In 1994, 13 year old Nicholas Barclay disappeared from his neighborhood in San Antonio, Texas. At first, police thought it looked like maybe another run-away case. Then years later a call came in from Spain. Someone claiming to be Nicholas had been found alive. But almost immediately things didn't line up.

His appearance was different, his eye color was different and his story kept shifting. Eventually, investigators realized this wasn't Nicholas but a serial imposter who had done this before.

On Christmas Eve 1945, a house fire changed the Sodder family forever. By morning, five of their children were gone- and what followed never quite added up.

In this episode of The M Word After Dark, we walk through the Sodder family's story piece by piece. From a rushed fire investigation to strange details that refuse to sit right, this case lives in the space between official explanations and doubt.

Listen in, and decide for yourself what you think happened that night.

In the early 1980s, a series of brutal attacks shook Minnesota- but it wasn't just the violence that haunted investigators. It was strange 911 phone calls.

After each attach, a man would call 911 with his voice trembling, crying and apologizing for what he'd done. He wept, he begged, he asked to be stopped all while refusing to turn himself in.

This week is a Monday Murderer episode where we dive into the chilling case of Paul Stephani, also known as the Weepy Voiced Killer.