I have read other Apollo/NASA books but this one stands on its own. Really enjoyed the discussion of the "space race" and the engineering feats it took to take the US to the Moon first. I highly recommend it for anyone interested in what it took to get to the Moon.
You know the story, but the people behind it are the crux of this book. It might be overly technical, but I found it particularly enjoyable since I missed the event on television due to a pesky little war going on at the time.
I've lived in Austin, Texas, for over 10 years, not Houston. World War II is my lifelong interest since my father was a combat veteran in the 8th Air Force. I grew up with pilots, bombardiers, and navigators. They told me many stories of their experiences and I cannot get enough of books and documentaries.
The flow of the story, the energy, the details of first hand accounts, the new stories. I worked in Mission Control and met most of these guys. We lived and breathed NASA history, and this book I found exciting.
The beginning sets the pace.
Yes, the narration has lots of energy.
Oh, it's long. Nice to stop and digest the new information.
Be sure to read Gene Kranz's book "Failure is not an Option." America's greatest accomplishment was Apollo 8 because of the culture change and focus of NASA after Kranz's Tough and Competent speech. Apollo 8 was an absolutely perfect mission and historical apogee for America. When man first left Earth. Wow! Damn near hit the recovery ship on landing. That accurate.
The story is told in a very exciting format. There are many errors that with marginal research should've been caught. Examples of this are the wingspan of the U2 aircraft, confusing Navy SEALs, Frog man and Air Force para rescue men. Other glaring errors are that the X 15 flu 4500 hours. Like I said a great story that was mired in errors, very disappointing.
The narration was excellent (which is key for audio books). Its the old story of the lunar landing but with a depth look into the characters and how everything fitted within the context of the cold war.
I have not.
Near beginning the author says Gene Cernan was on Apollo 14. He was not on 14 but 17. Not much further in, he says the command and lunar modules cost around $100,000 apiece. Simple misprint or mispeak that can be forgiven? I don't think so after he elaborates that this was 10 times cost of Spirit of St. Louis. The lunar module was built under a $2 billion contract for just 12 units.
I am disappointed to discover the author was lazy or an idiot or both.
I have no problems with the narration by Richard McGonagle. Good manly voice for a manly adventurous subject.
Perhaps my interest can be traced to my boyhood, where a launch could stop school. We'd assemble in the library and watch the launch on a color TV set, when seeing TV in color was still exciting. The narrative does meander a bit which can be confusing at times, as stories are introduced out of sequence. The are a number of places in the narrative where the author appears to have made some glaring factual errors. A google search can find you reviews which list a number of them. Those errors did impact my overall impression of the book. Once you get far enough in the book, the narrative begins to smooth out and take fewer jags and so the sequence is much more smooth. I appreciate his descriptions of Aldrin and Armstrong. I'm not sure what he adds to the existing literature. It's an enjoyable book, it just may not be all the reliable.
It's amazing what man can do when they set their minds to it. This really shows how the first astronauts were just regular people with the spirit of adventure. I was amazed to learn how the Government ruined the lives of Neil and Buzz after they achieved such an amazing feet. From a technological stand point, It is truly incredible what NASA did with less technology than what we have in our smart phones. This book also kind of made me realize just how political the space race was and it helped to explain why we haven't been back to the Moon in over 40 years. I for one think we should be setting up a permanent station on the moon before we focus on Mars. I recommend this book to anyone that enjoys Historical books and for people that like books about overcoming incredible odds to achieve greatness.
Sat in my car more than a few nights after I pulled up to the driveway just so I could finish the chapter.