Stacey Castor - The Black Widow Who Poisoned Her Husbands

Stacey Castor: The Black Widow Who Poisoned Her Husbands

She dialed 911 herself.

That’s what makes the story of Stacey Castor so chilling. Every time someone in her life collapsed, convulsed, or stopped breathing, she was the one who called for help. Calm. Controlled. Convincing.

First, her husband Michael Wallace died suddenly. The cause appeared to be antifreeze poisoning. Years later, her second husband, David Castor, was found dead under eerily similar circumstances. Again, antifreeze. Again, Stacey at the center of it. But this time, something didn’t sit right.

When investigators began to pull at the loose threads, the carefully woven narrative started to unravel. A staged suicide scene. A forged will. A typed confession letter planted to frame her own daughter. And a turkey baster quietly discarded in the trash, mundane and ordinary, yet tied to something far more sinister.

In this episode of Deadly Intent, we examine how manipulation can wear the mask of grief… how control can masquerade as chaos… and how one woman nearly got away with murder not once, but twice.

We’ll break down:

• The timeline of both deaths
• The antifreeze poisonings and forensic turning points
• The staged suicide scene that exposed everything
• The psychological profile behind the “Black Widow” narrative
• And the moment her plan collapsed under scrutiny

This is a case about calculation. About image management. About the terrifying power of someone who always seems helpful when tragedy strikes.

Because sometimes the most dangerous person in the room… is the one dialing for help.

🎙️ Listen now to uncover the motive, the manipulation, and the mindset behind one of the most disturbing poison murder cases in recent history.

#DeadlyIntent #TrueCrime #StaceyCastor #BlackWidow #TrueCrimePodcast #PoisonMurder #CriminalPsychology #AntifreezePoisoning #ForensicAnalysis #911Call #CrimePodcast #WomenWhoKill #MurderCase #DarkPsychology

EXPLORE MORE SPINE-CHILLING CONTENT:

Freaky Folklore: https://www.eeriecast.com/podcasts/freaky-folklore

Carman's Crypt (Original Horror): https://carmanscrypt.buzzsprout.com

Deadly Intent (True Crime): https://carmancarrion.buzzsprout.com

Destination Terror: https://www.eeriecast.com/podcasts/destination-terror

SUPPORT THE SHOW:

Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/CarmanCarrion

Buy Me a Coffee: https://buymeacoffee.com/carmancarrion

CONNECT WITH CARMAN:

Website: https://www.carman-carrion.com/

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CarmanCarrion

Twitter/X: https://x.com/CarmanCarrion

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/carmancarrion/

SUBSCRIBE & REVIEW:

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0uiX155WEJnN7QVRfo3aQY

iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/freaky-folklore/id1550361184

Your support helps bring you more terrifying tales!

DISCOVER MORE HORROR: http://eeriecast.com/

https://www.carman-carrion.com/

Crypt Shop: https: //the-crypt-shop-2.myshopify.com/

MUSIC CREDITS:

Music and sound effects provided by: CO.AG, Myuu, Jinglepunks, Epidemic Sound, Kevin MacLeod, Dark Music, and Soundstripe.