Theories, Crimes & Sandwich Strategies [89]

Amanda, Tyler, and James kick things off with a bang as James comes in spicy before sharing a very ‘time’-sensitive story. Amanda dives into a time-bending conspiracy theory, and the trio debates one of the greatest mysteries of our time—who really was the Scranton Strangler? Then, things get personal as they discover their IKEA furniture alter egos, argue the correct way to cut a sandwich, and settle the age-old debate on the right and very, very wrong ways to use butter. Just when you think the chaos is over, James stuns everyone with a shocking revelation: he has never heard of apple butter. Cue the outrage. It’s conspiracies, crimes, and culinary confusion—so, business as usual!