Understanding The Second Amendment Through History And Natural Law

What if the fiercest argument about the Second Amendment is solved by going back to grammar, history, and first principles? We bring on Professor Nelson Lund—constitutional scholar and author of Rousseau’s Rejuvenation of Political Philosophy—to cut through the noise with a clear reading of the text, a tour of English militia traditions, and a deep dive into the natural rights foundation that powered the founding era.

We start where the framers started: with England’s uneasy balance between standing armies and a citizen militia, and with Americans’ fear that concentrated military power would swallow liberty. From there, we unpack why the Constitution authorized peacetime armies, why Anti-Federalists worried about oppression, and why the Second Amendment’s operative command—“the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed”—protects an individual right. Professor Lund explains how “well-regulated” meant appropriate rather than heavy-handed, and how the amendment restrains Congress from disabling the people under the guise of militia regulation.

As the conversation moves to modern law, we examine incorporation under the Fourteenth Amendment and the reality that today’s regulations raise questions the founders didn’t face. Lund turns to Locke and Blackstone to argue that self-defense sits at the core of our political morality: government bears primary responsibility for enforcement, but individuals retain the right to repel lethal threats and resist oppression when law fails. That framework helps distinguish rules that enhance safety—like universal airport screening—from unsecured “gun-free zones” that signal vulnerability.

Finally, we explore a provocative civic proposal: revive a modern militia ethos through universal small-arms competence, end outdated exclusions, and use training to foster self-reliance, especially for those most at risk. The result is a fresh lens on gun policy that prioritizes liberty without trivializing safety and treats citizens as responsible partners in their own protection. If you value constitutional clarity and practical solutions, this conversation will challenge assumptions and sharpen your thinking.

Professor Lund recommends The Heritage Guide to the Constitution for more, including the section on the Second Amendment that he authored.

More from Professor Lund Here

Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum!

School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership

Center for American Civics