Everyone knows by now that Game of Thrones is a good series, especially if you like fantasy mixed with political intrigue. It is extremely complex, with many different stories happening simultaneously. Mr. Martin does not pull his punches at all. Game of Thrones is best compared to Lord of the Rings, but to me feels more complex and complicated. Unlike Lord of the Rings, there is no ultimate quest for one hero tying the whole together. Rather, it is more about the struggles of individuals in a time of political turmoil.
Concerning the narration however, I have fewer good things to say. Mr. Dotrice unfortunately reads in a manner that jars the listener from becoming fully immersed in the story. He reads as though the book were a history book, stating action scenes in matter-of-fact tones which detract from the feel of the book itself. In particular, he had a tendency to say "please" in the exact same way regardless of context or who was speaking.
I enjoyed this audiobook in spite of the narration, but certainly not because of it.
I love fantasy, but this is beyond the genre. As the the title suggests this is political intrigue and battle, with a modern mindset. Plumb the depths of the soul in search of power.
I could not follow the story line because the narrator's accent made it too difficult too follow
Lose the accent, I could not even get past the first chapter
Lost interest due to accent
The Song of Fire and Ice series is a masterfully done work of literature. The television show is a stunning interpretation of that work. Equally as impressive is the audio book performed by Roy Dotrice. I would recommend this audio book to anyone who enjoys the show, has read the books, or even someone who has little or no experience with the series. Like the show and the books the audio books bring something unique to the franchise. Roy Dotrice is absolutely masterful is his performance. He brings the written word to life in ways that I, an avid reader and audio book listener, have rarely encountered. I would say the for anyone who enjoys the series I would say that the audio book is just as important a piece as the books or the television show.
In A Game of Thrones George R.R. Martin sets the tone for a series that is a true work of art. A Game of Thrones, as well as the entire series, has its place among the greats of fantasy. I would place it among the likes of the greats of the genre and beyond.. It combines the wonder and deeper meaning of Lewis' Lion, Witch, and The Wardrobe. The unfettered sense of adventure of 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea or The Lost World. The world that Martin has created rivals that of the eminent world building authors such as J.R.R. Tolkien (The Lord of The Rings) and Robert Jordan (The Wheel of Time series).
It is a sprawling and imaginative and wondrous book. George R. R. Martin deftly combines the fantasy elements of the book with a gritty realism that captures the attention of the reader and leaves them craving more. Martin possesses a rare quality in an author to create in his writing a sincere and vivid sense of awe in the reader. Literature is a well of that runs deep with a diverse array of masterpieces, A Game of Throne belongs among that number.
I do not care for the narration. The same heavy accent for every character. And the female roles, Roy just does not do a good job of female voice.
The narrator is amazing. He has a voice for every single character. It was like watching a movie.
What can I say - it's Game of Thrones. It's awesome.
Never have - but I intend to.
Yes, it has excellent character driven narrative. The narrator performs many many voices extremely well.
One of the main characters is killed...it was awful. There are many small moments where the characters are teaching the young about the nature of life and the world. Ned Stark tells his children that "The lone wolf dies when winter comes - but the pack survives." That quote is worth the whole purchase price for me.
The man is brilliant. He performs men and women of different races, ages, and sizes. He performs animals as well. Brilliant voice actor.
Yes, When one of the main characters dies I was saying no no no - to my ipod. When the leader of the Black watch speaks to a character about where his true duty lies and that he belongs...got a little teary eyed at that. The conclusion was AMAZING
I listened to this book because a friend recommended it. An excellent friend indeed! On to Book 2!!
Your Brother in Christ
Story of Betrayal
The story has a lot of great characters and vivid scenes. There is a lot of story telling for your money in this book.
I have not listened to any of Roy Dotrice's other performances but this one makes me want to listen to more.
This book has the ability of bringing a person through lots of emotions.
It's funny, but for as sex obsessed as the HBO series supposedly is, it doesn't play near as much of a role in the book. It's there, but it doesn't seem to be as central.
Say something about yourself!
The narrator has a really good sense of the theatrical and a good sense for the inflection and moods that are set in the book. The does not however have the vocal range or acuity for a story with this many important characters. Many of the knights are done in the exact same voice and even some of the women. The voice used for a character may change during the course of the book as well. if Roy Dotrice narrated and there were other voice actors in the audio play it would enhance the story. The director for Roy Dotrice does do an exceptional job.
The TV show is so different from the books that it's like watching a whole new story.
I have had problems in the past reading this series, basically, with every chapter I'd feel more like drinking. Drinking gives me migraines, so you can see the conflict involved in reading this book. That being said, I have thoroughly enjoyed this book being read to me. Mr Dotrice does a wonderful job bringing voices to each character, I'd say bringing them alive but Mr Martin's writing does that well enough.
Can I list the reader as my favorite? I'd really love nothing more than for the lot of them to drop dead. Well, I did like the lady marrying the barbarians. She was interesting. I hope she wins.
For one thing, I didn't feel like pausing the book to think of all the ways the problems could be solved with a good dose of mass murder. I've always thought the book well written, but having the characters illustrated though a second medium of sound made their antics enjoyable rather than maddening. He carefully considered and does his best to provide each character with their own distinct voice. Also I didn't feel the need to drink to get though the book, which meant no migraines for me.
No, I didn't even feel like drinking. I just had fun.
Don't drink and read. Things get weird. Also, this guy, if her reads anything else you should give it a listen. This man is a true storyteller, a craft long dead except to a few.