of the first book. I'll be starting the third book today!
actor did a fantastic job establishing the distinction between characters.
Reacher - because its Jack Reacher
FBI Director McGregor
When Reacher was crawling through the caves - I also felt claustrophobic listening to the narration.
This is another fun Jack Reacher novel. It's cheesy... Reacher is roaming the US, and is once again thrust into another suspenseful murder/kidnapping/heist. As always, he is invincible, macho, somewhat superhuman, and takes vengeance on this round's evil-doers. The writing is terrible and I don't care, because it's great brain candy.
The one downside is the narrator. One of the FBI agents (Brogan is his name, I believe) is portrayed with the worst possible accent... EVER. I'm not sure the intention, but it switches from terrible Bostonian to terrible Australian... I call it Bostralian. Chapter 22 is possibly one of the best examples. The point is, no one on this planet speaks with that accent. But, if you can suffer through it, the book is a fun listen.