In our opening episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we begin the search for answers in one of Baltimore's most haunting mysteries: the unsolved murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik. As co-hosts Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters revisit the case, they bring fresh eyes to old evidence and reveal new insights that take listeners beyond what was shown in Netflix's The Keepers. Together, they engage with both familiar voices and new ones, uncovering deeper layers to a story shrouded in cover-ups, power, and the tragic cost of silence. This isn't just a retelling; it's an unyielding pursuit of justice for Sister Cathy and a call to confront the systemic failures that allowed this crime to be buried for so long. Join us as we unravel Baltimore's darkest secrets and fight to honor Sister Cathy's legacy.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to learn more and stay part of the investigation.

In our second episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we continue to peel back the layers of the unsettling truths surrounding the murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik. This episode dives into the voices of those closest to her, revealing details about her life and the days leading up to her disappearance that had never been fully explored. Co-hosts Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters introduce new perspectives and revisit pivotal moments that shine a light on the possible motives and key individuals who were part of the complex and chilling web surrounding Sister Cathy. With testimonies that challenge what we thought we knew and connections that grow more intricate, this episode intensifies the search for the truth and justice for Sister Cathy.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged and follow our ongoing investigation.

In the third episode of our gripping series, Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we share the resilient story of Cindy Lovell, who bravely recounts her years of torment under Father Joseph Maskell at Archbishop Keough High School. Cindy's experiences reflect institutional failure and the silencing of survivors, but her voice is now ready to emerge. Hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins guide this difficult conversation, underscoring the significance of Cindy's transformation from victim to survivor. Join us as we lend our ears to Cindy's inspiring journey and continue the fight for justice for Sister Cathy.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to follow the investigation.