What’s the correct way to say Craig? The trio may never agree, but it doesn’t stop Tyler from questioning the sound of his own voice (maybe he just needs to try sexier words). Amanda brings a list of video games with cutscenes longer than a feature film, Pokémon somehow gets dragged into the chaos, and Tyler’s possible cult status comes under investigation. James has an IMDB meltdown, Amanda tests the boys with some pop psychology, and we learn that while Amanda can be spontaneous, she absolutely does not like surprises.

This week, the gang uncovers just how petty Tyler really is before diving into a Craigslist ad that’s as strange as it is concerning. Amanda introduces everyone to the tale of the Gentleman Pirate, random thoughts derail the flow as usual, and the age-old question is asked: does a cyclops wink or blink? Things take a chaotic turn when the Global Peace Index of 2025 makes an appearance, and Amanda’s innocent questions about seagulls give Tyler flashbacks he’ll never recover from.

It’s another day, another batch of chaos as Tyler dusts off his old webcam and immediately turns the outro into a disaster. Amanda and Tyler compare notes on their very different (but equally ridiculous) injuries, the gang wonders what happens when you replace the word girl with squirrel in every song, and Amanda unveils the four official levels of crazy. James and Tyler squeeze in yet another fiery game rant, and somewhere in between, the trio discovers some of the most popular items sold in the world. Spoiler: it’s as random as it sounds.