A 1931 film about a washed-up boxer and his son turns into one of the most emotional episodes Ed and Melanie have ever recorded. They walk through The Champ scene by scene, with reflections on Frances Marion, child actors, and a performance by Jackie Cooper that still stuns.

📬 melanded@whothehellarewe.com
📰 melanieanded.substack.com

The Ghost and Mrs. Muir (1947), a ghost story with real romantic power. Gene Tierney is luminous, Rex Harrison is “Sexy Rexy,” and the ending still breaks our hearts.

📬 Email us: melanded@whothehellarewe.com
📰 Substack: https://melanieanded.substack.com
🌀 Originally released: July 4, 2022

Melanie and Ed begin a new movie-book rhythm with their first book episode: Rules of Civility by Amor Towles — a novel of restraint, elegance, and quiet ambition in 1930s New York.

📧 melanded@whothehellarewe.com
🔗 melanieanded.substack.com

Melanie and Ed discuss the 1951 sci-fi classic The Day the Earth Stood Still and explore why Klaatu’s quiet alien warning still resonates.

📧 melanded@whothehellarewe.com
🔗 melanieanded.substack.com
🌀 Originally released: November 24, 2024

A Technicolor convent clings to a cliff in Black Narcissus (1947), where desire, memory, and madness simmer. Ed and Melanie unpack Kathleen Byron’s unforgettable performance, Deborah Kerr’s quiet power, and colonialist shadows.

📧 melanded@whothehellarewe.com
🔗 melanieanded.substack.com
🌀 Originally released: October 15, 2023

Lena Horne leads a dazzling cast in Stormy Weather (1943), but the film holds back from giving her a real role. Melanie and Ed revisit this musical landmark with admiration and frustration.
📬 Email us: melanded@whothehellarewe.com
📰 Subscribe: whothehellarewe.substack.com

Hepburn dazzles, Grant simmers, and Stewart steals a kiss — but we’re asking what the movie does to its strongest character. Wit, weddings, and one quietly devastating rewatch.

📬 Email us: melanded@whothehellarewe.com
📰 Subscribe: whothehellarewe.substack.com

The team watches Robinson Crusoe on Mars (1964)—Melanie immediately wants a divorce. Monkey chaos, Cold War weirdness, and a survival story that forgets to care.

📬 Email us: whothehellarewe@gmail.com
📰 Read and subscribe: whothehellarewe.substack.com

🔁 This episode originally aired on September 9, 2020.