Voters Aren’t Dumb. And, Experts Aren’t as Smart as They Think.

Dan McCarthy, who edits Modern Age, thinks that what many believe to be “good” democratic citizenship is completely unrealistic. He challenges the idea that voters need expert-level knowledge and instead argues that elections are really judgments about whether life is getting better or worse. Along the way, he exposes the tension between intellectual elites and ordinary voters and why humility might be the missing ingredient in our politics. It’s a sharp, provocative conversation about expertise, democracy, and who we trust to know the truth.

When We Disagree is on holiday break until early January.

Tell us your argument stories!

• Email guest and topic suggestions to us at [e-mail]
• Follow us on Instagram