Shame Doesn’t Teach: A Better Way for Parents, Teachers & Carers

In this powerful solo episode of the Able to Care Podcast, host Andy Baker explores why shame—while still commonly used to manage behaviour in homes, classrooms, and care settings—often does more harm than good. From outdated scripts to emotional reactions, we dive into how shame suppresses learning, damages trust, and diminishes self-esteem in children and adults alike.

Whether you’re a teacher, parent, or carer, this episode offers practical insights on how to shift away from shame-based responses and towards compassionate, constructive behaviour support.

💡 Sponsor: Carers Card UK

This episode is proudly sponsored by Carers Card UK, the UK’s number one carers card offering discounts, support, and community for paid and unpaid carers.

✨ For less than the price of a box of chocolates a year, members get: ✅ Discounts on gyms, days out, clothes, glasses & more ✅ A wellbeing hub and the Carers Circle app ✅ An ID card that unlocks emergency info and shows you care

👉 Get your Carers Card here: 🔗 https://www.carerscarduk.co.uk/promocode/abletocare

🛠️ Resources Mentioned

📖 Targeting the Positive: A Practical Guide to Understanding and Supporting Challenging Behaviours by Andy Baker 🔗 Able Training

🔑 Key Messages

1. Shame doesn’t teach — it suppresses: Labelling children or adults as “naughty” or “bad” can damage their self-esteem and block emotional growth.

2. Short-term compliance isn’t long-term learning: Shame may stop behaviour in the moment, but it doesn’t foster understanding, empathy, or reflection.

3. Teach through connection, not condemnation: Use natural consequences, curiosity, and reflection to guide behaviour positively and sustainably.

⏳ Timestamps (Chapters)

00:00 – Why calling a child “naughty” can be harmful 01:11 – 🎧 Sponsor: Carers Card UK 02:18 – The psychology of shame and learned helplessness 03:48 – Real-world examples: classrooms, care homes, and parenting 05:03 – The long-term damage of shame on self-esteem 06:22 – Shame breeds secrecy, not growth 07:02 – Shame breaks trust and emotional connection 07:45 – Why shame persists and how it's emotionally reactive 08:35 – Instant compliance vs. authentic behaviour change 09:36 – Fight, flight, freeze: How shame becomes an emotional weapon 10:40 – How to replace shame with restorative practice and empathy 11:52 – Use natural consequences, not humiliation 12:56 – Respond with curiosity, not condemnation 13:50 – Repair and reflect after behaviour, not reprimand 14:46 – The myth of “not enough discipline” and the call for connection 15:40 – What kind of society are we really building with shame?

🎧 Why Listen to This Episode?

This episode is a must-listen for: ✔ Parents navigating challenging behaviour ✔ Teachers balancing emotional needs and discipline in the classroom ✔ Carers supporting individuals with emotional or behavioural distress

You’ll walk away with practical ways to support behaviour through empathy, growth mindset, and restorative connection—instead of outdated shame-based tools.

🔗 Connect with Us

📲 Instagram: @AbleTraining 📲 LinkedIn: Able Training 📲 TikTok: @AbleToCarePodcast 🌐 Website: AbleHub.uk

🎧 If you found this episode helpful, please subscribe, share it with someone who needs to hear it, and leave a review. Let’s create a world where behaviour is understood—not shamed.