She continues to amaze with the depth of her story telling. Each book is better than the last. Truly enjoy every minute of listening

I love this series. Lose Louise Penny writes with grace and creates characters and settings that make you want to live inside her world.

I hate to give one book after another five stars, but this series is just awesome. I have yet to be disappointed. The characters are realistic, complex and interesting, the plot is not predictable at all, and I appreciate an author who isn't afraid of adding a touch of bittersweet reality to counter balance big drama. And Cosham is the perfect - absolutely perfect - voice for Gamache. This man could read a phone book and keep me riveted.

Loved both the foray into the art world and the development of our familiar characters.

This was the best and most sincere story yet of this series. I loves it.

Have read all, but listened to this one. All of the 3 Pines books are wonderful.

I must remember that I do not like Ms. Penny's writing. This is the third Louise Penny book I've listened to and I seem to forget between that I don't like her style. The reviews are so good that I am swayed by them and ultimately disappointed in the book. Probably they are too emotional for my taste.

I would have liked a list of characters. It was difficult to understand the French.

Best of the Three Pines series. Best story with beautiful ending prose. Have listened to entire series several times.

The plot in this book was not as nuanced and character-deep as the previous books in this series. I like Penny's village and cast of characters but felt too many shallow characters were part of this book. First rate narrator as always! I assume this is an exception to the usual thought-provoking and elegant story lines of her other books.