Which Offer Model Makes You More Money: Custom, Templated, or Hybrid?

In this episode of The Nickolas Natali Show, Nickolas Natali dives deep into one of the most common dilemmas service providers face: whether to offer custom packages, templated packages, or a hybrid model. Drawing from personal experiences working with agencies and consulting clients, Nickolas introduces the “Offer Fit Matrix,” a scoring framework designed to help entrepreneurs determine the ideal delivery model for their business based on factors like outcome variance, ICP maturity, sales cycle, and margin volatility.

He breaks down three offer models—custom, package, and hybrid—and shows you how to choose between them depending on your business complexity and client type. Nickolas also shares a compelling analogy from a massage experience in Bali to highlight how perceived customization can maintain client satisfaction without sacrificing scalability. Whether you're an agency owner, freelancer, or founder, this episode equips you with practical tools like pricing guardrails, delivery systems, and even a 30-day action plan to transition smoothly into a new offer structure.

Takeaways

• Feast-or-famine cycles often stem from offer problems, not marketing issues.
• Custom packages win high-value clients but often drain operational capacity.
• Templated packages boost speed and margins but may not serve complex buyers well.
• Hybrid offers—80% productized with 20% modular customization—balance scale and personalization.
• The “Offer Fit Matrix” helps determine which model fits your business, based on 8 scoreable criteria.
• Score 0–6 → use packaged offers; 7–11 → go hybrid; 12–16 → lean custom with controls.
• Use pre-set “modules” to create change orders without slipping into scope creep.
• Custom work should follow phase-gated milestones and bill in 40/40/20 or similar structures.
• Personalization ≠ custom—letting clients choose options (like in a Bali massage) can feel custom while remaining scalable.
• A/B test your offer presentation: templated first, then reposition as custom if needed for big clients.
• Introduce pricing tiers for packages and cap hybrid modules to three for operational clarity.
• Follow a 4-week transition plan to test and measure offer fit before overhauling delivery models.

Chapters

00:00 Feast or Famine Is an Offer Problem

00:35 Balancing Margin vs Momentum

01:28 Real Client Story: Productizing from Chaos

02:50 The Offer Fit Matrix Breakdown

04:55 When to Choose Custom, Package, or Hybrid

06:30 Bali Massage Story: Personalization Without Complexity

07:38 Pricing and Guardrails for Each Model

08:50 Your 30-Day Transition Plan

09:58 Advanced Hybrid Strategy (Sales Call Repositioning)

11:00 Final Thoughts and Action Steps

Want to work with Nick?:

https://allthingsmediallc.com/

Free Resources Made by Nick:

https://nickolasnatali.gumroad.com/

Nick’s Podcast Equipment, Training Equipment and More (Affiliate):

https://www.amazon.com/shop/nickolasnatali

Support The Nickolas Natali Show on Patreon⁠:

https://www.patreon.com/nickolasnatali

What We Use For Virtual Interviews (Affiliate):

https://tinyurl.com/42h624wt

DM Nick on Instagram:

https://www.instagram.com/nickolasnatali