On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and host Conrad Thompson welcome the one and only Dalton Castle to the show!

The Ring of Honor superstar joins the guys to relive some of his most unforgettable entrances and show stealing matches. From the pageantry and presentation to the psychology once the bell rings, Dalton breaks down the art behind "The Peacock" and how he crafted one of the most unique characters in modern wrestling.

Tony and Conrad react in real time as they revisit the spectacle, the athleticism, and the larger-than life moments that made Dalton a fan favorite. Expect laughs, behind the scenes stories, and plenty of flair on this wildly entertaining edition of What Happened When.

MANDO - Control Body Odor ANYWHERE with @shop.mando and get 20% off + free shipping with promo code WHW at http://shopmando.com ! #mandopod

BLUECHEW - Get 10% off your first month of BlueChew Gold with code WHW at http://BlueChew.com

SAVE WITH CONRAD - Stop throwing money away by paying those high interest rates on your credit card. Roll them into one low monthly payment and on top of that, skip your next two house payments. Go to https://www.savewithconrad.com to learn more.

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and host Conrad Thompson welcome Colt Cabana to the show!

The AEW/ROH standout brings his signature quick wit, storytelling charm, and behind-the-scenes insight as the trio revisits four unforgettable battles from Colt's storied career in Ring of Honor:

Cabana & Bryan Danielson vs. Jimmy Rave & Bison Smith
ROH 7th Anniversary – March 21, 2009
Hammerstein Ballroom – New York City

Cabana & Kenny Omega vs. Austin Aries & Rhett Titus
ROH Final Countdown Tour – September 25, 2009
Boston, Massachusetts

Cabana & El Generico vs. Kevin Steen & Steve Corino
Steel Cage Match – ROH on HDNet
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Cabana vs. Homicide
Chicago Street Fight – ROH Better Than Our Best
Chicago, Illinois

From comedy to chaos, technical showcases to brutal brawls, Colt pulls back the curtain on locker room stories, road tales, and the evolution of ROH during one of its hottest eras.

It's laughs, nostalgia, and hard-hitting action—all on this can't-miss edition of What Happened When.

MARS MEN - Get 50% off FOR LIFE, Free Shipping, AND 3 Free Gifts at Mars Men at http://Mengotomars.com

BETTER WILD - Right now, Betterwild is offering our listeners up to 40% off your order at http://betterwild.com/WHW

BLUECHEW - Get 10% off your first month of BlueChew Gold with code WHW at http://BlueChew.com

SAVE WITH CONRAD - Stop throwing money away by paying those high interest rates on your credit card. Roll them into one low monthly payment and on top of that, skip your next two house payments. Go to https://www.savewithconrad.com to learn more.

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and host Conrad Thompson welcome the voice of Ring of Honor, Ian Riccaboni, to the show! Ian pulls back the curtain on his journey behind the mic, sharing incredible behind the scenes stories from his time calling professional wrestling at the highest level. The trio sit back and watch three classic ROH matches, breaking down the moments, the emotion, and the magic that made them special. From the pressure of live commentary to the evolution of ROH's in ring style, it's insight, nostalgia, and plenty of laughs all on this can't-miss edition of What Happened When.

IAN'S IRON PIG CAP - A 5950 Cap Designed in Collaboration with Ian Riccaboni Professional Wrestling Announcer for All Elite Wrestling ( AEW ) and Ring Of Honor. Ian just received the Fightful Announcer Of The Year Award For 2025 and can be seen and heard nationwide on AEW and ROH. A portion of the proceeds from this cap will benefit the Salisbury Youth Association https://milbstore.com/collections/fitted-caps/products/secret-influencer-new-era-5950

BLUECHEW - Get 10% off your first month of BlueChew Gold with code WHW at http://BlueChew.com

SAVE WITH CONRAD - Stop throwing money away by paying those high interest rates on your credit card. Roll them into one low monthly payment and on top of that, skip your next two house payments. Go to https://www.savewithconrad.com to learn more.