Toxic Nostalgia

Send us a text

Nostalgia feels warm and safe, but it can quietly steal your future. We sat down to examine why “back then” can look so much brighter than “right now,” and how to honor meaningful memories without getting trapped by them. From worship setlists and Halo midnight releases to Ezra’s rebuilt temple and Lot’s wife, we trace a line through Scripture and everyday life that shows the difference between remembrance that fuels hope and nostalgia that freezes growth.

We talk candidly about the chemistry of early romance and why chasing the high can sabotage covenant love. We unpack the Psalms’ call to sing a new song, the sting of Ecclesiastes’ warning about idealizing the past, and Haggai’s promise that the latter glory can surpass the former. Along the way, we offer a practical framework for faith and feelings—shifting from information to allegiance—and simple habits that retrain desire: gratitude that names present mercies, creative work that reflects God’s image today, and pruning inputs that keep us living in rewind.

If you’ve ever said “my best days are behind me,” this conversation is for you. We share stories from ministry transitions, the kitchen-to-church leap, and seasons where the highs faded but deeper endurance took root. The takeaway is clear: memory is a signpost, not a home. The future in Christ must speak louder than the past, and hope grows when we face forward with trust, endurance, and simple obedience.

If this resonates, follow the show, share it with a friend who’s stuck on yesterday, and leave a review to help more people find the conversation. Then tell us: what new thing might God be growing in you right now?

Support the show