Send us Fan Mail

Who were Ed and Lorraine Warren, and why are their stories still shaping how we think about hauntings, possession, and evil?

In this episode of Truth Behind the Terror, we step into the world of the Warrens, the real-life paranormal investigators behind The Conjuring, Annabelle, and The Nun, to explore the cases that made them famous, and the stories that made them controversial.

From the Perron family haunting in Rhode Island… to the unsettling case of the Annabelle doll… to the courtroom drama of The Devil Made Me Do It… We examine where belief, storytelling, and fear intersect, and why possession narratives can become bigger than the facts themselves.

This episode also explores the cultural context of the 1980s Satanic Panic, and how fear, media, and mythology helped shape public perception of cases like Arne Cheyenne Johnson.

Because sometimes… the question isn’t whether something is real ... It’s why we believe it is.

🕯️ In this episode:

• The real story behind The Conjuring and the Perron family
• The Annabelle case (and why the real doll is… surprisingly underwhelming)
• The Warrens’ rise to fame and the controversies surrounding their work
• The first use of “demonic possession” as a legal defense
• The Satanic Panic of the 1980s and its cultural impact
• Why possession narratives are so powerful — and so complicated

🎬 Referenced Films:

• The Conjuring (2013)
• Annabelle (2014)
• The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021)

📚 Further Listening:

• The Amityville Horror episode of Truth Behind the Terror
• The Exorcist episode of Truth Behind the Terror

🎧 Support the Podcast

We’re getting close to 2,000 downloads (!), and to celebrate, a limited merch drop is coming soon.

Think:
🦌 die-cut antler stickers
📓 creepy field notebooks
🐺 a subtle nod to Bea the Wendigo

Stay tuned…

🦈 Coming Next: Claws and Jaws (April Arc)
Because sometimes… the monster isn’t supernatural.

🎧 Podcast Credits

Clips used:

• The Conjuring Original Trailer (2013)
• History vs. Hollywood, “Ed and Lorraine Warren Occult Museum Tour Featuring Annabelle”

Music:

• "Curse" - Eerie and Scary Ambient Music by Mehul Sharma (Royalty-Free)

Editing:

• Written, researched, and edited by Carissa

Fan Mail:

• Send your thoughts, theories, or favorite horror rules using the “Fan Mail” button on Buzzsprout.

Send a text

In this month’s Love Hurts episode, we dive into Scream (1996), the slasher that didn’t just revive horror, but rewrote its rules.

From Ghostface’s iconic phone calls to Randy’s infamous survival guidelines, Scream turned horror into self-aware meta-commentary. But where did those rules come from? And why do we need them?

We explore:

• The evolution of slasher tropes
• The concept of the “Final Girl”
• Wes Craven’s comeback to horror
• The real-life crimes that inspired Scream, including the Gainesville Ripper murders
• The tragic 1950 babysitter murder of Janett Christman (also discussed in our Black Christmas episode)

Then we travel back to 1946 Texarkana and the unsolved Moonlight Murders, the real-life crimes that inspired The Town That Dreaded Sundown, and examine how unresolved tragedy becomes myth, legend, and eventually cinema.

Because horror didn’t invent the rules.

It inherited them.

And sometimes, the scariest stories aren’t fiction at all.

Stay tuned at the end for a few modern “Love Hurts” film recommendations — and a teaser for March’s deep dive into Ed and Lorraine Warren.

This episode discusses real-life crimes, including murder and sexual assault. While no graphic detail is included, listener discretion is advised.

• Scream (1996), directed by Wes Craven
• The Town That Dreaded Sundown (1976, 2014)
• Black Christmas (1974)
• Coverage of the Gainesville Ripper (Danny Rolling)
• The Texarkana Moonlight Murders (1946)
• Together
• Keeper
• Bone Lake

Clips used:

• Scream (1996) trailer and selected audio clips
• The Town That Dreaded Sundown trailer

Music:

• "Curse" - Eerie and Scary Ambient Music by Mehul Sharma (Royalty-Free)

Editing:

• Written, researched, and edited by Carissa

Fan Mail:

• Send your thoughts, theories, or favorite horror rules using the “Fan Mail” button on Buzzsprout.

Send a text

What happens when hunger doesn’t stop — even after survival?

In this episode of Truth Behind the Terror, I explore the Wendigo: a terrifying figure from Algonquian First Nations folklore associated with winter, starvation, greed, and the loss of humanity. More than a monster, the Wendigo serves as a moral warning — one that draws a sharp line between survival and excess.

From there, we dive into the 1999 cult classic Ravenous, a darkly comedic horror western inspired by real historical events including the Donner Party and the story of Alfred Packer, the so-called “Colorado Cannibal.” Set against the backdrop of American expansionism, Ravenous uses cannibalism as a metaphor for power, greed, and Manifest Destiny — and draws heavily on the Wendigo myth to do so.

Finally, we contrast mythic cannibalism with real-world survival cannibalism, examining the 1972 Andes plane crash as depicted in Alive (1993) and Society of the Snow (2023), and how folklore can help us understand — rather than sensationalize — human desperation.

This episode contains discussions of cannibalism, starvation, death, and psychological trauma. Listener discretion is advised.

🎬 Films & Stories Discussed

• Ravenous (1999)
• Alive (1993)
• Society of the Snow (2023)
• The Wendigo (Algonquian folklore)

🎵 Music & Audio

• “Curse” — Eerie and Scary Ambient Music by Mehul Sharma (Royalty-Free)
• Film clips used for commentary and educational purposes

🎙️ Production Credits

• Research, writing, editing, and narration: Carissa Willis
• Podcast hosted on Buzzsprout
• Fan Mail button enabled — listeners are welcome to send a message directly through the episode page