Dotrice makes a slew of mistakes and errors that should have been caught with editing and multiple takes. Not only does he occasionally trip over lines, but he doesn't seem to know how to pronounce a single name in this entire book. It's incredibly jarring to listen to Brian and P-tire and Sancha. Not only that, but his voices are frequently distracting. Aftere being spoilt for talent in the show, the caricature voices are either too difficult to understand, like Varys slurring his words disgustingly, or downright insulting, as with the strange Warwick Davis impression he seems to be doing for Tyrion.
I sincerely hope to find other narrators for the subsequent books, because I have no intention of continuing this series with Dotrice narrating.
This is my first review after hundreds of books. I am writing to try to spare someone else all the misery. The narrator simply cannot handle a variety of characters. If everyone in the book were a middle aged army captain, he would have been awesome. But that's not the case. He made Sansa Stark sound like a dirty old man in a trench coat. In a word, it was ridiculous. An audiobook without good narrating is like a birthday cake without sugar. No flavor. It was so bad that it made me confused at several points because I couldn't understand who the speaker was. This is truly bad narration. Do your ears a favor and read the physical books. The only
hope is a complete rerecording of the series.
A some-what long commute so a lot of time to listen to audiobooks!
Fantastic, enthralling, epic.
Tyrion Lannister is my favorite. He provides some of the best lines in the book. He knows his weaknesses and strengths and uses those to accomplish his goals.
Tyrion Lannister was still my favorite. Mr. Dotrice did an excellent job of reading his lines and providing the emphasis and emotions I felt were needed for each line.
I have seen the series so I knew what to expect from the book (which is refreshing to see how well HBO stuck to the storyline). Even so, I found myself anxious anticipating the next time I could listen to the book. I can't say there were any extreme reactions but there were some funny parts that literally made me laugh, simply because they were so unexpected (and most were from Tyrion Lannister). However, even knowing the fate of Lord Stark prior to reading the book, the anxiety of the moment was still there.
I'm not big on fantasy stories but A Game of Thrones (and the saga A Song of Ice and Fire) isn't your ordinary fantasy. In my opinion, it truly rates high with The Lord of the Rings. You become attached to characters and truly come to love or hate them. The descriptions are vivid to the point you can actually envision the person or item being described. Each chapter brings anticipation about the next chapter about the character but your anticipation on another character is relieved. And the narration by Mr. Dotrice was exceptional to the point that I could believe the character voices were what that character would really sound like. Overall, an incredible novel with great narration.
I love this series. I've read it already but decided to go through it again, but this time through audible.
In a story that is built off the richness and complexity of characters, it behooves the narrator to familiarize himself with the names, ages, and personalities of at least the main cast. This guy consistently misreads names, puts on an idiotic oaf voice for large and fierce characters, narrates a teenage boy's dialogue in the voice of an old man, and makes practically every other make character out in the same gruff voice. Completely ruins the diversity and dynamics of this great sory.
Further, after 30+ hours of him, I can say his prose and tone at times are just odd. They confuse the meaning of the passages and are littered with random pauses and abrupt continuations. It's like an actor breaking the fourth wall. His performance really jars you out of the story and is completely distracting.
It's a crime this guy goes on to narrate several more books in this series. I hope he improves, he's just awful.
I love the Game of Thrones series on HBO so let's just get that out of the way. And it may not be fair to compare Roy Dotrice's performance to those of the amazing actors on the show, but it's really hard to listen to his vocalizations of Tyrion and Varys after seeing them so expertly portrayed by Peter Dinklage and Conleth Hill.
If you are coming to the books fresh, you may find Mr. Dotrice a good narrator. He does put a lot of variety in his characterizations and inflections. It's just that for me they were almost all bad choices.
Plus, the language of the books is very unique and Mr. Dotrice's accents did not assist in understanding. There were multiple moments when I was unclear if I didn't understand what he was saying because it was literally a foreign language (e.g. Dothraki), a specifically medieval reference (e.g. portcullis), or I just couldn't make out the English word he was saying (e.g. Did he say wolf or wife???). I was constantly rewinding to re-listen to sections and wishing I had a transcript. Oh wait, I do, it's called the book!
In fact, I ended up buying a box set of the first four books in paperback, returning my purchase of the second book on Audible and I've found great joy in simply reading them.
The entire series is comprised of amazing writing and storytelling that I just could not allow to be further destroyed for me by Roy Dotrice. I would not discourage anyone from jumping into the world of Ice and Fire, in fact just the opposite, but you should be very wary of these recordings.
The reader made listening very difficult.
Although I understand that there are many characters, and the timeperiod lends itself to "gruff" characters, I didn't like listening to the gruff and harsh voice of some of the characters. It was a difficult listen for me personally.
I have seen the HBO series on game of thrones so I can keep up with the story but i got through 2 chapters and couldn't stand to listen to this terrible narration any longer. I thought I had it set at X1.5 for a minute but it was just the narration. His voices were terrible and the wens voice sounded like big burly men. Please get someone else to read these as I really do like the series and want to hear the books as well, since HBO has rushed things IMO.
Audible Obsessed wishes she had more time for so many audiobooks.
Well, I would recommend the print version since I did not like the narrator's acting. I felt awkward and disgusted at times.
The way that George R. R. Martin makes you connect with the characters and keeps you hooked to long to know what happens to them.
At first I thought It was just annoying and picky me, but then, I should it to my students and they also thought they were listening to the narration of a drunk orc. It is the first time I say this, but I am not going to buy the next ones because of the narrator. When he was only reading and not doing the voices it was ok, but then when he started doing the voices I just couldn't continue. I felt disgusted at parts. This is the kind of book you want to read / listen to in one sitting, but maybe with a different performance.
Because of the book, I started to see the HBO series and see how loyal it is to the book. I surely would go see it if it were a movie.
This book is not for the soft hearted. This is not for the mellow people. If being violent and explicit is what you call adult reading, well, this is it. There are some pretty rough scenes that are pretty shocking. So, if you decide to read it, brace yourself.
I found this book unbelievably well read. I have listened to books before read with feeling, accents and no one does it like the British. From the accents of Wales, Northern England, Ireland and even London's back streets, Mr. Roy Dotrice's reading leaves nothing to be desired. Why that Wiley LIttle Finger can't be mistaken for anyone else! Thanks for making the book come alive with it's pageantry and scope. Mr. Martin's skill of characterization is not diminished by this audio presentation, it is given the breath of life.
Like many, I decided to finally read George R.R. Martin's epic novels after being drawn in by the HBO TV series based on the books. But perhaps the awesome visuals and great cast of actors spoiled me, because I couldn't get in to the audiobooks. I found the narrator's pace plodding and his accents irritating...again, this could just be because I already had voices for the characters in mind. In any case, I finally just bought the series for my Kindle and am reading them the old-fashioned way.